War in Old Footsteps: Military Victories Short-Lived

Several shocking turns of events – but the latest year's war follows the same pattern as many previous ones. Military victories in the Middle East become short-lived, if they cannot be converted into political progress, says analyst Alexander Atarodi. Every time someone has tried to upset the balance of power in the region, it has resulted in catastrophe.

» Updated: October 08 2024

» Published: October 06 2024

War in Old Footsteps: Military Victories Short-Lived
Photo: AP/TT

There are many previous examples in the region, dating back to at least the Six-Day War and the October War, when Israel's neighboring countries tried to destroy the young Jewish state. Atarodi mentions Israel's first invasion of Lebanon in 1982, the US-led overthrow of Iraq's dictator Saddam Hussein, and decades of superpower involvement in Afghanistan – military might and surprise bring quick successes, but then what?

There are tactical victories, military victories today. But long-term problems, political problems, remain, says Atarodi, an independent security policy analyst.

They can very well come back to the surface in two years, five years, or whatever, in Iraq and Afghanistan. In some cases, it can come back ten years later.

Testing the Boundaries

This time, it was the Palestinian Hamas that shocked Israel with its massive terrorist attack on October 7 last year. The response was an overwhelming military offensive. It was initially focused on Gaza, although Hamas allies in Lebanon, Yemen, and – to a lesser extent – Syria and Iraq, also joined the fighting.

It was only after half a year that Israel "began to slightly test the boundaries of Iran", the superpower behind the militias, according to Atarodi. On the evening of April 1, Israeli fighter jets swept over Syria. Missiles were fired at Iran's consulate in Damascus, which was destroyed. Generals and diplomats were killed.

Weakened Capacity

Iran responded with the first direct missile attack ever against Israel. The conflict's playing field was thus definitively redrawn.

It quickly became clear that the region's two other crucial superpowers, Saudi Arabia and Turkey, would stand on the sidelines. And so did the US, to a large extent, when the superpower's attempt to impose a ceasefire in Gaza fell through.

The massive military support to Israel remains, says Atarodi.

But the idea of the US as an actor that has the capacity to put pressure on Israel has disappeared, or at least been greatly weakened.

"What is the Purpose?"

Israel has thus been able to continue challenging Iran in increasingly spectacular ways – with the person-hunting attacks in Lebanon as a climax, the bombs that killed Hamas and Hezbollah's top leaders, Ismail Haniya and Hassan Nasrallah, another.

But if it now appears that Israel can do what it wants militarily, the question remains what happens next.

It is extremely important for Israel to formulate something political now. What does it want to achieve in Lebanon? How long will it stay there? What is the purpose?

Does it have a political solution for how Gaza should be governed? And so on. There are incredibly many fundamental problems that remain.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

1,001 Killed in Gaza After
1 MIN READ

1,001 Killed in Gaza After Ceasefire Ends, Health Officials Report

Putin Open to Talks with
1 MIN READ

Putin Open to Talks with Trump Despite Recent Tensions

Democrats Seek New Leadership as
6 MIN READ

Democrats Seek New Leadership as Trump Dominates US Politics

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Explosion in Spanish Coal Mine Claims Five Lives

Hamas Urges Global Resistance to
1 MIN READ

Hamas Urges Global Resistance to Trump's Controversial Gaza Plan

Families Hold Vigil at Bangkok
2 MIN READ

Families Hold Vigil at Bangkok Skyscraper Collapse Site

Swedish Man Extradited to Norway
1 MIN READ

Swedish Man Extradited to Norway in Major Drug Trafficking Case

Netanyahu Aides Detained in Qatargate
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Aides Detained in Qatargate Probe

Le Pen Barred from 2027
3 MIN READ

Le Pen Barred from 2027 Election, Sentenced for EU Funds Misuse

Zelensky Prepares for Possible Ukrainian
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Prepares for Possible Ukrainian Election This Summer

