SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Germany introduces border controls – is Schengen under threat?

Germany's announced border controls are causing tremors in what has been hailed as the EU's greatest creation. Now, concern is growing for the Schengen Area's free movement – and its very existence.

» Updated: September 23 2024

» Published: September 12 2024

Germany introduces border controls – is Schengen under threat?
Photo: Matthias Schrader/AP/TT

On Monday, September 16, temporary German controls will be reintroduced against France, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, and Denmark. This means that the entire country will be covered, since similar controls were already introduced earlier against countries in the east and south.

Exactly how, where, and who will be controlled in the west has not yet been announced. But there is already great concern in neighboring countries about transport and economic consequences.

Just think of all the cross-border commuters. There could be enormous queues, says Martin Deleixhe, migration expert at ULB University in Brussels to the newspaper Le Soir.

"End of Schengen"

When mobility in the EU was restricted during the coronavirus pandemic, the economy was severely affected by mile-long truck queues at the borders. Even the controls that have been carried out since 2015 between Sweden and Denmark have occasionally caused great irritation and delays.

More sample-like controls have indeed been able to continue without major impact, but are not enough if a country wants to be 100 percent sure of who is allowed in or not. If that is to be done, the Schengen system risks becoming worthless.

"Internal border controls that are supposed to have some effect mean the end of Schengen", writes Gerald Knaus, head of the think tank ESI, on X.

Murder in Solingen

The German controls are a consequence of the intense asylum and migration debate that has been sparked in the country after the recent knife attack in Solingen, where a 26-year-old Syrian killed three people.

The government hopes to quickly stop and return people who have been registered as asylum seekers in other EU countries with the help of, among other things, fingerprints.

Interior Minister Nancy Faeser believes that the measures are necessary while waiting for the EU's new asylum and migration pact to be fully implemented in two years.

Before we reach the strong protection of the EU's external borders under the new common asylum system, we must strengthen our national borders, she said earlier in the week.

Orbán pleased

Germany's actions simultaneously strengthen the number of governments and political parties in the EU that are pushing for even tougher measures against migrants and asylum seekers.

"Welcome to the club, Chancellor Scholz", wrote, for example, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán sarcastically on X on Tuesday.

The Schengen cooperation guarantees free travel across borders without controls for member states' citizens and those with valid residence permits.

The cooperation includes all EU countries except Ireland and Cyprus, as well as Norway, Iceland, Switzerland, and Liechtenstein. The name comes from the small town in Luxembourg where a first agreement on the cooperation was reached in 1985.

Member states have the right to reintroduce temporary internal border controls if there are special reasons, such as terrorist threats or protection needs before major events.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Turkish Police Arrest Journalists Covering Istanbul Protests

