Criticism of TV4 for audio clip from massacre

Ten sound technicians are speaking out in the magazine Kvartal and criticizing TV4 for the channel's disputed publication of a clip from the school shooting in Örebro.

» Published:

Criticism of TV4 for audio clip from massacre
Photo: Kicki Nilsson/TT

Share this article

The day after the massacre, TV4 News published a video clip from the event, filmed from inside a toilet at Risbergska, where someone is claimed to have shouted "you should get out of Europe" during the ongoing shooting.

According to TV4, they came to this conclusion by letting sound technicians filter the sound and then having "several people without prior knowledge" listen.

The information has spread widely, both in Sweden and in foreign media, but has also been criticized from several quarters.

Sound technicians question

In an open letter in Kvartal, ten experienced sound technicians question whether it is possible to hear what is being said on the recording.

"A professional and knowledgeable sound technician would not have said that it is possible to discern the meaning of the words spoken in the macabre video with any precision," they write.

TV4 News' responsible publisher Fredrick Malmberg says he is completely confident in the publication.

You should know that the two people we had analyze this are extremely experienced. They work with sound, it's their job to hear what people say and make technical solutions to make it sound better, he said on Saturday's Medierna i P1.

"Ill-affected"

The letter writers criticize Malmberg for implying that TV4 has access to special equipment and expertise that others do not, which they claim is not true.

"Many of us in our forum have instead become ill-affected by the fact that our professional skills and professional honor seem to be used as an alibi for irresponsible and sensationalist click journalism," they write.

TT has sought TV4.

In Dagens Media, Fredrick Malmberg comments on the criticism from the sound technicians:

At the core, this is a journalistic decision made based on a foundation that I have received. I also note that no one is saying that it's wrong, they just have objections to our method.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Government Boosts Environmental Compensation for Freight Trains

Government Boosts Environmental Compensation for Freight Trains

More Voters Expected in Next Year's Swedish Election

More Voters Expected in Next Year's Swedish Election

Pandemic Face Masks Pose Environmental Risk with Microplastics and Chemicals

Pandemic Face Masks Pose Environmental Risk with Microplastics and Chemicals

Teen Girl Stabbed in Borås; Suspect of Same Age Arrested

Teen Girl Stabbed in Borås; Suspect of Same Age Arrested

Algal Bloom Crisis Worsens at British Isles' Largest Lake Lough Neagh

Algal Bloom Crisis Worsens at British Isles' Largest Lake Lough Neagh

Man in His 70s Dies in Drowning Accident at Motala Beach

Man in His 70s Dies in Drowning Accident at Motala Beach

Government Plans to Add Chickenpox Vaccine to Child Vaccination Program

Government Plans to Add Chickenpox Vaccine to Child Vaccination Program

Gang Leader Among Two Escapees from Borås Detention Center

Gang Leader Among Two Escapees from Borås Detention Center

Stolen Swedish Data from Miljödata Leaked on Darknet, Expert Warns

Stolen Swedish Data from Miljödata Leaked on Darknet, Expert Warns

How to Avoid Salmonella: Tips for Safe Egg and Food Handling

How to Avoid Salmonella: Tips for Safe Egg and Food Handling

Södermalm Explosion Deemed a Misfire by Police

Södermalm Explosion Deemed a Misfire by Police

Hackers Threaten to Release Personal Data After Miljödata Breach

Hackers Threaten to Release Personal Data After Miljödata Breach

Gotland Braces for Heavy Rain as SMHI Issues Yellow Warning

Gotland Braces for Heavy Rain as SMHI Issues Yellow Warning

Swedish Potato Farmers Face PFAS Dilemma Amid Consumer Demands

Swedish Potato Farmers Face PFAS Dilemma Amid Consumer Demands

Head-on Collision on E4 in Huskvarna Sends Five to Hospital

Head-on Collision on E4 in Huskvarna Sends Five to Hospital

Kristersson Criticizes Stegrud's Actions in Stockholm Incident

Kristersson Criticizes Stegrud's Actions in Stockholm Incident

Kristersson Invites Center Party to Join Growth Pact

Kristersson Invites Center Party to Join Growth Pact

Swedish Citizens Extradited from Dubai Arrested for Serious Crimes

Swedish Citizens Extradited from Dubai Arrested for Serious Crimes

SMHI Issues New Rain Warning for Flood-Hit Västernorrland

SMHI Issues New Rain Warning for Flood-Hit Västernorrland

Man Arrested for Murder of Elderly Man in Skurup

Man Arrested for Murder of Elderly Man in Skurup