Criticism: No Research Support for New Screen Recommendations

The new screen areas from the Public Health Agency are being criticized by experts. It is not reasonable to set such sharp boundaries based on such a weak foundation, says sociologist Henrik Pallin.

» Published: September 04 2024

Criticism: No Research Support for New Screen Recommendations
Photo: Christine Olsson/TT

The recommendations for children and young people were presented on Monday and include, among other things, that children under two years old should not have any screen time at all and that teenagers should have a maximum of three hours.

Social worker Henrik Pallin, who has written books about young people's internet use, is critical. He claims that the Public Health Agency is going against its own knowledge compilation, which the guidelines are supposed to be based on.

In the knowledge compilation, they are quite clear that they cannot be clear. Based on that, they then land on very sharp boundaries, he says.

"Does not shorten Bup queues"

Henrik Pallin takes overweight as an example.

In the compilation, they explicitly state that it may be the case that if you are overweight, you sit more still and then you are also more inclined to use the screen. But it is not necessarily the case that you became overweight because you used the screen.

Elza Dunkels, internet researcher and associate professor of educational work, believes that there is a lack of research support for the time limits.

Dangers such as stress, anxiety, and distorted self-image cannot be linked to screen use itself, she believes – and thinks that a "false image" was presented at the press conference.

When asked if there are any connections between screen use and physical and mental ill-health, she responds:

"No causal connections. There are no studies that have tried to show such a connection, but none have succeeded", she writes in an email.

Something Henrik Pallin agrees with.

Having unlimited screen time that crowds out other activities is certainly not good. But it's not the case that the queues to Bup will be shortened just because screen time decreases.

It would have been better with solutions than wagging fingers, he says.

Start by following the Public Health Agency's recommendations on how much you should exercise every day, and I think you would have solved many of the problems. But there were no investments in either youth sports, cultural school, or Bup.

Social community

Henrik Pallin also thinks that the Public Health Agency is missing the significance of screens for community.

It's the case that some can be outsiders at school and have their social contacts through their screen. That's not taken up at all, that an enormous sense of belonging can be created through Minecraft, Fortnite, and other platforms.

What is your advice to parents?

That you should get to know your children so that you can set the boundaries that the children deserve. If you're, for example, a girl who plays football four days a week and has an active life, it's no danger to sit four-five hours a day with a screen, he says.

The Public Health Agency's new recommendations for screen time for children and young people:

0-2-year-olds: Ideally no screen time at all.

2-5-year-olds: Maximum 1 hour.

6-12-year-olds: Maximum 1-2 hours.

13-18-year-olds: Maximum 2-3 hours.

+ The recommendations concern leisure-time use, such as social media, video clips, movies, TV, and computer games.

+ Music listening, podcasts, e-books, and school-related screen use are not included in the time limits.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Moved
1 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Moved to High-Security Turkish Prison

SMHI Warns of High Grass
1 MIN READ

SMHI Warns of High Grass Fire Risk in Sweden's Snow-Free Regions

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested
1 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested in Turkey, Press Freedom at Risk

Man in His 30s Found
1 MIN READ

Man in His 30s Found Dead Outdoors in Norrköping; Murder Investigation Launched

Police Car and Fire Truck
1 MIN READ

Police Car and Fire Truck Crash on E4 Injures Officers

Sweden Prioritizes Journalist's Release After
2 MIN READ

Sweden Prioritizes Journalist's Release After Arrest in Turkey

Europol Looks to Sweden for
2 MIN READ

Europol Looks to Sweden for Tackling Digital Gang Crime

Woman Dies After Clothes Catch
1 MIN READ

Woman Dies After Clothes Catch Fire in Strömstad Residence

Spring Warmth to Sweep Sweden
1 MIN READ

Spring Warmth to Sweep Sweden with Temperatures Over 20 Degrees

Prehistoric Wasp Used Plant-Like Trap
3 MIN READ

Prehistoric Wasp Used Plant-Like Trap to Capture Prey, Study Reveals

Turkey Accuses Swedish Journalist of
3 MIN READ

Turkey Accuses Swedish Journalist of Terrorism and Anti-Turkish Reporting

Elderly Woman Airlifted After Clothes
1 MIN READ

Elderly Woman Airlifted After Clothes Catch Fire at Swedish Hospital

Swedes Struggle as Food Prices
4 MIN READ

Swedes Struggle as Food Prices Soar: 200 Kronor Gift Cards Run Out

Police Push for Expanded Surveillance
3 MIN READ

Police Push for Expanded Surveillance Powers on Minors in Sweden

Siblings in Sweden Marvel at
1 MIN READ

Siblings in Sweden Marvel at Rare Solar Eclipse with Welding Masks

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Expected
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Expected to Be Released Soon in Turkey

Police Struggle to Keep Up
3 MIN READ

Police Struggle to Keep Up as Online Radicalization Surges

Witness the Partial Solar Eclipse
3 MIN READ

Witness the Partial Solar Eclipse on March 29: How to Safely Watch

Body Discovered After Gislaved Apartment
1 MIN READ

Body Discovered After Gislaved Apartment Fire; Police Investigate

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested in Turkey Without Charge Details

Teen Convicted in Skärholmen Tunnel
1 MIN READ

Teen Convicted in Skärholmen Tunnel Murder Appeals 14-Year Sentence

Key Figures Depart Following Millennium
1 MIN READ

Key Figures Depart Following Millennium System Halt in Västra Götaland

Teen Arrested After Man Shot
1 MIN READ

Teen Arrested After Man Shot in Gothenburg Residential Area

Two Arrested After Gunfire Hits
1 MIN READ

Two Arrested After Gunfire Hits Apartments in Arlöv Near Malmö

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Five Hospitalized Following Serious Car Crash Near Surahammar

Sweden Sets Clocks Forward for
1 MIN READ

Sweden Sets Clocks Forward for Summertime Transition

Man in His 70s Dies
1 MIN READ

Man in His 70s Dies in Drowning Accident in Jämtland

Facebook Revives Friend Feed to
1 MIN READ

Facebook Revives Friend Feed to Reconnect Users

Sweden Redirects 158 Million Kronor
1 MIN READ

Sweden Redirects 158 Million Kronor Aid to Myanmar Earthquake Relief

Fegen Residents Advised to Boil
1 MIN READ

Fegen Residents Advised to Boil Water Due to Waterworks Issue

Swedish Journalist's Arrest in Turkey
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist's Arrest in Turkey Sparks Global Outcry

EU License Changes May Impact
4 MIN READ

EU License Changes May Impact Swedish A-Tractor Rules for Teens

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Detained
3 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Detained in Turkey

Sixth Suspect Linked to December
1 MIN READ

Sixth Suspect Linked to December Murder in Växjö

Swedish Foreign Minister Deeply Moved
1 MIN READ

Swedish Foreign Minister Deeply Moved by Southeast Asia Earthquake

Man in Custody After Shooting
1 MIN READ

Man in Custody After Shooting at Police in Karlshamn

Swedish IS Terrorist Osama Krayem
1 MIN READ

Swedish IS Terrorist Osama Krayem Detained for Serious War Crimes

25 Charged in Sweden for
2 MIN READ

25 Charged in Sweden for Defrauding Elderly of Millions

Swedish Court to Decide on
2 MIN READ

Swedish Court to Decide on Alleged Birth Intervention Without Consent

18-Year-Old Faces Charges for Nine
1 MIN READ

18-Year-Old Faces Charges for Nine Attempted Murders in Malmö