Warning of more surveillance with new cyber treaty

More effective combating of cybercrime – or a step towards more surveillance and oppression? Opinions are divided on the UN's first treaty against cybercrime, which has now been approved.

» Published: August 09 2024

Warning of more surveillance with new cyber treaty
Photo: Tim Aro/TT

Share this article

After three years of negotiations, Faouzia Boumaiza Mebarki, Algerian diplomat and chair of the committee that drafted the proposal, announced that the UN Convention against Cybercrime has now been approved.

The committee was appointed following a Russian initiative in 2017 – despite American and European opposition.

The treaty, whose purpose is to "prevent and combat cybercrime more effectively", is now being submitted to the UN General Assembly for consideration. It will come into force after being ratified by 40 member states. The idea is that it will specifically focus on preventing child pornography and money laundering.

Much criticism

However, critics – an unusual combination of human rights activists and large tech companies – believe that the treaty could be used to monitor and suppress people on a global scale.

In particular, it is pointed out that a state, according to the treaty, can request electronic evidence related to a suspected crime from another country's authorities, and even request information from internet service providers, if the crime can be punished with at least four years' imprisonment in the country.

The treaty is in fact a legal instrument for oppression. It can be used against journalists, activists, LGBTQI people, free thinkers, and others across borders, says Deborah Brown from Human Rights Watch.

"Harmful"

Nick Ashton-Hart, who leads a delegation representing over 100 tech companies, including Meta and Microsoft, is urging member states not to ratify the convention.

The convention will be harmful to the digital environment in general and human rights in particular, everywhere it is adopted, he says.

At the same time, several nations, including Russia and Iran, have complained that the treaty contains too many safeguards for human rights.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Trump Deploys 10 F-35 Fighter Jets to Puerto Rico Amid Drug War
2 MIN READ

Trump Deploys 10 F-35 Fighter Jets to Puerto Rico Amid Drug War

WHO Declares Mpox No Longer a Global Health Crisis
1 MIN READ

WHO Declares Mpox No Longer a Global Health Crisis

Sweden's Foreign Minister Meets Zelenskyj to Boost Pressure on Russia
1 MIN READ

Sweden's Foreign Minister Meets Zelenskyj to Boost Pressure on Russia

IAGS Faces Backlash Over Gaza Genocide Resolution
4 MIN READ

IAGS Faces Backlash Over Gaza Genocide Resolution

UK Government Reshuffle: Angela Rayner Resigns, David Lammy Becomes Justice Minister
2 MIN READ

UK Government Reshuffle: Angela Rayner Resigns, David Lammy Becomes Justice Minister

Israeli Military Targets Gaza High-Rises Used by Hamas
1 MIN READ

Israeli Military Targets Gaza High-Rises Used by Hamas

UN Report: Congo Violence Could Be War Crimes
1 MIN READ

UN Report: Congo Violence Could Be War Crimes

Anutin Charnvirakul Elected as Thailand's New Prime Minister
1 MIN READ

Anutin Charnvirakul Elected as Thailand's New Prime Minister

Finland Joins UN Declaration for Peaceful Gaza Solution
1 MIN READ

Finland Joins UN Declaration for Peaceful Gaza Solution

Hamas Releases New Video of Israeli Hostage Guy Gilboa-Dalal
2 MIN READ

Hamas Releases New Video of Israeli Hostage Guy Gilboa-Dalal

Florida Moves to End All Vaccine Mandates
2 MIN READ

Florida Moves to End All Vaccine Mandates

Lisbon Cable Car Accident: Victims Identified, Three-Year-Old Survives
1 MIN READ

Lisbon Cable Car Accident: Victims Identified, Three-Year-Old Survives

Russia Delivers Humanitarian Aid to Afghanistan After Earthquake
1 MIN READ

Russia Delivers Humanitarian Aid to Afghanistan After Earthquake

USA Adds Ecuadorian Gangs Los Lobos and Los Choneros to Terror List
1 MIN READ

USA Adds Ecuadorian Gangs Los Lobos and Los Choneros to Terror List

Suspected Madeleine McCann Case Figure to Be Released from German Prison
2 MIN READ

Suspected Madeleine McCann Case Figure to Be Released from German Prison

Trump Proposes Renaming Defense Department to Ministry of War
1 MIN READ

Trump Proposes Renaming Defense Department to Ministry of War

Bolsonaro Faces Court Over Alleged Plot to Poison Rival Lula
3 MIN READ

Bolsonaro Faces Court Over Alleged Plot to Poison Rival Lula

Putin: Western Forces in Ukraine Are Legitimate Targets
2 MIN READ

Putin: Western Forces in Ukraine Are Legitimate Targets

Norway Returns Rare Roman Coin to France After Theft Allegations
1 MIN READ

Norway Returns Rare Roman Coin to France After Theft Allegations

Venezuelan Jets Fly Over US Ship Amid Tensions
1 MIN READ

Venezuelan Jets Fly Over US Ship Amid Tensions