Word choices and guarantees – a difficult path to a ceasefire

The negotiations about a ceasefire in the Gaza War are dragging on as the parties weigh their words on a gold scale. After several weeks where both Israel and Hamas have given contradictory statements, a comprehensive agreement is said to be near.

» Updated: July 16 2024

» Published: July 04 2024

Word choices and guarantees – a difficult path to a ceasefire
Photo: Leo Correa/AP/TT

Negotiations on a ceasefire in the Gaza War are dragging on as the parties weigh their words on a gold scale.

After several weeks where both Israel and Hamas have given contradictory messages, a comprehensive agreement is said to be near.

Reports in American media suggest that Israel and the Palestinian extremist movement Hamas are close to agreeing on the framework for a ceasefire agreement.

It has almost been a month since the UN Security Council, after much deliberation, voted for a resolution on a ceasefire.

Neither Israel nor Hamas seems to have accepted it, and during ongoing negotiations, the US is reported to have rewritten several formulations, primarily concerning how a "lasting peace" can be achieved.

Negotiated for months

The two sides in the war have made incompatible demands. Negotiations have been ongoing alongside intense warfare against besieged Gaza, where tens of thousands of people have been killed, with the exception of a week-long ceasefire in November.

Israel has said that the war will continue at least until all hostages held in Gaza are released. Hamas has said that the hostages will only be released if the parties agree on a more permanent end to the war. If and when the movement releases the hostages, it will have played its most valuable card from a negotiating perspective.

Mediation attempts have broken down time and again. Israel has insisted on formulations that do not necessarily rule out future interventions in Gaza. Hamas has demanded clear commitments with international guarantees.

Pressure from many sides

The day after the Security Council voted for the ceasefire proposal, Hamas said it accepted it, but it turned out to be with several reservations and was therefore interpreted as a de facto no.

Israel was said to be behind the proposal, but the Israeli government has not acknowledged it.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is under heavy pressure from opposition leaders, military leaders, relatives of hostages, and street demonstrators who accuse him of delaying a solution. He is also being pressured by a right-wing extremist government base that demands a more uncompromising war effort.

At Israel's northern border, there is also a threat of escalation and war against the Lebanese Shia militia Hezbollah.

Needs green light

To accept the overall framework for an agreement, Netanyahu needs to give the green light.

So does someone on the opposing side – and it is not entirely clear how much consensus there is between Hamas' political exiled leader in Qatar and its top leader in Gaza, the wanted Yahya Sinwar.

If the negotiations continue, it is expected to take several more weeks to resolve many difficult detail issues.

The ceasefire proposal presented to the UN Security Council was drafted by the US and subsequently adopted as a resolution. The proposal involved a three-phase scaling down.

The first phase would last six weeks and involve a complete ceasefire, the withdrawal of Israeli forces from "all populated areas in the Gaza Strip", and the exchange of a number of hostages for hundreds of Palestinian prisoners.

Phase two was said to be dependent on the parties first agreeing on "necessary arrangements". But if that were to happen, it would mean a permanent end to hostilities, the release of all remaining living hostages, and the withdrawal of all Israeli forces from the Gaza Strip.

In the third phase, the remains of hostages who are no longer alive would also be returned, and a comprehensive reconstruction plan would be launched.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Russian Drone Attack on Dnipro Leaves Four Dead, Many Injured

Yemen's Huthi Movement Accuses US
1 MIN READ

Yemen's Huthi Movement Accuses US of Airstrikes on Sanaa

Damascus Lifts Alcohol Ban in
1 MIN READ

Damascus Lifts Alcohol Ban in Christian Quarters After Protests

Zelensky Open to Peace Talks
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Open to Peace Talks with Russia, Excluding Putin

South Sudan's Vice President Riek
1 MIN READ

South Sudan's Vice President Riek Machar Placed Under House Arrest

Trump and Canada's Carney Report
2 MIN READ

Trump and Canada's Carney Report Productive Talks on US-Canada Relations

Ukraine Recovers 909 Soldiers' Remains
1 MIN READ

Ukraine Recovers 909 Soldiers' Remains from Russian Conflict

Frederiksen Calls Vance's Criticism of
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Calls Vance's Criticism of Denmark Unfair During Greenland Visit

