SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Expert on Trump's Gaza Plan: No Difference from Crimea

The USA is to take over the Gaza Strip and transform it into the "Riviera of the Middle East", claims Donald Trump. It is without a doubt the most absurd proposal I have seen from a political leader during my lifetime, says Professor of International Law Pål Wrange.

» Published: February 05 2025

Expert on Trump's Gaza Plan: No Difference from Crimea
Photo: Evan Vucci/AP/TT

Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu smiled while Trump laid out the orders for Gaza's future on Tuesday evening.

We're going to own it, the American president stated firmly.

The move is extremely remarkable, according to Pål Wrange, professor of international law at Stockholm University. In practice, Trump is talking about colonizing Gaza, he notes.

Neither the USA nor Israel has the right to take over Gaza. However many resolutions as possible in the UN Security Council have established that the Palestinians have the right to self-determination and the right to form their own state.

"As odd" as the Greenland deal

Wrange compares Trump's Gaza plans to Russia's annexation of Crimea. But not even that was as bizarre, he means.

Legally, there is no greater difference. But there was at least more logic in it since Crimea had belonged to the Russian republic in the Soviet Union until the mid-1950s – and Crimea is close to Russia. Gaza is not close to the USA.

Juridically, there are almost no ways to legally implement what Trump is talking about, according to Jann Kleffner, professor of international law at the Swedish Defence University. One would be if the Palestinians themselves give their consent; the other if the Security Council adopts a binding resolution. Neither is likely or politically sustainable, he says.

Legally, this is at least as odd as saying they're going to own Greenland.

"International hub"

Tuesday's statement – like previous Trump proposals to move all Gaza residents to Jordan or Egypt – sets the fundamental rules for human rights out of play, says Kleffner.

It's flagrant. It's in open conflict with many of the most fundamental principles and rules of international law, such as the right to self-determination, the prohibition of forced displacement and deportation, territorial integrity, and the prohibition of annexation.

During the press conference in Washington, Trump aimed for long-term American ownership of Gaza. Regarding who might live in Gaza in the future, he did not rule out Palestinians, but claimed that the area would become an "international hub".

The most benevolent interpretation is that Trump wants the Palestinians to live somewhere else while the war-torn Gaza is rebuilt, says Pål Wrange.

The Palestinians are of course free to invite Americans or other investors to create a "Middle Eastern Riviera". But Trump doesn't seem to see many Palestinians there in the future.

Gaza is located at the southeastern corner of the Mediterranean. Apart from the sea, the area borders Egypt in the southwest and is otherwise surrounded by Israel.

The population of Gaza has been estimated to be over two million people.

The area was part of the Ottoman Empire for several hundred years, later under British control (1918–48), and after that, in practice, under Egypt. Israel took Gaza in possession in connection with the Six-Day War in 1967.

According to the Oslo Agreement from 1993, Israel should allow the Palestinian Authority, which today leads the limited self-government on the West Bank, some self-government in Gaza. But after a power struggle in 2006–2007, the hardline Islamist Hamas took over the government instead.

Since then, Israel has maintained a blockade against the area, and Egypt has also treated Gaza restrictively. The talks about a two-state solution between Israel and the Palestinians have largely stalled.

Several wars have raged through the years. The current one, which began after Hamas' extensive terrorist attack against Israel on October 7, 2023, is the bloodiest so far.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

HD lectures Trump after outburst about impeachment

HD lectures Trump after outburst about impeachment

Zelensky visits Finland

Zelensky visits Finland

The EU base in Denmark: "Standing up" for Greenland

The EU base in Denmark: "Standing up" for Greenland

Pride Parade Banned in Hungary

Pride Parade Banned in Hungary

Migrants evicted from Paris theater

Migrants evicted from Paris theater

The International Community Reacts Strongly to Israeli Attacks

The International Community Reacts Strongly to Israeli Attacks

Extremists return to Netanyahu's government

Extremists return to Netanyahu's government

Tourist bus overturns in Spain – several injured

Tourist bus overturns in Spain – several injured

EU on Gaza: "The cycle of violence must be broken"

EU on Gaza: "The cycle of violence must be broken"

Sweden still best in EU – tops the list

Sweden still best in EU – tops the list

Germany: Thousands of Billions of Euros for Weapons and Roads

Germany: Thousands of Billions of Euros for Weapons and Roads

Sudden Floods in Southern Spain

Sudden Floods in Southern Spain

Trump attracts researchers from the USA to Belgium

Trump attracts researchers from the USA to Belgium

Kristersson on Putin talks: "The whole world is on edge"

Kristersson on Putin talks: "The whole world is on edge"

Ceasefire Broken: Nightmare Scenes in Gaza

Ceasefire Broken: Nightmare Scenes in Gaza

The EU attempts to rescue Radio Free Europe

The EU attempts to rescue Radio Free Europe

Putin pauses attacks on power plants

Putin pauses attacks on power plants

Plane Crash in the Caribbean – Dozens Dead

Plane Crash in the Caribbean – Dozens Dead

Kristersson: Risk of Complete Escalation

Kristersson: Risk of Complete Escalation

Expert: Broken Ceasefire a Major Setback for Trump

Expert: Broken Ceasefire a Major Setback for Trump

Protest outside Israel's parliament – "sacrificed hostages"

Protest outside Israel's parliament – "sacrificed hostages"

This is why Israel is attacking again: "Extremely pressured"

This is why Israel is attacking again: "Extremely pressured"

Stranded Astronauts on Their Way to Earth

Stranded Astronauts on Their Way to Earth

Expert: Putin knows he must give Trump an answer

Expert: Putin knows he must give Trump an answer

80,000 JFK documents made public

80,000 JFK documents made public

Israel warns Hamas - a new land invasion may be imminent

Israel warns Hamas - a new land invasion may be imminent

Multiple deaths in Israeli attacks in Syria

Multiple deaths in Israeli attacks in Syria

Trump: Parts of Agreement with Russia Clear

Trump: Parts of Agreement with Russia Clear

Over 600 migrants rescued off Tunisia

Over 600 migrants rescued off Tunisia

Rebels pull out of peace talks in Congo-Kinshasa

Rebels pull out of peace talks in Congo-Kinshasa

Seven Dead After Migrant Boat Capsizes

Seven Dead After Migrant Boat Capsizes

Trump wants to revoke Biden's pardons

Trump wants to revoke Biden's pardons

Hungary's ruling party wants to ban pride parade

Hungary's ruling party wants to ban pride parade

EU Gold for "Democracy's Lighthouse"

EU Gold for "Democracy's Lighthouse"

Seven Executed Resistance Fighters Found in Fjord

Seven Executed Resistance Fighters Found in Fjord

Death toll rises after severe weather in the USA

Death toll rises after severe weather in the USA

More Israeli attacks on Gaza

More Israeli attacks on Gaza

Deadly Israeli Attack in Southern Lebanon

Deadly Israeli Attack in Southern Lebanon

Rwanda breaks with Belgium

Rwanda breaks with Belgium

Charge: Firebomb at Ikea was Russian terror

Charge: Firebomb at Ikea was Russian terror