Unclear if rare metals can be extracted

Rare earth metals are being highlighted by Donald Trump as the trump card for continued support to Ukraine. But if they exist in the Ukrainian mineral-rich soil – and can be extracted – is uncertain. It's not something you do overnight, says expert Alireza Malehmir.

» Published: February 23 2025

Unclear if rare metals can be extracted
Photo: Efrem Lukatsky/AP/TT

Rare earth metals have come into focus as the USA wants to make a deal with Ukraine, where US President Donald Trump wants compensation for his support to Ukraine.

Ukraine has around five percent of the world's mineral deposits and ranks 40th among the world's mineral-producing countries, according to World mining data from last year. The country tops the world lists when it comes to iron, manganese, titanium, and graphite.

However, a lot of exploration is required to know if the country has extractable finds of the 17 elements classified as rare earth metals, according to Alireza Malehmir, professor of applied geophysics at Uppsala University.

Often, they are found together with other minerals that are then dominant – such as iron.

To be able to say that you have rare earth metals, you must first find the main raw material. Ukraine has that, so there may be potential, says Malehmir.

Highly Uncertain

But if they can be found, how large the finds are and whether they can be extracted is currently highly uncertain. Moreover, peace in the country is required to make the enormous infrastructure investments needed to begin extraction.

For example, in Sweden and globally, from the time you find evidence to the time you start mining – with all environmental considerations, access to water, and qualified personnel – it usually takes five to ten years.

He believes that the USA is primarily interested in critical minerals, such as lithium and titanium, which are already being extracted in Ukraine. They are important for modern technology, just like rare earth metals.

"Some Confusion"

I think there is some confusion, Ukraine has critical minerals but not rare earth metals in that sense. They certainly have lithium and some rare earth metals, but several other countries have that, he says, emphasizing the difference between what is known to exist and what may exist in the ground, says Malehmir.

Trump is said to have demanded rare earth metals worth $500 billion. Alireza Malehmir compares the sum to the $200 billion that the world's largest mining companies are worth – together.

With $500 billion, you could invest a lot. You could take over copper production worldwide.

Rare earth metals are a group of elements, including:

Lanthanum (La), cerium (Ce), praseodymium (Pr), neodymium (Nd), promethium (Pm), samarium (Sm), europium (Eu), gadolinium (Gd), terbium (Tb), dysprosium (Dy), holmium (Ho), erbium (Er), thulium (Tm), ytterbium (Yb), and lutetium (Lu).

Sometimes, scandium (Sc) and yttrium (Y) are also included.

The group is often abbreviated as REE, after the English term rare-earth elements.

Source: Swedish Geological Survey

Tags

TTT
By TTTranslated and adapted by Sweden Herald

More news

Friedrich Merz Begins EU Tour with Key Meetings in France and Poland
3 MIN READ

Friedrich Merz Begins EU Tour with Key Meetings in France and Poland

Russian Drone Attacks on Kyiv Kill Two, Injure Eight
1 MIN READ

Russian Drone Attacks on Kyiv Kill Two, Injure Eight

Cardinals Gather to Elect New Pope in Vatican Conclave
4 MIN READ

Cardinals Gather to Elect New Pope in Vatican Conclave

Over 30 Dead in Israeli Strike on Gaza School
1 MIN READ

Over 30 Dead in Israeli Strike on Gaza School

China and UN Call for Restraint in Kashmir Tensions
1 MIN READ

China and UN Call for Restraint in Kashmir Tensions

India-Pakistan Kashmir Conflict Escalates with Deadly Attacks
3 MIN READ

India-Pakistan Kashmir Conflict Escalates with Deadly Attacks

US Closes Jerusalem Office for Palestinian Affairs
1 MIN READ

US Closes Jerusalem Office for Palestinian Affairs

India Seeks to Halt Auction of Gemstones Found with Buddha's Remains
2 MIN READ

India Seeks to Halt Auction of Gemstones Found with Buddha's Remains

Can Friedrich Merz Build a Strong Relationship with Trump on the Golf Course
3 MIN READ

Can Friedrich Merz Build a Strong Relationship with Trump on the Golf Course

Carney Urges Trump to Stop Calling Canada the 51st State
2 MIN READ

Carney Urges Trump to Stop Calling Canada the 51st State

Putin and Xi to Discuss Ukraine War in Moscow Before Victory Day Parade
1 MIN READ

Putin and Xi to Discuss Ukraine War in Moscow Before Victory Day Parade

Trump Claims Houthi Militia Surrender After US-Israel Attack on Yemen
2 MIN READ

Trump Claims Houthi Militia Surrender After US-Israel Attack on Yemen

Indonesia Bus Crash Leaves at Least 12 Dead
1 MIN READ

Indonesia Bus Crash Leaves at Least 12 Dead

Ukraine and Russia Conduct Major Prisoner Exchange
1 MIN READ

Ukraine and Russia Conduct Major Prisoner Exchange

Israeli Finance Minister Calls for Destruction of Gaza Strip
1 MIN READ

Israeli Finance Minister Calls for Destruction of Gaza Strip

Thailand Closes Phu Chi Fa Viewpoint After Laos Drug Clash
1 MIN READ

Thailand Closes Phu Chi Fa Viewpoint After Laos Drug Clash

Gaza's Ongoing Crisis: Desperation Amid Bombings and Shortages
2 MIN READ

Gaza's Ongoing Crisis: Desperation Amid Bombings and Shortages

EU Parliament to Honor Supporters of European Values with New Award
1 MIN READ

EU Parliament to Honor Supporters of European Values with New Award

German Bundestag Rejects Merz as Chancellor, Signaling Discontent
2 MIN READ

German Bundestag Rejects Merz as Chancellor, Signaling Discontent

Brussels Outrage Over Racist Hooligan Attack After Belgian Cup Final
1 MIN READ

Brussels Outrage Over Racist Hooligan Attack After Belgian Cup Final