After 200 Years of Controversy: How Humans Wiped Out the Giant Animals

Not so very long ago, at the end of the last ice age, the earth was full of large animals – mammoths, mastodons, giant sloths and giant rodents. Then they suddenly disappeared completely. Now researchers are establishing that they were wiped out by humans.

» Published: July 27 2024

After 200 Years of Controversy: How Humans Wiped Out the Giant Animals
Photo: American Museum of Natural History/TT

Not so long ago, at the end of the last ice age, the Earth was full of large animals – mammoths, mastodons, giant ground sloths, and giant rodents. Then they suddenly disappeared. Now researchers have found that they were wiped out by humans.

In total, 46 species of large land-dwelling mammals – species weighing 1,000 kilos or more – disappeared from the Earth's surface over the past 50,000 years. In Europe, North America, South America, Australia, and northern Asia, it became eerily empty – no giant animals were left after the extinction.

Only in Africa and southern Asia did smaller remnants of the megafauna manage to survive – a total of eleven species – including the present-day elephants and rhinos.

Among the extinct species are twelve elephant-like animals: mammoths, mastodons, stegodons, gomphotheres, and others. Four rhino species died out, as did the massive toxodons in South America and the giant camel Camelops in North America.

Perhaps most remarkable among the wiped-out giants were the giant ground sloths in North and South America, a total of 16 species of gigantic, ground-dwelling relatives of the present-day sloths. Additionally, four species of giant armadillos, also from North and South America, disappeared. They were heavily armored and could weigh two tons, more than a Volkswagen Beetle.

Sabertoothed Cats

But the mass extinction did not only affect species weighing a ton or more. Species weighing 50 kilos or more also took an exceptionally hard hit, including several horse-like animals, camels, and oxen, as well as the enormous giant deer in Europe. A long list of large predators also died out, including all sabertoothed cats, the giant lion, the American lion, the terror wolf, and the massive short-nosed bear.

In total, 161 species of large mammals died out on Earth during this geologically short period. It lasted for around 40,000 years and was, in principle, completed 10,000 years ago at the end of the last ice age.

What happened? Researchers have debated the problem for over 200 years without being able to agree, but two hypotheses have been dominant. Either the megafauna was wiped out by climate change, or – which has been controversial – humans, the Ice Age hunters, were responsible.

Some researchers have been reluctant to point out our own species, our own ancestors. It is not possible, they argue, that a few thousand humans armed with spears could have had such a devastating effect on the fauna. Moreover, there are not particularly many archaeological traces of that type of hunting.

Humans Responsible

But in a new study in the scientific journal Extinction, researchers led by Danish biologist Jens-Christian Svenning at the University of Aarhus have compiled all available facts on the subject and concluded that climate change must be ruled out as a factor. Humans were largely responsible for the mass extinction. Paleontologist Lars Werdelin at the National Museum in Stockholm thinks the compilation is quite convincing:

I have always advocated that the extinction was due to multiple causes, but now I am leaning more towards humans being the main factor, he says.

The fact that there are not particularly many traces of human hunting is no argument. Such traces are always rare.

The extinction occurred at different times on different continents, in Australia around 50,000 years ago, and in Europe and northern Asia over a longer period from 50,000 to 10,000 years ago – although the woolly mammoth lived on until 4,000 years ago on Wrangel Island. In North America, the extinction occurred with sudden abruptness starting 14,000 years ago, and then spread to South America where the last giant animals disappeared 7,000 years ago.

During this period, the climate changed dramatically. Large inland ice sheets covered parts of the northern hemisphere, followed by periods of warmer climate. But the extinction does not follow the climate changes. And the changes were just as dramatic at earlier stages during the ice age – without causing any extinctions.

Ecological Disaster

The most convincing evidence that humans were ultimately responsible is the selectivity of the extinction. No small mammals died out, only the large species – the ones that were huntable.

Tellingly, the disappearance of the animals coincides with the modern human, Homo sapiens, invading the different continents. Our species originated in Africa and spread to southern Asia and Australia 60,000–50,000 years ago. Northern Eurasia was conquered somewhat later, and even later, around 20,000 years ago, humans arrived in western hemisphere. The extinction generally occurred shortly after humans arrived.

The study notes that the loss of megafauna must have had significant ecological consequences, as large mammals play a central role in shaping vegetation structure, seed dispersal, and nutrient cycling.

It's not just about killing. Humans started fires and had a significant impact on vegetation. The flora changed, which in turn changed the fauna, says Werdelin.

In contrast to other continents, large parts of the megafauna survived in Africa, including the present-day elephants and rhinos. The reason is believed to be that humans originated in Africa, and the fauna on the continent thus had time to adapt gradually to the new dangerous predator.

On other continents, however, the animals had no opportunity for such adaptation. But interestingly, humans had a negative impact on the African fauna at an earlier point in history. It was when the Homo genus began to develop towards larger species two million years ago, and Homo erectus emerged on the scene. Apparently, the species competed out the sabertoothed cats in Africa, leading to their extinction 1.5 million years ago from the continent, much earlier than on other continents.

Source: Ecology Letters

The Ice Age, Pleistocene, is the name of a series of glaciations, interrupted by shorter warm periods, interglacials, which began 2.58 million years ago and is still ongoing. In popular parlance, however, "the Ice Age" refers only to the most recent glaciation, which began 115,000 years ago and ended 11,700 years ago when the current interglacial began.

