Home HomeSwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Difficult for Bonnesen to get a new trial

The prison sentence against the former Swedbank CEO Birgitte Bonnesen will be appealed to the Supreme Court, assures her lawyer. However, the odds are against the Supreme Court taking up her case. You have to go through the eye of a needle to get a leave to appeal, says Daniel Stattin, professor of civil law.

» Updated: 30 September 2024, 10:57

» Published: 12 September 2024

Difficult for Bonnesen to get a new trial
Photo: Stina Stjernkvist/SvD/TT

The Svea Court of Appeal convicted Bonnesen on Tuesday for gross fraud to imprisonment for one year and three months. The court thereby overturned the district court's acquittal – a decision that her lawyer Per E Samuelsson described as "a shock".

Bonnesen will appeal to the Supreme Court, but to get a new trial there, the Supreme Court must first grant leave to appeal. Last year, around 9,000 cases were appealed, only about 100 were granted leave to appeal.

The Supreme Court's main task is to create guiding legal precedents, where there are uncertainties in how the law should be interpreted. To get leave to appeal, Bonnesen and her defenders must therefore convince the court that there are important legal issues in the case that need to be clarified.

Few precedents

Something that could speak in favor of succeeding is that fraud is an unusual form of crime, and that there are therefore few examples of similar previous cases. As a result, there may also be uncertainties in how certain parts of the law should be applied.

There are very few precedents on gross fraud, and even fewer when it comes to listed companies, says Daniel Stattin, professor of civil law at Uppsala University

The question of leave to appeal is, however, always complex, he says.

It's about managing to present a "pt-question" that is interesting enough. But there are some interesting aspects in the Court of Appeal's judgment on how to conduct the examination of fraud, so it's not ruled out.

On the other hand, it is a relatively large and complex case. This could speak against the Supreme Court, which wants to have as clear-cut cases as possible, taking it up.

It may be difficult to formulate a precedent question that is separate from the circumstances of this case. It builds so much on what was said at what time, says Stattin.

Difficult to predict

Even Marie Karlsson Tuula, professor of civil law at Linnaeus University with a focus on property law and economic crime, says it is difficult to predict how the Supreme Court will reason. The outcome likely depends to a large extent on how the appeal is formulated, she says.

It's about how the lawyer presents it, what question the Supreme Court has to try, that's what's important.

If the Supreme Court does not take up the case, the prison sentence against Birgitte Bonnesen will be upheld.

On September 10, the Svea Court of Appeal sentenced Swedbank's former CEO Birgitte Bonnesen to imprisonment for one year and three months for gross fraud.

The Court of Appeal found that the then-CEO provided misleading information when she was interviewed by Svenska Dagbladet and TT when the bank released its third quarter report 2018.

The information conveyed the misleading message that there were no suspected money laundering connections to Danske Bank's operations in Estonia. The information was, according to the court, capable of influencing the assessment of the Swedish bank in economic terms and thereby causing damage.

Tags
TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Major Banks Lower Mortgage Rates
1 MIN READ

Major Banks Lower Mortgage Rates

Major Banks Lower Mortgage Rates
1 MIN READ

Major Banks Lower Mortgage Rates

Central Bank Economist: Central Bank Cuts Interest Rate Too Late
2 MIN READ

Central Bank Economist: Central Bank Cuts Interest Rate Too Late

How You Are Affected by Lowered Interest Rates
2 MIN READ

How You Are Affected by Lowered Interest Rates

The Central Bank doubles down - uncertainty after Trump's victory
2 MIN READ

The Central Bank doubles down - uncertainty after Trump's victory

Inflation upswing does not threaten interest rate cuts
3 MIN READ

Inflation upswing does not threaten interest rate cuts

Stockholm Stock Exchange Rises at Opening
1 MIN READ

Stockholm Stock Exchange Rises at Opening

Most up on Asian stock exchanges
1 MIN READ

Most up on Asian stock exchanges

This is how your wallet can be affected by Trump's victory
2 MIN READ

This is how your wallet can be affected by Trump's victory

Cheerful on Wall Street after Trump win
1 MIN READ

Cheerful on Wall Street after Trump win

Thousand-kronor notes to be picked up when the Central Bank increases the pace
3 MIN READ

Thousand-kronor notes to be picked up when the Central Bank increases the pace

Swish up and running again after disruption
1 MIN READ

Swish up and running again after disruption

Trump's company is soaring on the stock exchange
1 MIN READ

Trump's company is soaring on the stock exchange

Swedish Export Threatened by Trump Victory
2 MIN READ

Swedish Export Threatened by Trump Victory

Sameby's appeal against mining company rejected
1 MIN READ

Sameby's appeal against mining company rejected

Inflation Expectations Fall
1 MIN READ

Inflation Expectations Fall

Better than expected for Novo Nordisk
1 MIN READ

Better than expected for Novo Nordisk

No "Trump Effect" on the Stockholm Stock Exchange
1 MIN READ

No "Trump Effect" on the Stockholm Stock Exchange

Stock Market Euphoria as Trump Heads for Victory
2 MIN READ

Stock Market Euphoria as Trump Heads for Victory

Rush on the Tokyo Stock Exchange after the election night
1 MIN READ

Rush on the Tokyo Stock Exchange after the election night