The Secrecy is Lifted on the Prize "that Ruined Everything"

The Nobel Prize to Academy members Harry Martinson and Eyvind Johnson became one of the most debated in history and had devastating consequences. Now, parts of the Academy's discussions in 1974 are being made public.

» Published: January 02 2025

The Secrecy is Lifted on the Prize "that Ruined Everything"
Photo: Olle Lindeborg/TT

The Swedish Nobel Prize was heavily criticized in the Swedish press, particularly by Olof Lagercrantz at Dagens Nyheter, who described it as "a small relapse into nationalism and provincialism".

“A catastrophic decision”, thundered Sven Delblanc in Expressen – a scornful laughter would roll around the world, since the two Swedes were not considered sufficiently translated. Sven-Eric Liedman told Göteborgs-Tidningen that the two were “terribly passé”.

The criticism was heard already before the announcement and at the press conference afterwards, the two prize winners did not express any public joy, according to the SVT documentary “Harry and Eyvind – The Nobel Prize that ruined everything” from last autumn. The attacks in the media took a hard toll on Martinson. Afterwards, the harsh treatment has been cited as a contributing factor to the author taking his life in 1978.

Argued for a Swedish prize

It is now revealed that the Nobel Committee's majority had a shared prize for Harry Martinson and Eyvind Johnson as their first proposal and a shared prize for Nadine Gordimer and Doris Lessing as their second. As a third alternative, Saul Bellow was proposed alone or together with Norman Mailer, and as a fourth, Eugenio Montale. However, Academy member Artur Lundkvist thought that Gordimer and Lessing should receive the prize, which also happened, but not until 1991 and 2007, respectively.

In previous years, the Nobel Committee had referred the question to the Academy. But in 1973, the Committee's chairman Karl Ragnar Gierow paved the way by forcefully arguing that a future Swedish Nobel Prize was possible.

The then three Swedish nominees – Harry Martinson, Eyvind Johnson, and Vilhelm Moberg (who died the same year) – were all worthy of it, according to Gierow, who wrote that they artistically "held their own" against the final candidates in 1973. To never seriously discuss them would mean that any thought of a Swedish Nobel Prize winner was excluded "in the foreseeable future", he emphasized.

Lundkvist opposed

In a now publicized statement from 1972, he describes them as "at least comparable not only with those we primarily discuss" but also with previous winners.

Until then, the discussions about a Swedish Nobel Prize had mainly concerned the suitability of awarding one's own. Artur Lundkvist had in 1972 opposed a Nobel Prize to Johnson and Martinson on these very grounds.

No internal criticism emerges in the statements that the Academy has now made public. Gierow shares the concerns about "incurring sharp foreign criticism" but is "far from certain" that the Academy's decision would be "determined by outsiders' presumed comments".

Harry Martinson received the Nobel Prize for "for an authorship that captures the dewdrop and reflects the cosmos". Eyvind Johnson “for a narrative art that in freedom's service surveys lands and times”. Both were authors from humble origins who, according to Karl Ragnar Gierow, enriched literature with "their riches". Both were members of the Swedish Academy.

In 1974, the shared prize had been proposed by member Johannes Edfelt. Eyvind Johnson was nominated by Johannes Edfelt and Pär Lagerkvist, as well as by three foreign professors, Harry Martinson by Johannes Edfelt and Pär Lagerkvist.

Harry Martinson took his life in 1978, and the harsh treatment from parts of the Swedish press after the Nobel Prize has been cited as a contributing factor.

The Swedish Academy decided in 1972 that no member of the Nobel Committee could be nominated for the Nobel Prize. Eyvind Johnson left the committee at the same time. But if no member of the Academy would ever be able to receive the Nobel Prize, it was something one had to think about already when they were elected, pointed out Karl Ragnar Gierow, chairman of the Nobel Committee.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Swedish Artist Lap-See Lam Wins
1 MIN READ

