Lawyers Argue Against Confiscating Students' Phones in Schools

A ban on school students using their mobile phones throughout the entire school day means that students are prevented from organizing themselves. Wrong way to go, according to two lawyers.

» Published: March 24 2025

Lawyers Argue Against Confiscating Students' Phones in Schools
Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

The government wants to see completely mobile-free schools and recently presented an investigative proposal that all elementary schools should collect students' mobile phones in the morning and not return them until the end of the school day. The motivation is that mobile phone use disrupts concentration and increases the risk of online harassment.

But student councils and school newspapers rely on young people being able to communicate to organize themselves.

"The fact that students cannot use their mobile phones, not even during breaks, constitutes a practical obstacle to the exercise of the constitutionally protected freedom of association," write lawyers Fredrik Engström and Peter Hellman on DN Debatt.

They compare it to an employer confiscating union representatives' mobile phones during working hours, which would be unthinkable. They write further that the Law Council already in 2007 pointed out that collecting students' mobile phones constitutes a restriction of property protection under the European Convention.

"It is, in practice, a matter of confiscation, which in the rest of society is normally reserved for law enforcement authorities," they write and urge the government to throw the proposal in the trash can.

TTT
By TT - Translated and adapted by Sweden Herald

More news

New Rules for Farm Sales
3 MIN READ

New Rules for Farm Sales Spark Criticism Over Hangover Threat

Gothenburg Double Murder Suspect Arrested,
1 MIN READ

Gothenburg Double Murder Suspect Arrested, 23-Year-Old in Custody

Body Found in Burnt-Out Rental
1 MIN READ

Body Found in Burnt-Out Rental Car in Northern Stockholm

West Coast Beaches See Surge
1 MIN READ

West Coast Beaches See Surge in Plastic Bottle Caps Despite EU Law

Genre image
3 MIN READ

Swedish Teens Exceed Recommended Sugar Intake, Study Finds

Two Arrested in Klippan for
1 MIN READ

Two Arrested in Klippan for Suspected Explosive Goods Crime

Man Stabbed in Västerås Brawl
1 MIN READ

Man Stabbed in Västerås Brawl Involving 20 People

Man Found Dead in Jämtland;
1 MIN READ

Man Found Dead in Jämtland; Police Investigate Suspected Murder

Man Arrested for Attempted Murder
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested for Attempted Murder of Ex-Wife in Sollentuna

Teen Boys Hospitalized After A-Tractor
1 MIN READ

Teen Boys Hospitalized After A-Tractor Collision in Blekinge

Suspect Arrested in Stockholm for
1 MIN READ

Suspect Arrested in Stockholm for Alleged Crime Preparation

Two Detained in Gothenburg Double
1 MIN READ

Two Detained in Gothenburg Double Murder Investigation

Sweden's Cardinal Arborelius: A Humble
5 MIN READ

Sweden's Cardinal Arborelius: A Humble Voice in Catholic Leadership

Climate Activists Allegedly Fly Drones
1 MIN READ

Climate Activists Allegedly Fly Drones at Landvetter Airport

Fredrick Federley Enters Church Election
1 MIN READ

Fredrick Federley Enters Church Election in Västerås Diocese

Chocolate's Shelf Life: Why It
3 MIN READ

Chocolate's Shelf Life: Why It Lasts Longer Than You Think

Proposal to Rename Arlanda Airport
1 MIN READ

Proposal to Rename Arlanda Airport to Alfred Nobel Airport Gains Support

Man Arrested in Connection with
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested in Connection with Suspected Rape at Stockholm Nightclub

Stem Cell Trials Offer New
2 MIN READ

Stem Cell Trials Offer New Hope for Advanced Parkinson's Treatment

Fire Destroys Barn, 30 Animals
1 MIN READ

Fire Destroys Barn, 30 Animals Lost; 170 Rescued Nearby

Police Nationwide to Tackle Sugar
1 MIN READ

Police Nationwide to Tackle Sugar Dating with New Proactive Measures

Explosion in Central Stockholm Damages
1 MIN READ

Explosion in Central Stockholm Damages Building, No Injuries Reported

Explosion Damages Malmö Apartment Door,
1 MIN READ

Explosion Damages Malmö Apartment Door, No Injuries Reported

Teen Receives Medical Attention After
1 MIN READ

Teen Receives Medical Attention After Dog Bite in Linköping

Woman Convicted for Cracking Egg
1 MIN READ

Woman Convicted for Cracking Egg on Daughter's Head in Live Stream

Man Fined for Explosion Caused
1 MIN READ

Man Fined for Explosion Caused by Attempt to Deep-Fry Chili Cheese

Fire at Gothenburg Refinery Injures
1 MIN READ

Fire at Gothenburg Refinery Injures Three, One Seriously

Climate Activists Arrested on Malmö
1 MIN READ

Climate Activists Arrested on Malmö Airport Runway

Passengers Evacuated from Arlanda Express
1 MIN READ

Passengers Evacuated from Arlanda Express After Three-Hour Delay

Extreme Weather and Viruses Threaten
2 MIN READ

Extreme Weather and Viruses Threaten Global Blood Donation Supply

Riders and Horses Rescued from
1 MIN READ

Riders and Horses Rescued from Bog Near Karlstad Airport

Five Rescued from Burning Fishing
1 MIN READ

Five Rescued from Burning Fishing Boat Near Strömstad

Avalanche Risk High in Swedish
1 MIN READ

Avalanche Risk High in Swedish Mountains: Stay Clear of Steep Slopes

Understanding April's Unpredictable Weather: Insights
2 MIN READ

Understanding April's Unpredictable Weather: Insights from a Meteorologist

Sweden Boosts Egg Exports as
3 MIN READ

Sweden Boosts Egg Exports as Bird Flu Hits Global Supply

Man Jailed for Missing Military
1 MIN READ

Man Jailed for Missing Military Exercise to Care for Children