Expert: The Ceasefire in Gaza May Fail

A fragile ceasefire is looming in Gaza. The question is whether it will hold. I think they might manage to hold it together during the first six-week phase. Then it will probably become significantly more difficult, says Middle East expert Isabell Schierenbeck.

» Published: January 17 2025

Expert: The Ceasefire in Gaza May Fail
Photo: Abd al-Karim Hana/AP/TT

It didn't take many minutes after Wednesday's announcement about the ceasefire before the cracks became visible.

Israel accused Hamas of trying to back out of vital parts, which the Palestinian movement denied. Thursday's meeting where Israel was to formally give the agreement the green light was postponed until Friday.

At the same time, new bombs fell over the Gaza Strip. Half a day after the announcement of an agreement, reports emerged of over 70 dead.

Popular Demands

Middle East expert Isabell Schierenbeck, professor of political science at the University of Gothenburg, notes that the situation is extremely fragile. But she believes that the agreed ceasefire will come into effect on Sunday.

I believe it is likely. The pressure on the parties and mediators from the outgoing and incoming presidents of the USA, that they have gone out and proclaimed that there is a deal, is very important here. But then the parties are also in a situation that looks different than before.

On the Israeli side, there are political divisions and, as more soldiers die, increased popular demands for peace and prisoner exchange agreements, says Schierenbeck. At the same time, Hamas is severely weakened: its leadership is largely eliminated, its arms supply is strangled, and its allies in Lebanon and Iran have lost ground.

Critical voices against Hamas are also being heard from the population in Gaza, she says.

Border Drawing

The ceasefire is divided into three phases. Schierenbeck doubts that they will unfold without friction.

There will definitely be bigger or smaller problems along the way.

The parties will have to accept various violations, she predicts. In the absence of international observers, Israel and Hamas are largely left to decide for themselves where the border goes. When things heat up, a great responsibility lies with the mediators.

Usually, you can turn a blind eye to smaller violations. But if they become too many and too large, it won't work anymore.

Big Difference

The formulations regarding the duration of the ceasefire have been one of the major stumbling blocks during the negotiations, which has raised concerns that the parties do not really want lasting peace. Isabell Schierenbeck says it is difficult to know.

Israel may not think it has achieved all its goals with the war, the same with Hamas. Now it's about how the parties manage to sell the ceasefire to their respective populations – how they argue that they are emerging victorious from the whole thing.

But regardless of how long the ceasefire lasts, it will make a big difference. Both for the civilian population in Gaza and for the families in Israel who get their loved ones back.

At 12:15 on Sunday, all weapons will be laid down and all violence will cease for six weeks.

During that time, new negotiations will be held on how the parties will proceed in phase two and three.

Much is still unclear, but the overall goal is a prisoner exchange and to "return to a sustainable calm" to achieve a permanent ceasefire between the parties, according to a copy of the agreement obtained by The Times of Israel.

In the first phase of the agreement, 33 Israeli prisoners will be released in exchange for a large number of Palestinians imprisoned in Israel. Further prisoner exchanges will take place in later stages.

In the third phase, Israel will completely leave the Gaza Strip and a reconstruction plan for Gaza's future will be initiated under international supervision.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

UAE Court Sentences Three Uzbeks
1 MIN READ

UAE Court Sentences Three Uzbeks to Death for Rabbi's Murder

Central Asian Nations Resolve Fergana
1 MIN READ

Central Asian Nations Resolve Fergana Valley Dispute

1,001 Killed in Gaza After
1 MIN READ

1,001 Killed in Gaza After Ceasefire Ends, Health Officials Report

Putin Open to Talks with
1 MIN READ

Putin Open to Talks with Trump Despite Recent Tensions

Democrats Seek New Leadership as
6 MIN READ

Democrats Seek New Leadership as Trump Dominates US Politics

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Explosion in Spanish Coal Mine Claims Five Lives