Turkish Police Arrest Journalists Covering Istanbul Protests

EU Foreign Minister Warns Israel Strikes Risk Escalation

EU Foreign Minister Warns Israel Strikes Risk Escalation

Ukraine Claims Destruction of Russian Helicopters in Belgorod Region

Ukraine Claims Destruction of Russian Helicopters in Belgorod Region

Egypt Proposes New Ceasefire Plan with Hostage Release and Aid to Gaza

Egypt Proposes New Ceasefire Plan with Hostage Release and Aid to Gaza

US Delegation's Greenland Visit Sparks Controversy Over True Intentions

US Delegation's Greenland Visit Sparks Controversy Over True Intentions

Istanbul Mayor Imamoglu Named Opposition Presidential Candidate

Istanbul Mayor Imamoglu Named Opposition Presidential Candidate

Russian Spy Cell in Austria Posed as Ukrainians to Sway Public Opinion

Russian Spy Cell in Austria Posed as Ukrainians to Sway Public Opinion

USA and Russia Begin Ceasefire Talks in Riyadh

USA and Russia Begin Ceasefire Talks in Riyadh

Netanyahu Accuses Security Chief of Unauthorized Probe into Minister

Netanyahu Accuses Security Chief of Unauthorized Probe into Minister

199 Deported Migrants Return to Venezuela from the USA

199 Deported Migrants Return to Venezuela from the USA

Building a New Syria Through Reconciliation Efforts

Building a New Syria Through Reconciliation Efforts

South Korea Court Dismisses Impeachment of Acting President Han

South Korea Court Dismisses Impeachment of Acting President Han

Suspect Swallows $700K Tiffany Earrings in Bold Orlando Heist

Suspect Swallows $700K Tiffany Earrings in Bold Orlando Heist

France Criticizes Turkey Over Istanbul Mayor's Imprisonment

France Criticizes Turkey Over Istanbul Mayor's Imprisonment

Canada Sets April Election Date as Tensions with Trump Rise

Canada Sets April Election Date as Tensions with Trump Rise

EU's Kaja Kallas Visits Israel and West Bank for Key Talks

EU's Kaja Kallas Visits Israel and West Bank for Key Talks

Turkish Regime Jails Istanbul Mayor, Sparking Opposition Tensions

Turkish Regime Jails Istanbul Mayor, Sparking Opposition Tensions

Zelensky Urges Pressure on Putin as US Mediates Ukraine Talks

Zelensky Urges Pressure on Putin as US Mediates Ukraine Talks

Israeli Airstrikes Target Southern Lebanon After Rocket Launch

Israeli Airstrikes Target Southern Lebanon After Rocket Launch

Pope Francis Thanks Supporters in First Appearance After Hospital Stay

Pope Francis Thanks Supporters in First Appearance After Hospital Stay

Three Civilians, Including Two Children, Killed in Sudan Shelling

Three Civilians, Including Two Children, Killed in Sudan Shelling

World War II Bomb in Norway Safely Disarmed by Experts

World War II Bomb in Norway Safely Disarmed by Experts

Imprisoned Istanbul Mayor Imamoglu Poised to Challenge Erdogan

Imprisoned Istanbul Mayor Imamoglu Poised to Challenge Erdogan

Israel Neutralizes Drone Allegedly Launched from Yemen

Israel Neutralizes Drone Allegedly Launched from Yemen

Central Asian Workers Tricked into Ukraine Conflict by Russian Recruiters

Central Asian Workers Tricked into Ukraine Conflict by Russian Recruiters

Russian Drone Strikes on Kyiv Leave Three Dead, Including Child

Russian Drone Strikes on Kyiv Leave Three Dead, Including Child

Israeli Strike Hits Gaza Hospital, Hamas Leader Reportedly Killed

Israeli Strike Hits Gaza Hospital, Hamas Leader Reportedly Killed

Istanbul Mayor Ekrem Imamoglu Dismissed After Arrest

Istanbul Mayor Ekrem Imamoglu Dismissed After Arrest

US Envoy Praises Putin as a Leader and Friend of Trump

US Envoy Praises Putin as a Leader and Friend of Trump

Israelis Rally in Tel Aviv as Opposition Calls for General Strike

Israelis Rally in Tel Aviv as Opposition Calls for General Strike

US Officials Visit Greenland Sparking Speculation on Intentions

US Officials Visit Greenland Sparking Speculation on Intentions

Ten Officers Injured in Dramatic Paris Car Chase

Ten Officers Injured in Dramatic Paris Car Chase

England to Plant 20 Million Trees in First New National Forest in 30 Years

England to Plant 20 Million Trees in First New National Forest in 30 Years

Platform X Closes Accounts in Politically Unstable Turkey

Platform X Closes Accounts in Politically Unstable Turkey

China Eases Marriage Rules to Tackle Population Decline

China Eases Marriage Rules to Tackle Population Decline

Sudanese Refugees Seek Shelter in Chad as Aid Dwindles

Sudanese Refugees Seek Shelter in Chad as Aid Dwindles

Fatah Urges Hamas to Relinquish Control for Palestinian Future

Fatah Urges Hamas to Relinquish Control for Palestinian Future

State of Emergency in South Korea as Forest Fire Claims Four Lives

State of Emergency in South Korea as Forest Fire Claims Four Lives

Trump Decision Forces 500,000 Migrants to Leave the USA

Trump Decision Forces 500,000 Migrants to Leave the USA

Pope Francis Set to Leave Hospital After Pneumonia Treatment

Pope Francis Set to Leave Hospital After Pneumonia Treatment