Expert: Trump's peace initiative a "smokescreen"

Ukraine must give up territory to achieve peace with Russia, according to the USA. But President Donald Trump's statement about an end to the war through negotiations does not guarantee that peace is within reach. It is a political game. He creates a smokescreen because he has to do something, says Arkady Moshes at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

» Published:

Expert: Trump's peace initiative a "smokescreen"
Photo: Alex Brandon/AP/TT

Share this article

Ukraine must not join NATO and must also give up territories to Russia. Otherwise, there can be no peace, according to the US.

The statement should be seen in the light of Donald Trump's earlier promise of a quick end to the Ukraine war. That promise is a major reason why the president now wants to show that he is working to fulfill his election promises, according to Arkady Moshes, program director at Finland's UI.

He's trying to show that he's ready to get things done, that he's going to move forward with negotiations, but we shouldn't take his statement literally at this point, he says.

"Completely unpredictable"

Since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine almost three years ago, President Vladimir Putin has not made any concessions regarding the regime's goals in the war. And Russia is a recognized tough negotiator, emphasizes Arkady Moshes.

I wouldn't want to predict any successes from this negotiation, because when Trump realizes that Russia won't make concessions, he'll need to use pressure methods, and where that takes us, we don't know. The situation is completely unpredictable.

But Trump will win anyway, because he can say that he's tried.

Now, the attempts to determine Ukraine's fate seem to be handled between the great powers USA and Russia, with both Europe and Ukraine as spectators instead of participants.

On his own terms

Donald Trump usually does things on his own terms, says Jan Hallenberg, political scientist at Swedish UI. But how Trump's party colleagues will react to a peace negotiation where the starting points seem to be lined up in Russia's favor remains to be seen.

And he has a special relationship with Putin, which is partly because he sees some kind of similarity between the two as authoritarian leaders, he says.

Trump and Putin have two things in common, according to Arkady Moshes. The first is that neither of them sees Europe as important.

For Putin, it's about Russia's sovereignty, for Trump, it's about his ego. But basically, they just don't see Europe as a player.

The second common denominator is, according to Moshes, that they don't think foreign policy can be built on values.

They think it's about power and money, that values are for sale.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Ukrainian Drones Strike Major Russian Refineries, Impacting Operations

Ukrainian Drones Strike Major Russian Refineries, Impacting Operations

Russia Returns 1,000 Bodies of Ukrainian Soldiers

Russia Returns 1,000 Bodies of Ukrainian Soldiers

Three Arrested in UK for Suspected Russian Espionage

Three Arrested in UK for Suspected Russian Espionage

Syria and Israel Nearing Agreement to Halt Military Actions

Syria and Israel Nearing Agreement to Halt Military Actions

EU Climate Goals Delayed Amid Disagreements at Brussels Meeting

EU Climate Goals Delayed Amid Disagreements at Brussels Meeting

Tear Gas Used in France Protests Against Macron's Budget Cuts

Tear Gas Used in France Protests Against Macron's Budget Cuts

Lula Says No Relationship Exists with Trump

Lula Says No Relationship Exists with Trump

Spain to Support ICC's Gaza War Crimes Investigation

Spain to Support ICC's Gaza War Crimes Investigation

Macron Sues to Disprove Rumors About Wife's Gender in US Court

Macron Sues to Disprove Rumors About Wife's Gender in US Court

Trump Meets UK Prime Minister Starmer After Royal Reception

Trump Meets UK Prime Minister Starmer After Royal Reception

Argentinians Celebrate as Congress Rejects Milei's Budget Veto

Argentinians Celebrate as Congress Rejects Milei's Budget Veto

Three Police Officers Killed in Pennsylvania Shooting; Suspect Dead

Three Police Officers Killed in Pennsylvania Shooting; Suspect Dead

Four-Year-Old Omar's Heartbreak After Fleeing Gaza: Who Will I Play With Now?

Four-Year-Old Omar's Heartbreak After Fleeing Gaza: Who Will I Play With Now?

Judge Orders Deportation of Activist Mahmoud Khalil

Judge Orders Deportation of Activist Mahmoud Khalil

Ukraine Anticipates Increased Arms Fund for Weapon Purchases

Ukraine Anticipates Increased Arms Fund for Weapon Purchases

Trump Calls Antifa a Terrorist Organization

Trump Calls Antifa a Terrorist Organization

Tyler Robinson Surrenders to Avoid SWAT Arrest in Charlie Kirk Case

Tyler Robinson Surrenders to Avoid SWAT Arrest in Charlie Kirk Case

Saudi Arabia and Pakistan Sign Mutual Defense Agreement

Saudi Arabia and Pakistan Sign Mutual Defense Agreement

Trump's Historic Second State Visit to Windsor Castle

Trump's Historic Second State Visit to Windsor Castle

Bernie Sanders Accuses Israel of Genocide in Gaza, Urges US Action

Bernie Sanders Accuses Israel of Genocide in Gaza, Urges US Action