Vehicle Linked to Missing US
1 MIN READ

Vehicle Linked to Missing US Soldiers Found Underwater in Lithuania

Russia Accuses Ukraine of Power
2 MIN READ

Russia Accuses Ukraine of Power Line Attacks Amid Drone Strikes

Israel Urges Palestinians in Southern
1 MIN READ

Israel Urges Palestinians in Southern Gaza to Relocate to al-Mawasi

Iran Vows Powerful Response if
1 MIN READ

Iran Vows Powerful Response if US Launches Attack

Three Found Dead in Southern
1 MIN READ

Three Found Dead in Southern Norway; Police Investigate Possible Link

Netanyahu Appoints New Security Chief
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Appoints New Security Chief Despite Court Block and Protests

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 2,000
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 2,000 Lives, Hopes for Survivors Fade

Le Pen's Presidential Hopes in
3 MIN READ

Le Pen's Presidential Hopes in Jeopardy as Fraud Verdict Looms

Trump Accuses Zelenskyj of Backing
1 MIN READ

Trump Accuses Zelenskyj of Backing Out of US Mineral Deal

Zelensky Thanks Stubb for Finland's
2 MIN READ

Zelensky Thanks Stubb for Finland's Support After Trump Golf Diplomacy

Ice Storm Leaves 500,000 Without
1 MIN READ

Ice Storm Leaves 500,000 Without Power Across US and Canada

Islamic Extremists Suspected in Deadly
1 MIN READ

Islamic Extremists Suspected in Deadly Attack on Burkina Faso Soldiers

Trump Hints at Third Term
1 MIN READ

Trump Hints at Third Term Despite Constitutional Limits

Erna Solberg Witnesses Ukraine's War
1 MIN READ

Erna Solberg Witnesses Ukraine's War Devastation on Frontline Journey

US Students Face Deportation Over
3 MIN READ

US Students Face Deportation Over Alleged Pro-Palestinian Support

Red Cross Condemns Israeli Attack
1 MIN READ

Red Cross Condemns Israeli Attack on Ambulance Workers in Rafah

Trump Warns of Strikes if
1 MIN READ

Trump Warns of Strikes if Iran Rejects Peace Deal Proposal

Trump Frustrated with Putin Over
1 MIN READ

Trump Frustrated with Putin Over Ukraine, Threatens New Tariffs

Erdogan Urges PKK to Disarm
1 MIN READ

Erdogan Urges PKK to Disarm Without Delay

Tsunami Warning Lifted After 7.1
1 MIN READ

Tsunami Warning Lifted After 7.1 Earthquake Near Tonga

Netanyahu Urges Hamas to Disarm
2 MIN READ

Netanyahu Urges Hamas to Disarm in Ceasefire Talks

Norwegian Rocket Test Ends in
2 MIN READ

Norwegian Rocket Test Ends in Crash but Deemed a Success by Isar Aerospace

Sudanese Army Takes Control of
2 MIN READ

Sudanese Army Takes Control of Khartum as RSF Withdraws

Israeli Defense Intercepts Yemeni Robot
1 MIN READ

Israeli Defense Intercepts Yemeni Robot as Air Raid Sirens Sound

Netanyahu Heads to EU Despite
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Heads to EU Despite ICC Arrest Warrant

US Pledges Strong Military Presence
1 MIN READ

US Pledges Strong Military Presence in Taiwan Strait to Deter China

Greenland's Prime Minister Firmly Rejects
2 MIN READ

Greenland's Prime Minister Firmly Rejects Trump's Takeover Claims

Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills
1 MIN READ

Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills Eight, Including Five Children

Grave Cleanup Sparks South Korea's
1 MIN READ

Grave Cleanup Sparks South Korea's Largest Forest Fire

Greenland's Independence Dream: A Dangerous
2 MIN READ

Greenland's Independence Dream: A Dangerous Utopia, Warns Lynge