Swedish Artist Lap-See Lam Wins Prestigious Norwegian Art Prize

Dick Bengtsson's Art Challenges Perceptions
3 MIN READ

Dick Bengtsson's Art Challenges Perceptions at Stockholm Exhibit

Hollywood Remembers Val Kilmer: Tributes
2 MIN READ

Hollywood Remembers Val Kilmer: Tributes Pour in for the Iconic Actor

Tarantino's Hollywood Sequel May Land
1 MIN READ

Tarantino's Hollywood Sequel May Land on Netflix with Fincher Directing

New Films and Series: Minecraft
3 MIN READ

New Films and Series: Minecraft Movie Debuts and More This Week

Susanne Yakes Could Be Chosen
2 MIN READ

Susanne Yakes Could Be Chosen as Listeners' Summer Host on P1

Munich 1972: How Live TV
3 MIN READ

Munich 1972: How Live TV Coverage Changed Journalism Forever

Val Kilmer, Iconic Actor from
2 MIN READ

Val Kilmer, Iconic Actor from Top Gun and Batman, Dies at 65

The Hives Announce New Album
1 MIN READ

The Hives Announce New Album and European Tour Starting October

Meg Westergren Honored with 2023
1 MIN READ

Meg Westergren Honored with 2023 Fatima Prize by Karl Gerhard Society

Authors Demand UK Action on
1 MIN READ

Authors Demand UK Action on Meta Over Alleged Book Copyright Breach

Ane Brun Cancels Istanbul Concert
1 MIN READ

Ane Brun Cancels Istanbul Concert Following Protest Backlash

Marion Brunet Wins Alma Prize
4 MIN READ

Marion Brunet Wins Alma Prize for Young Adult Literature

Oliver Stone to Testify in
1 MIN READ

Oliver Stone to Testify in Congress on New JFK Documents

Maria Montazami and Samir Badran
1 MIN READ

Maria Montazami and Samir Badran Join The Traitors on TV4

Masked Singer Tops TV Ratings
1 MIN READ

Masked Singer Tops TV Ratings with 1.5 Million Viewers

New Beatles Biopics Cast Revealed:
1 MIN READ

New Beatles Biopics Cast Revealed: Mescal, Quinn, Keoghan, Dickinson

World's Largest Children's Book Prize
3 MIN READ

World's Largest Children's Book Prize Set for 1 PM Announcement

Micke Syd Joining Noice as
1 MIN READ

Micke Syd Joining Noice as Drummer Revealed as April Fool's Joke

Meet the New Faces of
2 MIN READ

Meet the New Faces of Married at First Sight Season 12

Sweden's Creative Industries Generate 650
2 MIN READ

Sweden's Creative Industries Generate 650 Billion Kronor Annually

Lady Gaga Adds Third Stockholm
1 MIN READ

Lady Gaga Adds Third Stockholm Show to European Tour

Net Fishing in Torneälven Nominated
1 MIN READ

Net Fishing in Torneälven Nominated for UNESCO Cultural Heritage

Pernilla Wahlgren Welcomes Second Grandchild
1 MIN READ

Pernilla Wahlgren Welcomes Second Grandchild as Oliver Ingrosso Celebrates New Arrival

British Schools to Screen Netflix
1 MIN READ

British Schools to Screen Netflix Hit Adolescence After PM's Endorsement

Laleh's New Album I Am
1 MIN READ

Laleh's New Album I Am Drops June 27 with Summer Tour

New Novels by Sandgren and
1 MIN READ

New Novels by Sandgren and Schulman Explore Teachers' Journeys

Love is Blind Season 2
1 MIN READ

Love is Blind Season 2 Reunion Arrives on Netflix April 3

Sweden Revives Field Artist Training
1 MIN READ

Sweden Revives Field Artist Training After 25-Year Hiatus

Örebro Museum Plans Exhibition on
2 MIN READ

Örebro Museum Plans Exhibition on Risbergska School Tragedy

Netflix Unveils Live-Action Scooby-Doo Series
1 MIN READ

Netflix Unveils Live-Action Scooby-Doo Series Exploring First Mystery

Richard Chamberlain, Iconic TV Star,
2 MIN READ

Richard Chamberlain, Iconic TV Star, Dies at 90

Richard Chamberlain, Beloved TV Icon,
2 MIN READ

Richard Chamberlain, Beloved TV Icon, Dies at 90

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Actor Bruce Glover, Known for Bond Role, Dies at 92

Sigge Eklund's Play Bolero Brings
3 MIN READ

Sigge Eklund's Play Bolero Brings Family Drama to Stockholm Stage

Bob Hund's Thomas Öberg Honored
1 MIN READ

Bob Hund's Thomas Öberg Honored with Hassepris for Humanistic Spirit

Roger Daltrey Shares Vision Loss
1 MIN READ

Roger Daltrey Shares Vision Loss News at Charity Concert

Ferry Svan Advances in Let's
2 MIN READ

Ferry Svan Advances in Let's Dance as Ciara Zelmerlöw Exits

Academy Apologizes to Director Hamdan
1 MIN READ

Academy Apologizes to Director Hamdan Ballal After Criticism

Mammas Nya Kille Returns for
1 MIN READ

Mammas Nya Kille Returns for a Ninth Season on Sveriges Radio