Difficult for Bonnesen to get a new trial

The prison sentence against the former Swedbank CEO Birgitte Bonnesen will be appealed to the Supreme Court, assures her lawyer. However, the odds are against the Supreme Court taking up her case. You have to go through the eye of a needle to get a leave to appeal, says Daniel Stattin, professor of civil law.

» Updated: September 30 2024

» Published: September 12 2024

Difficult for Bonnesen to get a new trial
Photo: Stina Stjernkvist/SvD/TT

The Svea Court of Appeal convicted Bonnesen on Tuesday for gross fraud to imprisonment for one year and three months. The court thereby overturned the district court's acquittal – a decision that her lawyer Per E Samuelsson described as "a shock".

Bonnesen will appeal to the Supreme Court, but to get a new trial there, the Supreme Court must first grant leave to appeal. Last year, around 9,000 cases were appealed, only about 100 were granted leave to appeal.

The Supreme Court's main task is to create guiding legal precedents, where there are uncertainties in how the law should be interpreted. To get leave to appeal, Bonnesen and her defenders must therefore convince the court that there are important legal issues in the case that need to be clarified.

Few precedents

Something that could speak in favor of succeeding is that fraud is an unusual form of crime, and that there are therefore few examples of similar previous cases. As a result, there may also be uncertainties in how certain parts of the law should be applied.

There are very few precedents on gross fraud, and even fewer when it comes to listed companies, says Daniel Stattin, professor of civil law at Uppsala University

The question of leave to appeal is, however, always complex, he says.

It's about managing to present a "pt-question" that is interesting enough. But there are some interesting aspects in the Court of Appeal's judgment on how to conduct the examination of fraud, so it's not ruled out.

On the other hand, it is a relatively large and complex case. This could speak against the Supreme Court, which wants to have as clear-cut cases as possible, taking it up.

It may be difficult to formulate a precedent question that is separate from the circumstances of this case. It builds so much on what was said at what time, says Stattin.

Difficult to predict

Even Marie Karlsson Tuula, professor of civil law at Linnaeus University with a focus on property law and economic crime, says it is difficult to predict how the Supreme Court will reason. The outcome likely depends to a large extent on how the appeal is formulated, she says.

It's about how the lawyer presents it, what question the Supreme Court has to try, that's what's important.

If the Supreme Court does not take up the case, the prison sentence against Birgitte Bonnesen will be upheld.

On September 10, the Svea Court of Appeal sentenced Swedbank's former CEO Birgitte Bonnesen to imprisonment for one year and three months for gross fraud.

The Court of Appeal found that the then-CEO provided misleading information when she was interviewed by Svenska Dagbladet and TT when the bank released its third quarter report 2018.

The information conveyed the misleading message that there were no suspected money laundering connections to Danske Bank's operations in Estonia. The information was, according to the court, capable of influencing the assessment of the Swedish bank in economic terms and thereby causing damage.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Zuckerberg's Wealth Drops by 177
1 MIN READ

