Lawyers Argue Against Confiscating Students' Phones in Schools

A ban on school students using their mobile phones throughout the entire school day means that students are prevented from organizing themselves. Wrong way to go, according to two lawyers.

» Published: March 24 2025

Lawyers Argue Against Confiscating Students' Phones in Schools
Photo: Fredrik Sandberg/TT

Share this article

The government wants to see completely mobile-free schools and recently presented an investigative proposal that all elementary schools should collect students' mobile phones in the morning and not return them until the end of the school day. The motivation is that mobile phone use disrupts concentration and increases the risk of online harassment.

But student councils and school newspapers rely on young people being able to communicate to organize themselves.

"The fact that students cannot use their mobile phones, not even during breaks, constitutes a practical obstacle to the exercise of the constitutionally protected freedom of association," write lawyers Fredrik Engström and Peter Hellman on DN Debatt.

They compare it to an employer confiscating union representatives' mobile phones during working hours, which would be unthinkable. They write further that the Law Council already in 2007 pointed out that collecting students' mobile phones constitutes a restriction of property protection under the European Convention.

"It is, in practice, a matter of confiscation, which in the rest of society is normally reserved for law enforcement authorities," they write and urge the government to throw the proposal in the trash can.

Loading related articles...

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers
Loading related posts...