Despite massive criticism – anonymous witnesses are now allowed

After years of debate and two government inquiries, it is finally becoming a reality: Anonymous witnesses are being allowed in Swedish courts. The government hopes that it can break the culture of silence surrounding gangs, while heavyweight lawyers warn of zero or opposite effect.

» Published: January 01 2025

Despite massive criticism – anonymous witnesses are now allowed
Photo: Johan Nilsson/TT

The 27th of November 2024, the government's proposal on anonymous witnesses was passed in the Riksdag. With the law now in effect, it is possible for individuals to testify anonymously in investigations and trials under certain circumstances.

The law comes after a prolonged political debate, where the Social Democrats were initially opposed but suddenly changed their stance in the fall of 2024 and became positive towards the proposal.

The issue was first investigated in 2021 on the S-government's initiative. The investigator, Stefan Johansson, then believed that the drawbacks from a legal security perspective outweighed the benefits and that anonymous witnesses should not be allowed.

He argued, among other things, that the evidentiary value is too limited to restrict the fundamental principle of both parties having equal insight into the material.

Not Used

The investigation also noted that in countries where it existed, such as Denmark and Norway, it was hardly ever used.

It has not been possible to apply in court. The evidence presented anonymously has no value, says Joakim Nergelius, professor of law at Örebro University.

But the then opposition held fast to the issue. After the election, the government and the SD agreed to introduce anonymous witnesses. A new investigation was set up and presented its proposals in the fall of 2023.

It received harsh criticism from several instances – including the Chancellor of Justice and the Court Administration, who warned that the system could lead to fewer people willing to testify openly.

No from the Law Council

The government went ahead anyway, submitting the proposal to the Law Council – which also strongly advised against it. The Council wrote, among other things, that the added value "appears to be very limited" and that it could lead to "courts receiving poorer basis for judgment".

After several changes, the government still presented the proposal to the Riksdag. Justice Minister Gunnar Strömmer then said that even if one does not know if the benefits outweigh the drawbacks, one needs to try new measures.

Professor of Law Joakim Nergelius is critical of this approach.

Responsible politicians should care more about the rule of law. It is a nonchalant attitude to say "let's try" when it comes to fundamental legal security values, he says.

He believes that the government's actions, like the Social Democrats' changed stance, can be explained by politicians wanting to show action to voters who demand "tough measures".

It's not just the politicians' fault. There is a repressive atmosphere in a large part of public opinion that they satisfy. It is alarming and something we should talk more about.

A prosecutor, a suspect, or a defendant may apply to the district court for a witness to be heard anonymously during an investigation or trial.

The application can be approved if there is a "significant risk" that the witness or their relatives would otherwise be exposed to serious crime.

The sentence for the crime the witness is to testify about must correspond to at least two years' imprisonment.

The reason for anonymity must "outweigh" the difficulties it poses for a suspect or defendant to defend themselves.

Other measures to protect the witness must be considered insufficient or significantly more difficult to implement, and it must otherwise be appropriate to hear the witness anonymously.

The court that tries the case shall not have knowledge of the anonymous witness's identity, a public counsel shall be appointed to monitor legal security issues in the case, and the court's decision shall be appealable.

Source: The Riksdag

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Bribery Convictions in Sweden See
1 MIN READ

