Netanyahu's Gaza Aid Plan Criticized as "Perverse" by Relief Chief

Israel is to allow a very limited amount of emergency aid into Gaza after nearly eleven weeks of blockade. The plan is then to bypass trusted aid organizations and let private security firms handle the deliveries. A deliberate delaying tactic, according to aid profile Jan Egeland.

» Published: May 19 2025

Netanyahu's Gaza Aid Plan Criticized as "Perverse" by Relief Chief
Photo: NRC/TT

Share this article

Around 20 trucks from aid organizations are expected to roll in on Monday – just a drop in the ocean of the Gazans' needs.

They want to show that they're doing something, but they're not opening the border, says Jan Egeland, Secretary-General of the international aid organization NRC.

It's still uncertain whether and when Israel will allow a larger quantity of emergency aid to the starving population in Gaza.

Militarizing humanitarian work

Israel has, together with the USA, outlined a plan that involves private security companies being responsible for distributing food and essential aid – and not the trusted organizations and UN agencies that are already standing by with thousands of trucks.

The idea is "perverse", according to Egeland, who sees it as a way to militarize humanitarian work.

A party to a conflict should not decide who gets help in a disputed area. The need for help should be the decisive factor, he says to TT.

Donor countries and international organizations are unlikely to allow private companies to take part in their emergency aid.

There is no reason to introduce a system that goes against the DNA of all principled humanitarian organizations, said Jens Lærke, spokesperson for the UN's humanitarian coordination agency OCHA, to BBC earlier in May.

Must declare occupation

The only way for Israel to implement the plan would be to more or less finance it itself.

Israel says it wants to take control of the entire Gaza Strip on Monday. If the country openly declares an occupation, it also implies clearer responsibilities towards the occupied population, emphasizes Egeland.

In parallel with the eyewitness accounts from inside Gaza – of starving children who weigh only a few kilos and exhausted mothers who faint when trying to breastfeed their newborns – hawkish politicians in Israel are criticizing the decision to allow even a limited amount of food in.

At the same time as bombs are falling and killing hundreds of Palestinians every week, a large part of Gaza's population risks starvation.

People are now so weakened that they will die from any illness, says Egeland, emphasizing that the crisis is man-made.

This is a step away from catastrophe.

Around 100 aid organizations are standing by with thousands of trucks, filled with approximately 170,000 tons of aid outside Gaza's borders. Nothing has been let in during the ten-week-long blockade that Israel has imposed.

Around 20 are expected to be let in on Monday. Before the war, hundreds of trucks were needed every day to meet the Gazans' needs.

Almost the entire population of 2.3 million in Gaza is acutely malnourished. One in five risks starvation, according to the UN-supported IPC. WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus went so far as to say that two million people – essentially the entire population of the area – are starving.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Norway Election Polls Show Red-Green Bloc Leading Over Høyre
2 MIN READ

Norway Election Polls Show Red-Green Bloc Leading Over Høyre

Man Killed in Rare Shark Attack at Sydney's Northern Beaches
1 MIN READ

Man Killed in Rare Shark Attack at Sydney's Northern Beaches

Europe Faces Autumn Crisis Amid Trump Tensions
3 MIN READ

Europe Faces Autumn Crisis Amid Trump Tensions

Trump Proposes Hosting Next G20 Summit at His Miami Golf Club
2 MIN READ

Trump Proposes Hosting Next G20 Summit at His Miami Golf Club

Serbian Police Clash with Protesters in Novi Sad Amid Election Demands
1 MIN READ

Serbian Police Clash with Protesters in Novi Sad Amid Election Demands

Trump Engages in Talks with Hamas for Israeli Hostage Release
1 MIN READ

Trump Engages in Talks with Hamas for Israeli Hostage Release

Trump Renames Defense Department to War Department
1 MIN READ

Trump Renames Defense Department to War Department

Lebanon Military Begins Plan to Disarm Hizbollah
1 MIN READ

Lebanon Military Begins Plan to Disarm Hizbollah

Eagle S Captain Denies Intentional Damage to Baltic Sea Cables
2 MIN READ

Eagle S Captain Denies Intentional Damage to Baltic Sea Cables

Trump Deploys 10 F-35 Fighter Jets to Puerto Rico Amid Drug War
2 MIN READ

Trump Deploys 10 F-35 Fighter Jets to Puerto Rico Amid Drug War

WHO Declares Mpox No Longer a Global Health Crisis
1 MIN READ

WHO Declares Mpox No Longer a Global Health Crisis

Sweden's Foreign Minister Meets Zelenskyj to Boost Pressure on Russia
1 MIN READ

Sweden's Foreign Minister Meets Zelenskyj to Boost Pressure on Russia

IAGS Faces Backlash Over Gaza Genocide Resolution
4 MIN READ

IAGS Faces Backlash Over Gaza Genocide Resolution

UK Government Reshuffle: Angela Rayner Resigns, David Lammy Becomes Justice Minister
2 MIN READ

UK Government Reshuffle: Angela Rayner Resigns, David Lammy Becomes Justice Minister

Israeli Military Targets Gaza High-Rises Used by Hamas
1 MIN READ

Israeli Military Targets Gaza High-Rises Used by Hamas

UN Report: Congo Violence Could Be War Crimes
1 MIN READ

UN Report: Congo Violence Could Be War Crimes

Anutin Charnvirakul Elected as Thailand's New Prime Minister
1 MIN READ

Anutin Charnvirakul Elected as Thailand's New Prime Minister

Finland Joins UN Declaration for Peaceful Gaza Solution
1 MIN READ

Finland Joins UN Declaration for Peaceful Gaza Solution

Hamas Releases New Video of Israeli Hostages Amid Ongoing Conflict
2 MIN READ

Hamas Releases New Video of Israeli Hostages Amid Ongoing Conflict

Florida Moves to End All Vaccine Mandates
2 MIN READ

Florida Moves to End All Vaccine Mandates