Zuckerberg's Wealth Drops by 177 Billion Kronor in Stock Market Slide

New Trade Deal Boosts Pay
1 MIN READ

New Trade Deal Boosts Pay and Cuts Hours for Swedish Workers

Police Warn of Crime Surge
1 MIN READ

Police Warn of Crime Surge Risk Following Northvolt Bankruptcy

Cristina Stenbeck Returns as Kinnevik
1 MIN READ

Cristina Stenbeck Returns as Kinnevik Chairman After 7 Years

Stockholm Stock Exchange Faces Downturn
1 MIN READ

Stockholm Stock Exchange Faces Downturn as US Trade Talks Stall

Stock Market Sees Largest Single-Day
1 MIN READ

Stock Market Sees Largest Single-Day Drop Since 2020 Pandemic

Sweden's Inflation Falls More Than
2 MIN READ

Sweden's Inflation Falls More Than Expected, Offering Economic Relief

Transport Unions and Employers Seal
1 MIN READ

Transport Unions and Employers Seal New Wage Agreement

European Stocks Slide Further After
2 MIN READ

European Stocks Slide Further After US Tariff Announcement

EU Tariffs on US Goods
3 MIN READ

EU Tariffs on US Goods Could Raise Prices for Swedish Shoppers

Asian Markets Slide Following US
1 MIN READ

Asian Markets Slide Following US Tariff Announcement

IMF Warns US Tariffs Threaten
1 MIN READ

IMF Warns US Tariffs Threaten Global Economic Growth

Trump Signals Openness to Tariff
1 MIN READ

Trump Signals Openness to Tariff Negotiations for Economic Boost

EU Prepares Trade Countermeasures as
3 MIN READ

EU Prepares Trade Countermeasures as US Tariffs Loom

WTO Warns Trump's Tariffs Could
1 MIN READ

WTO Warns Trump's Tariffs Could Cut Global Trade by 1 Percent

Canada Imposes 25-Percent Tariffs on
1 MIN READ

Canada Imposes 25-Percent Tariffs on US Cars in Trade Dispute

Macron Urges EU Firms to
1 MIN READ

Macron Urges EU Firms to Rethink US Investments Over Tariffs

Volvo's Shift to Electric Cars
2 MIN READ

Volvo's Shift to Electric Cars Faces Scrutiny as Diesel Demand Persists

Stellantis Halts Canada and Mexico
1 MIN READ

Stellantis Halts Canada and Mexico Production Over US Tariffs

Fitch Downgrades China's Credit Rating
1 MIN READ

Fitch Downgrades China's Credit Rating Citing Economic Concerns

Wind Farm Cable Approval Granted
2 MIN READ

Wind Farm Cable Approval Granted but Vattenfall Faces Cost Hurdle

US Stock Market Tumbles as
3 MIN READ

US Stock Market Tumbles as Tariffs Hit Tech Giants

US Tariffs Pose Global Economic
2 MIN READ

US Tariffs Pose Global Economic Challenge, Says Swedish Central Bank Chief

Ikano Bank Faces Police Report
1 MIN READ

Ikano Bank Faces Police Report in Denmark Over Misleading Marketing

EU Trade Chief Sefcovic to
1 MIN READ

EU Trade Chief Sefcovic to Discuss US Tariffs on Friday

Volvo Cars Boosts US Production
3 MIN READ

Volvo Cars Boosts US Production in Response to Trump's Tariffs

US Imposes Tariffs on Remote
1 MIN READ

US Imposes Tariffs on Remote Penguin Islands in Australian Territory

Saab Secures Major Order for
1 MIN READ

Saab Secures Major Order for Combat Vehicle Systems from BAE Systems

Trump Tariffs Threaten to Hike
1 MIN READ

Trump Tariffs Threaten to Hike Coffee Prices in the US

Trump's New Tariffs Spark Global
2 MIN READ

Trump's New Tariffs Spark Global Criticism and Economic Concerns

Kent Concerts Spark Hotel Market
1 MIN READ

Kent Concerts Spark Hotel Market Boost in Stockholm

US Boosts Norwegian Salmon Imports
1 MIN READ

US Boosts Norwegian Salmon Imports Before Tariff Decision

Sweden's IT Sector Sees Reduced
1 MIN READ

Sweden's IT Sector Sees Reduced Work Hours and Pay Raise

Service Sector Slows as Index
1 MIN READ

Service Sector Slows as Index Drops Below 50 in Sweden

Kristersson Urges Action Over US
2 MIN READ

Kristersson Urges Action Over US Tariffs, Calls for EU-US Trade Talks

Economist Urges Swedish Savers to
2 MIN READ

Economist Urges Swedish Savers to Hold Steady Despite Tariff Impact

Stockholm Stocks Plunge 3.4 Percent
2 MIN READ

Stockholm Stocks Plunge 3.4 Percent After Trump's Tariff News

Stock Market Faces Uncertainty After
2 MIN READ

Stock Market Faces Uncertainty After Trump's Tariff Announcement

Food Prices Stabilize as Supermarkets
3 MIN READ

Food Prices Stabilize as Supermarkets Compete for Shoppers

EU Prepares Countermeasures as US
2 MIN READ

EU Prepares Countermeasures as US Tariffs Threaten Global Economy