Bribery Convictions in Sweden See Rise in Gross Offenses

Suspect Detained in Norrköping Murder
1 MIN READ

Suspect Detained in Norrköping Murder Investigation

Sabotage Cuts Power to 500
1 MIN READ

Sabotage Cuts Power to 500 Homes in Småland, Police Investigate

Twelve Indicted in Major Scania
1 MIN READ

Twelve Indicted in Major Scania Drug Network Bust

Sun-Seeking App Trend Raises Skin
2 MIN READ

Sun-Seeking App Trend Raises Skin Cancer Concerns in Sweden

Sweden Braces for Year's Warmest
1 MIN READ

Sweden Braces for Year's Warmest Day Before Cold Snap Hits

Online Sect's Influence on Teen
4 MIN READ

Online Sect's Influence on Teen Knife Attacks Faces Court Scrutiny

Swedish Man Sentenced to 10
1 MIN READ

Swedish Man Sentenced to 10 Years for Long-Term Abuse of Relative

Man Critically Injured in Sollefteå
1 MIN READ

Man Critically Injured in Sollefteå Workplace Accident

Child Seriously Injured After Fall
1 MIN READ

Child Seriously Injured After Fall from Window in Stockholm

Sweden's Spring Covid Vaccine Campaign
2 MIN READ

Sweden's Spring Covid Vaccine Campaign Focuses on High-Risk Groups

Stockholm Police Launch Pilot to
2 MIN READ

Stockholm Police Launch Pilot to Curb Violence Against Women

Anna-Karin Hatt Declines Centre Party
1 MIN READ

Anna-Karin Hatt Declines Centre Party Leadership Role

Expert Group to Guide Västra
1 MIN READ

Expert Group to Guide Västra Götaland After Millennium System Setback

Kristersson Calls for Doubling Sweden's
3 MIN READ

Kristersson Calls for Doubling Sweden's Conscription Numbers

Woman in Her 60s Killed
1 MIN READ

Woman in Her 60s Killed in Collision with Truck Near Kristianstad

Three Men Charged in Assault
1 MIN READ

Three Men Charged in Assault and Rape Case in Kristianstad

Sweden Proposes Stricter Housing Rules
3 MIN READ

Sweden Proposes Stricter Housing Rules for New Immigrants

Woman Prosecuted for Forcing Women
1 MIN READ

Woman Prosecuted for Forcing Women into Sex Work at Malmö Massage Parlor

Swedish Authorities to Probe Lexbase
1 MIN READ

Swedish Authorities to Probe Lexbase and Krimfup for GDPR Compliance

Swedish Police Arrest 15 in
2 MIN READ

Swedish Police Arrest 15 in Global Crackdown on Child Abuse Site

Father and Brother Sentenced in
3 MIN READ

Father and Brother Sentenced in Sweden for Honor Killing of 22-Year-Old

Current Laws Sufficient to Tackle
1 MIN READ

Current Laws Sufficient to Tackle Hunting Sabotage, Says Investigator

Social Democrats Push to End
2 MIN READ

Social Democrats Push to End Sick Pay Deduction in Sweden

Kristersson: Sweden Intensifies Efforts for
2 MIN READ

Kristersson: Sweden Intensifies Efforts for Journalist Detained in Turkey

Kristersson: EU Ready to Tackle
2 MIN READ

Kristersson: EU Ready to Tackle US Tariffs Together

Google to Slow Pixel Phone
2 MIN READ

Google to Slow Pixel Phone Charging for Better Battery Health

Teen Sentenced to Nearly 9
1 MIN READ

Teen Sentenced to Nearly 9 Years for Murder of 16-Year-Old in Stockholm

Suspected Sinkhole Disrupts Gothenburg Tram
1 MIN READ

Suspected Sinkhole Disrupts Gothenburg Tram Lines 4, 7, 9, and 11

Sweden Allocates 500 Million Kronor
2 MIN READ

Sweden Allocates 500 Million Kronor to Enhance Psychiatric Care

Postcode Lottery Halts Phone Sales
2 MIN READ

Postcode Lottery Halts Phone Sales After Aggressive Tactics Exposed

Sweden Faces Pension Debate as
2 MIN READ

Sweden Faces Pension Debate as Calls for Fee Hike Intensify

Boy Under 15 Arrested in
1 MIN READ

Boy Under 15 Arrested in Attempted Murder Case in Sweden

Report Highlights Workplace Vulnerability of
2 MIN READ

Report Highlights Workplace Vulnerability of Young Women in Sweden

Fasting Three Days a Week
3 MIN READ

Fasting Three Days a Week Yields Greater Weight Loss Than Calorie Cutting

Medicine Turns Human Blood Toxic
2 MIN READ

Medicine Turns Human Blood Toxic to Mosquitoes, Offering Malaria Hope

Explosion at Malmö Apartment Building
1 MIN READ

Explosion at Malmö Apartment Building Under Investigation

Two Seriously Injured in Ydre
1 MIN READ

Two Seriously Injured in Ydre Car Crash; Police Investigate Negligence

Suspicious Object in Malmö Deemed
1 MIN READ

Suspicious Object in Malmö Deemed Harmless by Police

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of
1 MIN READ

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of Sami Truth Commission