The EU historically weak as heavyweights are in crisis

Crisis in Berlin and crisis in Paris create a crisis for Brussels as well. Weak and unpopular governments in both Germany and France are causing the EU to stall.

» Published: September 16 2024

The EU historically weak as heavyweights are in crisis
Photo: Ebrahim Noroozi/AP/TT

Share this article

The Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has increasingly emerged as Europe's most powerful leader. But it doesn't help her much when her two most important backers have major domestic political problems.

Germany's Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz and France's President Emmanuel Macron are under heavy pressure and weak at home. And that makes the EU historically weak, notes André Sapir, a political scientist at the Brussels-based think tank Bruegel.

Yes. I think it will be difficult to make progress, says Sapir to TT.

"Nothing happens"

Admittedly, the EU is much more than just France and Germany. But getting anything done in the EU without strong engagement from at least one of the heavyweights is difficult.

It's not like France and Germany can change Europe on their own, but they can create a dynamic that drags others along. If France and Germany don't cooperate, nothing happens, says Sapir.

He doesn't think von der Leyen can drive progress instead.

No. I can't see how the EU Commission President can lead without at least one of the two leaders being strong. The EU is not the United States of Europe. Member states, and above all the two largest, are absolutely necessary.

Tusk moves forward?

The German-French uncertainty will make it difficult for the EU to make decisions on everything from asylum policy to trade agreements.

Instead, a period of increasing disagreement between member states and political groups in the EU Parliament is likely to await.

Perhaps Poland and its strongly EU-engaged government under Prime Minister Donald Tusk can move forward their positions during this time. However, neither the influence nor the votes are sufficient for Warsaw to replace Paris or Berlin.

Barnier in key role

The deadlock may well persist until September 2025, until the next German election. Or even until France's next presidential election, 2027.

André Sapir still sees an opportunity for France to take the lead – if former Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier succeeds in gathering "right" ministers into a strong government.

Macron has a weak position, but his choice of prime minister can give some hope for him and his ability to drive an agenda over the next three years. It depends very much on who he picks. It's a very narrow path, says Sapir to TT.

Germany's Federal Chancellor Olaf Scholz belongs to the Social Democratic Party (SPD), which in the EU election in June only got 14 percent of the votes. Since then, the party has also made very weak election results in the federal state elections in Thuringia and Saxony, just like the governing coalition partners in the Greens and the liberal FDP.

France's President Emmanuel Macron also had to settle for only 14 percent for his liberal movement LREM in the EU election. A quickly called new election to the French parliament has also made LREM lose its majority, and Macron has instead launched right-wing politician Michel Barnier as the new prime minister.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Hungary Blocks Ukrainian Commander Over Oil Pipeline Dispute
1 MIN READ

Hungary Blocks Ukrainian Commander Over Oil Pipeline Dispute

Polish Air Force F16 Crash During Exercise Kills Pilot
1 MIN READ

Polish Air Force F16 Crash During Exercise Kills Pilot

Trump to Address UN General Assembly in New York
1 MIN READ

Trump to Address UN General Assembly in New York

Haiti Faces Humanitarian Crisis Amidst Escalating Violence and Instability
3 MIN READ

Haiti Faces Humanitarian Crisis Amidst Escalating Violence and Instability

Kyiv Struggles to Counter Escalating Russian Drone and Missile Attacks
2 MIN READ

Kyiv Struggles to Counter Escalating Russian Drone and Missile Attacks

UN Extends Lebanon Peacekeeping Mission Until 2027
1 MIN READ

UN Extends Lebanon Peacekeeping Mission Until 2027

Israeli Military Strikes Huthi Targets in Yemen's Capital Sanaa
1 MIN READ

Israeli Military Strikes Huthi Targets in Yemen's Capital Sanaa

Alligator Alcatraz Closure Plans Move Forward Amid Environmental Concerns
1 MIN READ

Alligator Alcatraz Closure Plans Move Forward Amid Environmental Concerns

Europe Moves to Reinstate UN Sanctions on Iran Over Nuclear Dispute
4 MIN READ

Europe Moves to Reinstate UN Sanctions on Iran Over Nuclear Dispute

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan Faces New Sexual Harassment Allegations
2 MIN READ

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan Faces New Sexual Harassment Allegations

Kyiv Resident Natalya Lytvynova Sees Divine Protection Amid Russian Attack
2 MIN READ

Kyiv Resident Natalya Lytvynova Sees Divine Protection Amid Russian Attack

Over 20 Killed in New Attack by Rapid Support Forces in Sudan
1 MIN READ

Over 20 Killed in New Attack by Rapid Support Forces in Sudan

UN Experts Alarmed by Disappearances During Gaza Food Distribution
2 MIN READ

UN Experts Alarmed by Disappearances During Gaza Food Distribution

Gaza Crisis: UN Urges More Aid as Children Face Severe Malnutrition
1 MIN READ

Gaza Crisis: UN Urges More Aid as Children Face Severe Malnutrition

Minor Plane Accident at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport Involving Juneyao Airlines
1 MIN READ

Minor Plane Accident at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport Involving Juneyao Airlines

Russian Drones Suspected of Monitoring German Arms Routes to Ukraine
1 MIN READ

Russian Drones Suspected of Monitoring German Arms Routes to Ukraine

Over 1.2 Million Impacted by Pakistan Floods as Rivers Overflow
1 MIN READ

Over 1.2 Million Impacted by Pakistan Floods as Rivers Overflow

CDC Chief Fired Amid Vaccine Policy Dispute and Resignations
2 MIN READ

CDC Chief Fired Amid Vaccine Policy Dispute and Resignations

Israeli Raids Target Sites Near Damascus Amid Demilitarization Talks
1 MIN READ

Israeli Raids Target Sites Near Damascus Amid Demilitarization Talks

US Envoy Condemns Russian Attack on Kyiv as Heinous
2 MIN READ

US Envoy Condemns Russian Attack on Kyiv as Heinous