SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Expert on Trump's Gaza Proposal: Astonishing

Donald Trump's statement about relocating Gazans to neighboring countries has sparked strong reactions. But the question is whether Trump means that the inhabitants should move permanently or only temporarily. It's a stunning statement, says Anders Persson, Israel-Palestine expert at Linnaeus University.

» Published: January 28 2025

Expert on Trump's Gaza Proposal: Astonishing
Photo: Johan Nilsson/TT

Over the weekend, US President Donald Trump stated that the Gaza Strip should be cleared out and that the Gazans should move to, among other places, Egypt or Jordan. A statement that has not been well received among Palestinians and neighboring countries.

He will have a hard time finding buyers for this policy. There is no doubt about it, says Anders Persson.

The Refugee Issue is Crucial

Several million Palestinians are formally refugees in the Middle East and live in neighboring countries where they have limited rights.

The entire narrative around the refugee issue, return, and land is incredibly strong in Palestinian history. We see, for example, at the beginning of the week, how symbolic it was when Palestinians were allowed to return to northern Gaza, says Anders Persson.

A very large part of Gaza's population consists of refugees or descendants of refugees who were driven out or fled during the founding of the State of Israel.

Requires Voluntary Action

The proposal to move Gaza's inhabitants is not entirely inhumane, Persson believes. But the big question is whether the proposal is short- or long-term.

If one thinks about a six-month to one-year period and that the Gazans can then return to rebuilt homes, then it can be a humane solution – if it is voluntary.

But if the idea is that they should not return and that it is a permanent solution, then it is truly astonishing. I cannot recall any other American president having said anything similar, he adds.

But the idea of a two-state solution, which has been driven by American policy previously, is not dead, Persson believes.

Absolute not. Politicians can say a lot of different things in different contexts, in the end, it's all about what they do and not what they say.

Trump tends to come up with bombastic statements.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Testimonies from Gaza: Children walk around without shoes

Testimonies from Gaza: Children walk around without shoes

Musk: Then the First Ship Lifts Off to Mars

Musk: Then the First Ship Lifts Off to Mars

Trump on the 24-hour promise: "I was a bit sarcastic"

Trump on the 24-hour promise: "I was a bit sarcastic"

Tech giants want to train AI on protected material

Tech giants want to train AI on protected material

Dissatisfaction culminates: Giant protest in Belgrade

Dissatisfaction culminates: Giant protest in Belgrade

Urination in the Hot Pot Gave Free Food to Thousands

Urination in the Hot Pot Gave Free Food to Thousands

New Power Outage Paralyzes Cuba

New Power Outage Paralyzes Cuba

Dog shoots owner in USA - "got stuck"

Dog shoots owner in USA - "got stuck"

Starmer: Putin is not serious about peace

Starmer: Putin is not serious about peace

Rescue of Stranded Astronauts Initiated

Rescue of Stranded Astronauts Initiated

The Senate Approves Budget – Prevents Shutdown

The Senate Approves Budget – Prevents Shutdown

Captain suspected of causing another person's death

Captain suspected of causing another person's death

Universities in the USA investigated for racism against whites

Universities in the USA investigated for racism against whites

British Man in Kenya Killed by President's Motorcade

British Man in Kenya Killed by President's Motorcade

Greenlandic party leaders on Trump: "Unacceptable"

Greenlandic party leaders on Trump: "Unacceptable"

UN: Russia has committed crimes against humanity

UN: Russia has committed crimes against humanity

Carney new Prime Minister in Canada

Carney new Prime Minister in Canada

G7 warns Russia – may introduce new sanctions

G7 warns Russia – may introduce new sanctions

Iraq: High-ranking IS leader killed

Iraq: High-ranking IS leader killed

Source: UN agency lays off every fifth employee

Source: UN agency lays off every fifth employee

Teenager sentenced to terror - became a Nazi online

Teenager sentenced to terror - became a Nazi online

New Attack in Bombarded Key City in Sudan

New Attack in Bombarded Key City in Sudan

German parties united – billion investment secured

German parties united – billion investment secured

Hamas: Release the Israeli-American Hostages

Hamas: Release the Israeli-American Hostages

Child dies after rape – protests in Bangladesh

Child dies after rape – protests in Bangladesh

Duterte in court in The Hague via video link

Duterte in court in The Hague via video link

Over 30 dead in cholera outbreak in Ethiopia

Over 30 dead in cholera outbreak in Ethiopia

Internal conflicts threaten the Tigray peace agreement

Internal conflicts threaten the Tigray peace agreement

Measles in Mexico – linked to outbreak in the USA

Measles in Mexico – linked to outbreak in the USA

EU sanctions extended - also against notorious oligarch

EU sanctions extended - also against notorious oligarch

Trump may cause Portugal to skip US planes

Trump may cause Portugal to skip US planes

The Alarm: One Million Myanmar Nationals Will Go Without Emergency Aid

The Alarm: One Million Myanmar Nationals Will Go Without Emergency Aid

Task: Wants to Move the People of Gaza to East Africa

Task: Wants to Move the People of Gaza to East Africa

Trump urges Putin: Spare Ukrainian lives

Trump urges Putin: Spare Ukrainian lives

Iran in China for urgent nuclear deal meeting

Iran in China for urgent nuclear deal meeting

Protested against Israel – may be deported by Trump

Protested against Israel – may be deported by Trump

Democrat leader wants to avoid shutdown in the USA

Democrat leader wants to avoid shutdown in the USA

Australia furious with American who stole wombat

Australia furious with American who stole wombat

Zelensky: Very difficult situation in Kursk

Zelensky: Very difficult situation in Kursk

Finland launches crisis stores

Finland launches crisis stores