Ten doctors: Advice as meaningless as New Year's resolutions

Ten general practitioners slam the National Board of Health's new guidelines with advice on care for unhealthy lifestyles.

» Published:

Ten doctors: Advice as meaningless as New Year's resolutions
Photo: Jonas Ekströmer/TT

Share this article

The studies that the National Board of Health and Welfare relies on are, the doctors claim in DN debate, poorly substantiated and the guidelines are therefore as effective and meaningful as New Year's resolutions. And they are very time-consuming and expensive.

"New Year's resolutions are at least free", they note and point out that the National Board of Health and Welfare itself estimates that it will cost over 800 million kronor for primary care to follow just part of the advice on healthcare for "unhealthy lifestyles", such as giving advice on alcohol, tobacco, diet, and exercise.

The groups that the National Board of Health and Welfare wants the counseling to be directed towards are the majority of all patients, they emphasize, and highlight that an average visit to primary care takes 20 minutes. And the National Board of Health and Welfare seems to think that a large part of that time should be spent on talking about lifestyles, not about what the patient is seeking care for.

"Seriously ill, frail, and elderly patients will be pushed aside if healthcare is to spend more time on younger and healthier people's lifestyles", write the ten representatives of the Council for Sustainable Diagnostics and Treatment, within the Swedish Association for General Medicine.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Water Restored in Solna and Sundbyberg After Leak

Water Restored in Solna and Sundbyberg After Leak

Suspected Dangerous Object Found in Stockholm Prompts Investigation

Suspected Dangerous Object Found in Stockholm Prompts Investigation

Man Stabbed to Avoid Military Service Fined Along with Accomplice

Man Stabbed to Avoid Military Service Fined Along with Accomplice

Psilocybin from Mushrooms Tested for Anorexia Treatment in Pilot Study

Psilocybin from Mushrooms Tested for Anorexia Treatment in Pilot Study

Kramfors Residents Urged to Boil Drinking Water Due to Contamination

Kramfors Residents Urged to Boil Drinking Water Due to Contamination

Uddevalla Municipality Files Police Report on Home Care Service Issues

Uddevalla Municipality Files Police Report on Home Care Service Issues

Girl in Bålsta Suspected of Planning School Murder

Girl in Bålsta Suspected of Planning School Murder

Seven Detained in Major Raid on Waterpipe Tobacco Tax Evasion Network

Seven Detained in Major Raid on Waterpipe Tobacco Tax Evasion Network

Police Confident in Reversing Gang Violence Trend

Police Confident in Reversing Gang Violence Trend

Three Swedes Arrested in Portugal for Elderly Fraud Scheme

Three Swedes Arrested in Portugal for Elderly Fraud Scheme

Sweden Boosts Civil Defense Budget by 3 Billion Kronor

Sweden Boosts Civil Defense Budget by 3 Billion Kronor

Four Sentenced to Prison for Taking Girl Abroad Against Her Will

Four Sentenced to Prison for Taking Girl Abroad Against Her Will

Protest Near Stockholm Jewish School Targets Israeli Soldier

Protest Near Stockholm Jewish School Targets Israeli Soldier

Opposition Parties Blocked from Summoning Migration Minister to Committee

Opposition Parties Blocked from Summoning Migration Minister to Committee

Decent Jeans Now Permitted in Parliament Dress Code Update

Decent Jeans Now Permitted in Parliament Dress Code Update

Hungary Responds to Kristersson's Criticism: Sweden Is Also Lying

Hungary Responds to Kristersson's Criticism: Sweden Is Also Lying

Live Hand Grenade Found in Malmö's Hyllie District

Live Hand Grenade Found in Malmö's Hyllie District

Government to Invest 4.3 Billion Kronor in Schools Next Year

Government to Invest 4.3 Billion Kronor in Schools Next Year

Sweden's Agenda 2030 Efforts Face Criticism for Lack of Direction

Sweden's Agenda 2030 Efforts Face Criticism for Lack of Direction

Only One of 80 Large Shelters in Sweden Upgraded

Only One of 80 Large Shelters in Sweden Upgraded