Ethical dilemmas when AI revives deceased celebrities

Judy Garland and James Dean read audiobooks and can already be cloned with AI. But more and more actors are worried that the new technology can be abused.

» Published: July 23 2024

Ethical dilemmas when AI revives deceased celebrities
Photo: Pressens bild/TT

Judy Garland and James Dean read audiobooks and can already be cloned with AI. But more and more actors are worried that the new technology can be misused.

"What are you going to do with my body and my face when I'm dead? I don't want you to do anything!", said actor Nicolas Cage in an interview with Huffington Post.

AI was a major issue during the Hollywood strike in 2023 and continues to be debated – recently after the news of an app from Eleven Labs, where Judy Garland and James Dean can read out, for example, audiobooks. Dean, who died in a car crash in 1955, is soon also current with his digital image in a new film with the title "Back to Eden".

"Counteracts diversity"

The problem is that it builds on what has already been done and seen – the AI-generated material creates nothing new – but maybe it's "good enough". So it often counteracts innovation and diversity, says Simon Norrthon, chairman of the trade union Scen & Film.

According to him, the new AI development leads to moral and ethical dilemmas for our perception of reality.

Even if we know that a voice is AI-generated, we are still easy to manipulate, and we can still experience that this person actually said something that AI has made them say.

Norrthon also believes that clearer legislation is on the way.

Maybe not necessarily to protect actors, but rather to protect civilians and those in power so that we can know who has said what.

Earlier this year, film star Scarlett Johansson got into a conflict with the company Open AI, after they launched an AI voice that had striking similarities to her voiceover in the film "Her". Johansson described "deep fake" technology in general as "a dark hole you can never climb out of".

"Hottest potato"

Sanna Thiel, a lawyer at the industry organization Film & TV Producers, describes the AI issue as "the hottest potato in the copyright area" and sees both opportunities, challenges, and risks with the technology. An AI tool could, for example, be instructed to write a script or create a film in the same style as a certain author or a certain film.

It is likely that a script or a film that comes out of an AI tool in most cases does not constitute an infringement of an existing work – a style or a manner is not protected by copyright. But the knowledge and information that enable the AI tool's creation have been acquired through training on existing works – such training must be possible for rights holders to oppose.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Olympic Champion Sarah Sjöström First
2 MIN READ

