Expert: Trump's peace initiative a "smokescreen"

Ukraine must give up territory to achieve peace with Russia, according to the USA. But President Donald Trump's statement about an end to the war through negotiations does not guarantee that peace is within reach. It is a political game. He creates a smokescreen because he has to do something, says Arkady Moshes at the Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

» Published: February 13 2025

Expert: Trump's peace initiative a "smokescreen"
Photo: Alex Brandon/AP/TT

Ukraine must not join NATO and must also give up territories to Russia. Otherwise, there can be no peace, according to the US.

The statement should be seen in the light of Donald Trump's earlier promise of a quick end to the Ukraine war. That promise is a major reason why the president now wants to show that he is working to fulfill his election promises, according to Arkady Moshes, program director at Finland's UI.

He's trying to show that he's ready to get things done, that he's going to move forward with negotiations, but we shouldn't take his statement literally at this point, he says.

"Completely unpredictable"

Since Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine almost three years ago, President Vladimir Putin has not made any concessions regarding the regime's goals in the war. And Russia is a recognized tough negotiator, emphasizes Arkady Moshes.

I wouldn't want to predict any successes from this negotiation, because when Trump realizes that Russia won't make concessions, he'll need to use pressure methods, and where that takes us, we don't know. The situation is completely unpredictable.

But Trump will win anyway, because he can say that he's tried.

Now, the attempts to determine Ukraine's fate seem to be handled between the great powers USA and Russia, with both Europe and Ukraine as spectators instead of participants.

On his own terms

Donald Trump usually does things on his own terms, says Jan Hallenberg, political scientist at Swedish UI. But how Trump's party colleagues will react to a peace negotiation where the starting points seem to be lined up in Russia's favor remains to be seen.

And he has a special relationship with Putin, which is partly because he sees some kind of similarity between the two as authoritarian leaders, he says.

Trump and Putin have two things in common, according to Arkady Moshes. The first is that neither of them sees Europe as important.

For Putin, it's about Russia's sovereignty, for Trump, it's about his ego. But basically, they just don't see Europe as a player.

The second common denominator is, according to Moshes, that they don't think foreign policy can be built on values.

They think it's about power and money, that values are for sale.

Tags

TTT
By TT - Translated and adapted by Sweden Herald under license from TT

More news

Genre image
1 MIN READ

USA Considers Recognizing Crimea as Russian in Peace Deal Talks

Senator Van Hollen Criticizes El
2 MIN READ

Senator Van Hollen Criticizes El Salvador's "Margarita-gate" Stunt

Hezbollah Leader Qassem: Group Will
2 MIN READ

Hezbollah Leader Qassem: Group Will Not Disarm Despite Pressures

USA to Relocate 1,000 Troops
1 MIN READ

USA to Relocate 1,000 Troops from Syria in Coming Months

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Congo River Boat Fire Leaves 148 Dead, Over 100 Still Missing

Trump Proposes New Rules for
2 MIN READ

Trump Proposes New Rules for Federal Employees to Enforce His Policies

Kyoto Bus Driver Loses Pension
1 MIN READ

Kyoto Bus Driver Loses Pension After Ticket Theft Ruling

Asean Calls on Myanmar Junta
1 MIN READ

Asean Calls on Myanmar Junta to Honor Ceasefire After Earthquake

Judge Blocks Trump's Plan to
1 MIN READ

Judge Blocks Trump's Plan to Cut CFPB Workforce

Australian Fighter for Ukraine Faces
1 MIN READ

Australian Fighter for Ukraine Faces Mercenary Charges in Luhansk

Venice Doubles Tourist Day-Trip Fee
2 MIN READ

Venice Doubles Tourist Day-Trip Fee for Non-Overnight Visitors

Trials Begin for Nearly 200
2 MIN READ

Trials Begin for Nearly 200 Critics of Turkish Regime Protests

Iran Nuclear Talks in Rome
2 MIN READ

Iran Nuclear Talks in Rome Face Doubts and Threats

Vance Expresses Cautious Optimism on
2 MIN READ

Vance Expresses Cautious Optimism on Ukraine Peace Talks in Europe

Ukraine Receives Remains of Over
1 MIN READ

Ukraine Receives Remains of Over 900 Fallen Soldiers

Veterans and Reservists Rally to
2 MIN READ

Veterans and Reservists Rally to End Gaza Conflict

EU Expansion: Hungary's Block Delays
3 MIN READ

EU Expansion: Hungary's Block Delays Ukraine and Moldova Membership

New Russian Attacks on Ukraine
2 MIN READ

New Russian Attacks on Ukraine Leave 11 Dead, Over 100 Injured

China Refutes Claims of Supplying
1 MIN READ

China Refutes Claims of Supplying Weapons to Russia

EU Officials Use Disposable Phones
1 MIN READ

EU Officials Use Disposable Phones for US Trips Over Spy Concerns

Israel's Blockade Leaves Gaza Residents
3 MIN READ

Israel's Blockade Leaves Gaza Residents Facing Severe Hunger Crisis

Israeli Strikes on Gaza Leave
1 MIN READ

Israeli Strikes on Gaza Leave 15 Dead, Including Family in Khan Yunis

US Airstrikes in Yemen Kill
2 MIN READ

US Airstrikes in Yemen Kill 74, Injure 171, Houthi Movement Reports

Trump Plans UK Visit to
1 MIN READ

Trump Plans UK Visit to Meet King Charles This Autumn

Luigi Mangione Faces Federal Murder
1 MIN READ

Luigi Mangione Faces Federal Murder Charges in CEO's Death

Two Killed, Five Injured in
1 MIN READ

Two Killed, Five Injured in Florida State University Shooting

Red Cross Building in Gaza
1 MIN READ

Red Cross Building in Gaza Damaged by Explosion, ICRC Expresses Outrage

Ukraine Talks to Continue in
2 MIN READ

Ukraine Talks to Continue in London Next Week Following Paris Meeting

USA and Ukraine Set to
1 MIN READ

USA and Ukraine Set to Finalize Mineral Agreement Next Thursday

Myanmar Seeks Regional Aid After
1 MIN READ

Myanmar Seeks Regional Aid After Devastating Earthquake

Cable Car Accident in Italy
1 MIN READ

Cable Car Accident in Italy Claims Four Lives Near Naples

Trump Seeks to Narrow Species
1 MIN READ

Trump Seeks to Narrow Species Protection Law, Sparking Criticism

Zelensky Accuses China of Supplying
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Accuses China of Supplying Weapons to Russia

Aid Groups Warn of Imminent
1 MIN READ

Aid Groups Warn of Imminent Collapse in Gaza Due to Blockade

Russia Cautions Germany on Sending
1 MIN READ

Russia Cautions Germany on Sending Taurus Robots to Ukraine

Haiti's Security Crisis Worsens as
1 MIN READ

Haiti's Security Crisis Worsens as Violence Spreads, Warns HRW