Hamas Urges Global Resistance to
1 MIN READ

Hamas Urges Global Resistance to Trump's Controversial Gaza Plan

Families Hold Vigil at Bangkok
2 MIN READ

Families Hold Vigil at Bangkok Skyscraper Collapse Site

Swedish Man Extradited to Norway
1 MIN READ

Swedish Man Extradited to Norway in Major Drug Trafficking Case

Netanyahu Aides Detained in Qatargate
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Aides Detained in Qatargate Probe

Marine Le Pen Barred from
3 MIN READ

Marine Le Pen Barred from 2027 Election After EU Funds Verdict

Zelensky Prepares for Possible Ukrainian
1 MIN READ

Zelensky Prepares for Possible Ukrainian Election This Summer

Three Missing US Soldiers in
1 MIN READ

Three Missing US Soldiers in Lithuania Found Dead

Russia Accuses Ukraine of Power
2 MIN READ

Russia Accuses Ukraine of Power Line Attacks Amid Drone Strikes

Israel Urges Palestinians in Southern
1 MIN READ

Israel Urges Palestinians in Southern Gaza to Relocate to al-Mawasi

Iran Vows Powerful Response if
1 MIN READ

Iran Vows Powerful Response if US Launches Attack

Three Found Dead in Southern
1 MIN READ

Three Found Dead in Southern Norway; Police Investigate Link

Netanyahu Appoints New Security Chief
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Appoints New Security Chief Despite Court Block and Protests

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 2,000
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 2,000 Lives, Thousands Injured

Le Pen's Presidential Hopes in
3 MIN READ

Le Pen's Presidential Hopes in Jeopardy as Fraud Verdict Looms

Trump Accuses Zelenskyj of Backing
1 MIN READ

Trump Accuses Zelenskyj of Backing Out of US Mineral Deal

Zelensky Thanks Stubb for Finland's
2 MIN READ

Zelensky Thanks Stubb for Finland's Support After Trump Golf Diplomacy

Ice Storm Leaves 500,000 Without
1 MIN READ

Ice Storm Leaves 500,000 Without Power Across US and Canada

Islamic Extremists Suspected in Deadly
1 MIN READ

Islamic Extremists Suspected in Deadly Attack on Burkina Faso Soldiers

Trump Hints at Third Term
1 MIN READ

Trump Hints at Third Term Despite Constitutional Limits

Erna Solberg Witnesses Ukraine's War
1 MIN READ

Erna Solberg Witnesses Ukraine's War Devastation on Frontline Journey

US Students Face Deportation Over
3 MIN READ

US Students Face Deportation Over Alleged Pro-Palestinian Support

Red Cross Condemns Israeli Attack
1 MIN READ

Red Cross Condemns Israeli Attack on Ambulance Workers in Rafah

Trump Warns of Strikes if
1 MIN READ

Trump Warns of Strikes if Iran Rejects Peace Deal Proposal

Trump Frustrated with Putin Over
1 MIN READ

Trump Frustrated with Putin Over Ukraine, Threatens New Tariffs

Erdogan Urges PKK to Disarm
1 MIN READ

Erdogan Urges PKK to Disarm Without Delay

Tsunami Warning Lifted After 7.1
1 MIN READ

Tsunami Warning Lifted After 7.1 Earthquake Near Tonga

Netanyahu Urges Hamas to Disarm
2 MIN READ

Netanyahu Urges Hamas to Disarm in Ceasefire Talks

Norwegian Rocket Test Ends in
2 MIN READ

Norwegian Rocket Test Ends in Crash but Deemed a Success by Isar Aerospace

Sudanese Army Takes Control of
2 MIN READ

Sudanese Army Takes Control of Khartum as RSF Withdraws

Israeli Defense Intercepts Yemeni Robot
1 MIN READ

Israeli Defense Intercepts Yemeni Robot as Air Raid Sirens Sound

Netanyahu Heads to EU Despite
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Heads to EU Despite ICC Arrest Warrant

US Pledges Strong Military Presence
1 MIN READ

US Pledges Strong Military Presence in Taiwan Strait to Deter China

Greenland's Prime Minister Firmly Rejects
2 MIN READ

Greenland's Prime Minister Firmly Rejects Trump's Takeover Claims

Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills
1 MIN READ

Israeli Airstrike in Gaza Kills Eight, Including Five Children