SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Criticism: No Research Support for New Screen Recommendations

The new screen areas from the Public Health Agency are being criticized by experts. It is not reasonable to set such sharp boundaries based on such a weak foundation, says sociologist Henrik Pallin.

» Updated: 04 September 2024, 16:12

» Published: 04 September 2024

Criticism: No Research Support for New Screen Recommendations
Photo: Christine Olsson/TT

The recommendations for children and young people were presented on Monday and include, among other things, that children under two years old should not have any screen time at all and that teenagers should have a maximum of three hours.

Social worker Henrik Pallin, who has written books about young people's internet use, is critical. He claims that the Public Health Agency is going against its own knowledge compilation, which the guidelines are supposed to be based on.

In the knowledge compilation, they are quite clear that they cannot be clear. Based on that, they then land on very sharp boundaries, he says.

"Does not shorten Bup queues"

Henrik Pallin takes overweight as an example.

In the compilation, they explicitly state that it may be the case that if you are overweight, you sit more still and then you are also more inclined to use the screen. But it is not necessarily the case that you became overweight because you used the screen.

Elza Dunkels, internet researcher and associate professor of educational work, believes that there is a lack of research support for the time limits.

Dangers such as stress, anxiety, and distorted self-image cannot be linked to screen use itself, she believes – and thinks that a "false image" was presented at the press conference.

When asked if there are any connections between screen use and physical and mental ill-health, she responds:

"No causal connections. There are no studies that have tried to show such a connection, but none have succeeded", she writes in an email.

Something Henrik Pallin agrees with.

Having unlimited screen time that crowds out other activities is certainly not good. But it's not the case that the queues to Bup will be shortened just because screen time decreases.

It would have been better with solutions than wagging fingers, he says.

Start by following the Public Health Agency's recommendations on how much you should exercise every day, and I think you would have solved many of the problems. But there were no investments in either youth sports, cultural school, or Bup.

Social community

Henrik Pallin also thinks that the Public Health Agency is missing the significance of screens for community.

It's the case that some can be outsiders at school and have their social contacts through their screen. That's not taken up at all, that an enormous sense of belonging can be created through Minecraft, Fortnite, and other platforms.

What is your advice to parents?

That you should get to know your children so that you can set the boundaries that the children deserve. If you're, for example, a girl who plays football four days a week and has an active life, it's no danger to sit four-five hours a day with a screen, he says.

The Public Health Agency's new recommendations for screen time for children and young people:

0-2-year-olds: Ideally no screen time at all.

2-5-year-olds: Maximum 1 hour.

6-12-year-olds: Maximum 1-2 hours.

13-18-year-olds: Maximum 2-3 hours.

+ The recommendations concern leisure-time use, such as social media, video clips, movies, TV, and computer games.

+ Music listening, podcasts, e-books, and school-related screen use are not included in the time limits.

Tags
TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Teenage boy suspected of rape
1 MIN READ

Teenage boy suspected of rape

Long prison sentence for shots at residential buildings
1 MIN READ

Long prison sentence for shots at residential buildings

Falcon hunting at 3,000 meters altitude: "Fascinating"
1 MIN READ

Falcon hunting at 3,000 meters altitude: "Fascinating"

Argentina Withdraws from Climate Summit
1 MIN READ

Argentina Withdraws from Climate Summit

Management backs down on criticized journal system
2 MIN READ

Management backs down on criticized journal system

Man arrested for murder of woman
1 MIN READ

Man arrested for murder of woman

Windy on the Mountain Plateau – Warnings Issued
2 MIN READ

Windy on the Mountain Plateau – Warnings Issued

Major disruption to train traffic after accident
1 MIN READ

Major disruption to train traffic after accident

The Defense: A Responsible Decision by the Government
3 MIN READ

The Defense: A Responsible Decision by the Government

Girl Missing for Over 50 Years Found Dead
1 MIN READ

Girl Missing for Over 50 Years Found Dead

Driver prosecuted for hit-and-run after boy's death
1 MIN READ

Driver prosecuted for hit-and-run after boy's death

Smoke at Forsmark – people took shelter underground
1 MIN READ

Smoke at Forsmark – people took shelter underground

Emissions within the EU are decreasing – but too little
1 MIN READ

Emissions within the EU are decreasing – but too little

After the Arrest: Previous Victim Got Panic Attack
1 MIN READ

After the Arrest: Previous Victim Got Panic Attack

"My island has been destroyed by floods" – great frustration
3 MIN READ

"My island has been destroyed by floods" – great frustration

Concern about the proposal for electronic ankle tags for children
2 MIN READ

Concern about the proposal for electronic ankle tags for children

Over 700,000 live in areas of exclusion
3 MIN READ

Over 700,000 live in areas of exclusion

Kristersson: Doesn't want a superficial conversation with Trump
2 MIN READ

Kristersson: Doesn't want a superficial conversation with Trump

Kristersson on the Nytorgsman: Extremely Serious
2 MIN READ

Kristersson on the Nytorgsman: Extremely Serious

Person found dead in northern Stockholm
1 MIN READ

Person found dead in northern Stockholm