Olympic Champion Sarah Sjöström First Out on Masked Singer Sweden

Zelda Film Set for 2027
1 MIN READ

Zelda Film Set for 2027 Release with Live-Action Adventure

Trump's Cultural Moves Mirror Putin's
2 MIN READ

Trump's Cultural Moves Mirror Putin's Tactics, Expert Warns

Frida Edman Takes the Helm
1 MIN READ

Frida Edman Takes the Helm at Gothenburg City Theatre

Diary of a Wimpy Kid
1 MIN READ

Diary of a Wimpy Kid Series Surpasses 300 Million Copies Sold

Sanna Samuelsson Wins Swedish Radio's
1 MIN READ

Sanna Samuelsson Wins Swedish Radio's Short Story Prize

Iron Maiden's Bruce Dickinson Releases
1 MIN READ

Iron Maiden's Bruce Dickinson Releases Book with Blake's Grave Soil

Indian Film Debut Shines: All
3 MIN READ

Indian Film Debut Shines: All We Imagine as Light Hits Swedish Cinemas

Kaliffa Launches 31-Stop Summer Tour
1 MIN READ

Kaliffa Launches 31-Stop Summer Tour Across Sweden and Mariehamn

Norén Brothers Tour Continues Without
2 MIN READ

Norén Brothers Tour Continues Without Gustaf as Viktor Leads with Guest Artists

Kent's Legacy Lives On with
1 MIN READ

Kent's Legacy Lives On with Fresh Takes by Emerging Artists

Gorillaz Set to Release New
1 MIN READ

Gorillaz Set to Release New Album in 2025, Confirms Damon Albarn

Paul Lynch's Novel Explores Collapse
4 MIN READ

Paul Lynch's Novel Explores Collapse of Democracy and Human Resilience

Camilla Läckberg Opens Up Family
3 MIN READ

Camilla Läckberg Opens Up Family Life in New Reality Series

Swedish Artists Rally Against Rehearsal
2 MIN READ

Swedish Artists Rally Against Rehearsal Room Closures

Mia Skäringer Returns as Ann-Marie
3 MIN READ

Mia Skäringer Returns as Ann-Marie in New SVT Series Choosing Joy

Trump Targets Museums to Remove
1 MIN READ

Trump Targets Museums to Remove Divisive Narratives and Ideologies

Kent's Farewell Concerts Set New
3 MIN READ

Kent's Farewell Concerts Set New Attendance Record in Stockholm

Sweden's KAJ to Perform Sixth
2 MIN READ

Sweden's KAJ to Perform Sixth in Eurovision Semi-Final 1

Salman Rushdie Unveils New Short
2 MIN READ

Salman Rushdie Unveils New Short Story Collection This November

Benjamin Ingrosso Shines with Three
4 MIN READ

Benjamin Ingrosso Shines with Three Wins at Sweden's Grammis Awards

Sundance Film Festival to Relocate
1 MIN READ

Sundance Film Festival to Relocate from Park City to Boulder in 2027

Reindeer Fawn Leads Bafta Nominations
1 MIN READ

Reindeer Fawn Leads Bafta Nominations with Eight Nods

Afro-Swedish Archive Creator and Cultural
1 MIN READ

Afro-Swedish Archive Creator and Cultural Innovators Win Prestigious Award

Prosecutor Seeks Therapy and Conditional
2 MIN READ

Prosecutor Seeks Therapy and Conditional Sentence for Depardieu

Hellenius Confirms Masked Singer Unchanged
1 MIN READ

Hellenius Confirms Masked Singer Unchanged Despite Divorce Rumors

Academy of Fine Arts Warns
2 MIN READ

Academy of Fine Arts Warns Against Merging Swedish Art Institutions

Swedish Authors Compete for Nordic
1 MIN READ

Swedish Authors Compete for Nordic Council Children's Literature Prize

Culture Minister Liljestrand Reflects on
1 MIN READ

Culture Minister Liljestrand Reflects on Playful Gothenburg Speech

Algerian-French Author Boualem Sansal Sentenced
1 MIN READ

Algerian-French Author Boualem Sansal Sentenced to Five Years in Prison

Benjamin Ingrosso Leads Grammis Gala
3 MIN READ

Benjamin Ingrosso Leads Grammis Gala with Five Nominations

Abba Voyage Setlist Gets a
1 MIN READ

Abba Voyage Setlist Gets a Refresh for Third Anniversary Celebration

Three Couples Tie the Knot
3 MIN READ

Three Couples Tie the Knot in Swedish Love is Blind Finale

Ultras Documentary Celebrates Passionate Football
3 MIN READ

Ultras Documentary Celebrates Passionate Football Fan Culture

The Magic Flute Debuts in
1 MIN READ

The Magic Flute Debuts in Swedish at Gothenburg Opera This Fall

Miranda Nordqvist Wins Prestigious Jan
1 MIN READ

Miranda Nordqvist Wins Prestigious Jan Wallander Prize

Peter LeMarc's Music Takes the
2 MIN READ

Peter LeMarc's Music Takes the Stage in New Stockholm Theatre Show

Philadelphia Honors Will Smith with
1 MIN READ

Philadelphia Honors Will Smith with Street Naming Ceremony

Zendaya to Star as Ronnie
1 MIN READ

Zendaya to Star as Ronnie Spector in Barry Jenkins' New Film

Lady Gaga Returns to Sweden
1 MIN READ

Lady Gaga Returns to Sweden for Two Stockholm Shows in October