SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

AI criticism against Oscar favorite – changed the dialogue

The filmmakers used AI to improve the actors' dialogue. Now the Oscar favorite "The Brutalist" is receiving criticism for having used the controversial technique.

» Published: 21 January 2025, 09:23

AI criticism against Oscar favorite – changed the dialogue
Photo: Lol Crawley/A24/AP/TT

Large parts of the dialogue in the film "Brutalisten" are in Hungarian, a language that actors Adrien Brody and Felicity Jones had to learn to master before filming.

But not well enough. So the filmmakers used AI to ensure that the Hungarian pronunciation was perfect, revealed editor Dávid Jancsó in a recent interview.

It's a very unique language. We trained them and they did a fantastic job, but we also wanted it to sound perfect, so that not even native Hungarians would notice anything, says Jancsó to tech magazine Red Shark News.

The criticism has not been slow to emerge. Several users on social media think that the move is equivalent to cheating and that the film should not be allowed to compete for an Oscar. The debate comes at the same time as many in Hollywood are worried that AI technology will take over a large part of the jobs in the film industry.

"Brutalisten" is one of the favorites ahead of the Oscars in March. The nominations will be presented on Thursday.

The film's director Brady Corbet defends the use of AI and says it was only done to make the film's dialogue feel more authentic.

"The goal was for Adrien's and Felicity's performances to feel authentic even in another language, not to replace or distort their efforts. And it was done with the greatest respect for professionalism", says Corbet in a statement to Variety.

Tags
TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

The Dream of Debuting – "Harder to Get Noticed"
3 MIN READ

The Dream of Debuting – "Harder to Get Noticed"

Prince Harry testifies against British tabloids
2 MIN READ

Prince Harry testifies against British tabloids

Asap Rocky on trial – faces up to 24 years in prison
1 MIN READ

Asap Rocky on trial – faces up to 24 years in prison

David Lynch is celebrated at the Stockholm Film Festival
1 MIN READ

David Lynch is celebrated at the Stockholm Film Festival

Debut with mixed feelings: A little awkward
4 MIN READ

Debut with mixed feelings: A little awkward

The Dream of Debuting
3 MIN READ

The Dream of Debuting

Industrial area can be remediated – with plants
1 MIN READ

Industrial area can be remediated – with plants

They will lead Eurovision in Switzerland this spring
1 MIN READ

They will lead Eurovision in Switzerland this spring

TV Top: "On the Track" Number One
1 MIN READ

TV Top: "On the Track" Number One

Proposal on Arkdes and Moderna is complete
2 MIN READ

Proposal on Arkdes and Moderna is complete

Ant Wan to Sthlm Fields
1 MIN READ

Ant Wan to Sthlm Fields

Snyder: The Translation Alters My Message
1 MIN READ

Snyder: The Translation Alters My Message

So "YMCA" became Donald Trump's soundtrack
2 MIN READ

So "YMCA" became Donald Trump's soundtrack

National Theater Continues – Despite Dageby's Death
1 MIN READ

National Theater Continues – Despite Dageby's Death

The Cure Star Leaves X: Time to Move On
1 MIN READ

The Cure Star Leaves X: Time to Move On

Nicole Kidman on erotic film - "makes me feel vulnerable"
3 MIN READ

Nicole Kidman on erotic film - "makes me feel vulnerable"

Draft of Dylan song sold for millions
1 MIN READ

Draft of Dylan song sold for millions

Everything You Need to Know Ahead of P3 Gold
2 MIN READ

Everything You Need to Know Ahead of P3 Gold

Translator altered Snyder's book
1 MIN READ

Translator altered Snyder's book

Culture under Trump - a survival struggle
2 MIN READ

Culture under Trump - a survival struggle