The last Ice Age is not the only one in Earth's history. At least four times, large parts of the globe have been covered by massive ice sheets.

Source: Journal of Quaternary Science

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Suspected Hazardous Object Found in Malmö Vehicle Prompts Police Response

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of
1 MIN READ

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of Sami Truth Commission

Tony's Chocolonely Recalls Chocolate Over
1 MIN READ

Tony's Chocolonely Recalls Chocolate Over Stone Contamination Risk

Sweden Expands Conscription Eligibility with
1 MIN READ

Sweden Expands Conscription Eligibility with Streamlined Process

Suspect Detained in Uddevalla Mosque
1 MIN READ

Suspect Detained in Uddevalla Mosque Fire Investigation

Critics Urge Sweden to Scrap
2 MIN READ

Critics Urge Sweden to Scrap Proposal on Lifestyle-Based Permit Revocation

Swedes Enjoy Longer Lives but
2 MIN READ

Swedes Enjoy Longer Lives but Face Growing Health Inequality

Stockholm Region's Journalist Register Sparks
2 MIN READ

Stockholm Region's Journalist Register Sparks Privacy Concerns

Woman Hospitalized After Attempted Murder
1 MIN READ

Woman Hospitalized After Attempted Murder in Örsundsbro, Suspect Arrested

Journalist Joakim Medin Declares from
2 MIN READ

Journalist Joakim Medin Declares from Turkish Prison: Journalism Is Not a Crime

Fredrick Federley Eyes Return to
1 MIN READ

Fredrick Federley Eyes Return to Center Party Politics in Sweden

Kristersson: Swedish Efforts Intensify for
1 MIN READ

Kristersson: Swedish Efforts Intensify for Journalist's Release in Turkey

Nina Larsson Steps In as
2 MIN READ

Nina Larsson Steps In as Sweden's New Gender Equality Minister

75-Year-Old Woman Arrested in Ale
1 MIN READ

75-Year-Old Woman Arrested in Ale for Suspected Murder of Elderly Man

New Blood Marker Tracks Alzheimer's
2 MIN READ

New Blood Marker Tracks Alzheimer's Progression, Aiding Drug Approval

Stefan Löfven Leaves Facebook Citing
1 MIN READ

Stefan Löfven Leaves Facebook Citing Concerns Over Democracy

Sweden to Announce New Minister
1 MIN READ

Sweden to Announce New Minister for Gender Equality and Labor Market

Region Skåne to Pay 80
1 MIN READ

Region Skåne to Pay 80 Million Kronor in Ambulance Dispute Settlement

Greta Thunberg Removed by Police
1 MIN READ

Greta Thunberg Removed by Police During Stockholm Climate Protest

Man in His 50s Killed
1 MIN READ

Man in His 50s Killed by Falling Beam in Mölndal Workplace Accident

Swedish Teen Sentenced to 8
1 MIN READ

Swedish Teen Sentenced to 8 Years in Denmark for Attempted Murder

Sweden Considers Deportation for Misbehavior
3 MIN READ

Sweden Considers Deportation for Misbehavior Under New Proposal

Man Arrested in Norrköping Murder
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested in Norrköping Murder Investigation

Death in Fjärås Ruled Non-Criminal
1 MIN READ

Death in Fjärås Ruled Non-Criminal After Investigation

Swedish Armed Forces Ordered to
1 MIN READ

Swedish Armed Forces Ordered to Pay for PFAS Cleanup in Uppsala

Swedish Man Charged in Copenhagen
1 MIN READ

Swedish Man Charged in Copenhagen Murder Disguised as Courier

Gender Gap in Sick Leave:
3 MIN READ

Gender Gap in Sick Leave: Women Face Double Workload Challenges

Sweden's April Fools' Day: Elk
2 MIN READ

Sweden's April Fools' Day: Elk Cavalry and Studio Swap Pranks

Sweden Ends Spruce Bark Beetle
2 MIN READ

Sweden Ends Spruce Bark Beetle Control as Threat Diminishes

Drought Shifts Earth's Axis and
3 MIN READ

Drought Shifts Earth's Axis and Raises Sea Levels, Study Finds

Örebro Doctor Sentenced to 7
1 MIN READ

Örebro Doctor Sentenced to 7 Years for Sexual Assaults on Patients

Swedish Journalist's Detention in Turkey
1 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist's Detention in Turkey Raises Legal Concerns

Woman Hospitalized After Villa Fire
1 MIN READ

Woman Hospitalized After Villa Fire Near Älvsbyn

Sölvesborg Man in Custody for
1 MIN READ

Sölvesborg Man in Custody for Alleged Online Child Sex Crimes

Report Highlights High Rates of
1 MIN READ

Report Highlights High Rates of Relationship Violence Among Young Girls

Hedgehogs Reveal High Lead and
1 MIN READ

Hedgehogs Reveal High Lead and Pollutant Levels in Swedish Study

Skåne Region Ends Krys Contract,
1 MIN READ

Skåne Region Ends Krys Contract, Seeks 19 Million Kronor Refund

Summer House Buyers Urged to
3 MIN READ

Summer House Buyers Urged to Consider Climate Risks in Sweden

Truck Collision in Sweden Sparks
1 MIN READ

Truck Collision in Sweden Sparks Drunk Driving Investigation

Kristersson Praises Brandberg's Efforts on
1 MIN READ

Kristersson Praises Brandberg's Efforts on Gender Equality and Safety