Greenland's New Government Aims for
2 MIN READ

Greenland's New Government Aims for Stability and Unity

Bangkok Skyscraper Collapse Caught on
1 MIN READ

Bangkok Skyscraper Collapse Caught on Camera in 30 Seconds

Putin and Erdogan Talk Black
1 MIN READ

Putin and Erdogan Talk Black Sea Deal and Sanctions Relief

Denmark Proposes Defense Pact with
2 MIN READ

Denmark Proposes Defense Pact with US Amid Diplomatic Tensions

Myanmar Earthquake Adds to Struggles
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Adds to Struggles in War-Torn Nation

Seismologist Warns of Severe Impact
1 MIN READ

Seismologist Warns of Severe Impact After Myanmar Earthquake

Russian Strikes Hit Ukrainian Energy
1 MIN READ

Russian Strikes Hit Ukrainian Energy Sites as Ceasefire Talks Falter

Swedes in Bangkok Share Earthquake
3 MIN READ

Swedes in Bangkok Share Earthquake Fears as City Grapples with Aftershocks

Istanbul Mayor's Lawyer Arrested in
1 MIN READ

Istanbul Mayor's Lawyer Arrested in Turkey, Sparking Outcry

Myanmar Earthquake: Over 150 Dead,
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake: Over 150 Dead, Thousands Feared Lost

US Vice President Visits Greenland
2 MIN READ

US Vice President Visits Greenland Base as Tensions Simmer

Greenlanders Anxious Over US Interest
3 MIN READ

Greenlanders Anxious Over US Interest as Trump Sparks Debate

US VP Visit to Greenland
2 MIN READ

US VP Visit to Greenland Base Sparks Tension and Uncertainty

Canada's New PM Carney Declares
1 MIN READ

Canada's New PM Carney Declares Shift in US Relations

Seized Superyacht Linked to Money
1 MIN READ

Seized Superyacht Linked to Money Laundering Fetches 108 Million

Rubio Warns Venezuela Against Aggression
1 MIN READ

Rubio Warns Venezuela Against Aggression Towards Guyana

Judge Orders Preservation of Leaked
1 MIN READ

Judge Orders Preservation of Leaked Chat on Yemen Discussions

King Charles Hospitalized for Observation
1 MIN READ

King Charles Hospitalized for Observation Due to Treatment Side Effects

Iran Replies to Trump's Nuclear
1 MIN READ

Iran Replies to Trump's Nuclear Energy Letter via Oman

Belgium Probes 40+ Drink-Spiking Rape
1 MIN READ

Belgium Probes 40+ Drink-Spiking Rape Cases in Kortrijk Bars

Denmark Eases Health Criteria to
1 MIN READ

Denmark Eases Health Criteria to Boost Defense Recruitment

Four Parties Form New Coalition
1 MIN READ

Four Parties Form New Coalition in Greenland's Government

Prosecutors Seek Seven-Year Sentence for
1 MIN READ

Prosecutors Seek Seven-Year Sentence for Sarkozy in Libyan Funds Case

Just Stop Oil Ends High-Profile
2 MIN READ

Just Stop Oil Ends High-Profile Protests After Achieving Goals

Putin Warns US Intent on
1 MIN READ

Putin Warns US Intent on Greenland is Serious

Zelensky Urges US to Respond
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Urges US to Respond to Alleged Russian Ceasefire Violations

Five Injured in Central Amsterdam
1 MIN READ

Five Injured in Central Amsterdam Knife Attack

UN Warns Gaza's Food Supplies
1 MIN READ

UN Warns Gaza's Food Supplies May Run Out in Two Weeks

US Health Authority Restructures, Cutting
1 MIN READ

US Health Authority Restructures, Cutting 10,000 Jobs

Macron Announces International Support Force
2 MIN READ

Macron Announces International Support Force Plan for Ukraine

Pope Francis Plans to Deliver
1 MIN READ

Pope Francis Plans to Deliver Easter Blessing Despite Health Concerns

Swede Among Survivors After Submarine
2 MIN READ

Swede Among Survivors After Submarine Sinks in Egypt's Red Sea