Leak: Netanyahu Mocks Relatives - "What Agreement?"

Those who believe that an agreement with Hamas would "solve everything" are delusional, claims Israel's increasingly pressured Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. In leaked recordings from a meeting with relatives of hostages in Gaza, he is heard contradicting and ridiculing the audience.

» Updated: October 03 2024

» Published: August 26 2024

Leak: Netanyahu Mocks Relatives - "What Agreement?"
Photo: Abir Sultan/Pool Photo via AP/TT

Share this article

I want them here, exclaims a daughter of a hostage during the recorded meeting with the Prime Minister, referring to those who are still being held captive by Hamas.

And I want to walk to Italy in a straight line, Netanyahu responds sarcastically.

The metaphor, in an analysis in the Israeli Haaretz called "astonishing", is one of several comments that have sparked criticism since they leaked from Friday's meeting between Netanyahu and a group of freed hostages and relatives of hostages in Gaza.

In one of the three recordings, released by TV channel Keshet 12, Netanyahu appears to lose patience when meeting participants repeatedly raise the hostages' situation and ask the Prime Minister to accept the agreement on the negotiating table.

What agreement? Which agreement? Whoever says there is an agreement on the table that we haven't accepted for some reason, they're lying, he responds angrily.

Compared to the Holocaust

In the recordings, Netanyahu claims that he is fighting for the country's continued existence in a situation where Hezbollah and Iran want to destroy Israel.

We're not talking about anything else but that agreement. "If we make an agreement, everything will be solved – Iran will stop", etcetera etcetera. It's madness. It's delusions, he says.

A freed hostage questions Netanyahu's emphasis on "victory" in the war against Hamas.

We've already lost on October 7, she says, referring to the terrorist- branded Islamist movement Hamas' brutal attack on Israel, which marked the start of the war.

In the recording, Netanyahu quickly objects – and compares to the mass murders of Jews during the Holocaust.

We didn't lose, he says, and continues:

During the Holocaust, there were 4,500 to 5,000 "October 7" every day.

Defended by his wife

In Haaretz' analysis of the recordings, Netanyahu is described as "heartless" and "totally insensitive". Among other things, he responds to a former hostage's account of torture during captivity by pointing out that he too was once a hostage – during a military exercise.

In Israeli media, his wife Sara is also criticized for "mouthing off" with former hostages and relatives and lacking empathy.

When the responsibility for the October 7 attack is raised, Sara Netanyahu defends her husband by blaming the country's military.

A leader is responsible for his army, responds one of the meeting participants.

Born in 1949 in Tel Aviv. Grew up in Jerusalem, later educated in the USA. In the army, Netanyahu served in an elite unit from 1967 to 1973, when he left the military with the rank of captain.

His older brother Yonatan was part of the same elite unit, but was killed in 1976 during an attempt to free Israeli hostages on a hijacked plane in Uganda. Little brother Benjamin had then begun a career in the USA, but moved back to Israel and entered politics.

Leader of the right-wing party Likud, Prime Minister of Israel 1996–1999 and 2009–2021. In 2022, he managed to regain power, but only after laboriously piecing together a coalition with, among others, small extremist parties.

The process contributed to the perception of Netanyahu as a power-hungry politician. Even before the Gaza war, regular, large street protests were held, then against the government's attempts to shift power from the courts to politics – legislative proposals that sparked accusations of the Prime Minister wanting to curb the judiciary to get away with his own corruption.

Since the outbreak of the Gaza war, large demonstrations against Netanyahu's way of waging war – and inability to bring home hostages held by terrorist-branded Hamas in Gaza – have been held in several Israeli cities.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

French Government Faces Collapse Amid Political Turmoil
4 MIN READ

French Government Faces Collapse Amid Political Turmoil

Two Boys Fatally Stabbed in Melbourne Suburbs
1 MIN READ

Two Boys Fatally Stabbed in Melbourne Suburbs

Deadly Russian Attack Hits Kyiv Government Building
2 MIN READ

Deadly Russian Attack Hits Kyiv Government Building

Chicago Leaders Condemn Trump's Threats as "Repulsive"
2 MIN READ

Chicago Leaders Condemn Trump's Threats as "Repulsive"

Loose Cable Caused Fatal Lisbon Funicular Crash, Investigators Say
1 MIN READ

Loose Cable Caused Fatal Lisbon Funicular Crash, Investigators Say

Family Calls for Health Minister Kennedy's Resignation Over Vaccine Stance
2 MIN READ

Family Calls for Health Minister Kennedy's Resignation Over Vaccine Stance

Car Crashes into French Pizzeria Patio Leaving One Dead
1 MIN READ

Car Crashes into French Pizzeria Patio Leaving One Dead

Over 425 Arrested at Pro-Palestinian Protest in London
1 MIN READ

Over 425 Arrested at Pro-Palestinian Protest in London

Over 50 Killed in Boko Haram Attack in Northeastern Nigeria
2 MIN READ

Over 50 Killed in Boko Haram Attack in Northeastern Nigeria

Hippopotamus Capsizes Boat in Ivory Coast: Eleven Missing
1 MIN READ

Hippopotamus Capsizes Boat in Ivory Coast: Eleven Missing

$1 Million Reward Offered for Capture of Armed Police Killer in Australia
1 MIN READ

$1 Million Reward Offered for Capture of Armed Police Killer in Australia

Gaza Toddler Shamm Finds New Hope with Treatment in Italy
2 MIN READ

Gaza Toddler Shamm Finds New Hope with Treatment in Italy

Russia Boosts Drone Production to 2,700 Monthly
1 MIN READ

Russia Boosts Drone Production to 2,700 Monthly

Hamas Threat to Israel: Analysts Say Eradication Unlikely
7 MIN READ

Hamas Threat to Israel: Analysts Say Eradication Unlikely

Thousands Gather in Milan to Honor Fashion Icon Giorgio Armani
1 MIN READ

Thousands Gather in Milan to Honor Fashion Icon Giorgio Armani

Zelensky Rejects Putin's Moscow Meeting Invitation
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Rejects Putin's Moscow Meeting Invitation

Israel Calls for Evacuation to Contested Humanitarian Zone in Gaza
2 MIN READ

Israel Calls for Evacuation to Contested Humanitarian Zone in Gaza

Norway Election Poll: Red-Greens Lead as Høyre Faces Historic Low
2 MIN READ

Norway Election Poll: Red-Greens Lead as Høyre Faces Historic Low

Large Shark Attack in Sydney Leaves Surfer Dead
1 MIN READ

Large Shark Attack in Sydney Leaves Surfer Dead

Europe Faces Autumn Crisis Amid Trump Tensions
3 MIN READ

Europe Faces Autumn Crisis Amid Trump Tensions