Ten doctors: Advice as meaningless as New Year's resolutions

Ten general practitioners slam the National Board of Health's new guidelines with advice on care for unhealthy lifestyles.

» Published: January 01 2025

Ten doctors: Advice as meaningless as New Year's resolutions
Photo: Jonas Ekströmer/TT

Share this article

The studies that the National Board of Health and Welfare relies on are, the doctors claim in DN debate, poorly substantiated and the guidelines are therefore as effective and meaningful as New Year's resolutions. And they are very time-consuming and expensive.

"New Year's resolutions are at least free", they note and point out that the National Board of Health and Welfare itself estimates that it will cost over 800 million kronor for primary care to follow just part of the advice on healthcare for "unhealthy lifestyles", such as giving advice on alcohol, tobacco, diet, and exercise.

The groups that the National Board of Health and Welfare wants the counseling to be directed towards are the majority of all patients, they emphasize, and highlight that an average visit to primary care takes 20 minutes. And the National Board of Health and Welfare seems to think that a large part of that time should be spent on talking about lifestyles, not about what the patient is seeking care for.

"Seriously ill, frail, and elderly patients will be pushed aside if healthcare is to spend more time on younger and healthier people's lifestyles", write the ten representatives of the Council for Sustainable Diagnostics and Treatment, within the Swedish Association for General Medicine.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Social Democrats Propose Profit Ban in Preschools After Scandal
2 MIN READ

Social Democrats Propose Profit Ban in Preschools After Scandal

SMHI Warns of Heavy Rain and Flood Risk in Western Sweden
1 MIN READ

SMHI Warns of Heavy Rain and Flood Risk in Western Sweden

Suspect Identified in Malmö Train Accident Investigation
1 MIN READ

Suspect Identified in Malmö Train Accident Investigation

Kristersson and Åkesson Disagree Over Stegrud's Cultural Canon Remarks
2 MIN READ

Kristersson and Åkesson Disagree Over Stegrud's Cultural Canon Remarks

Man Sentenced for Insulting Police Officer in Landmark Case
1 MIN READ

Man Sentenced for Insulting Police Officer in Landmark Case

Norwegian Man Arrested After Double Murder in Gothenburg
3 MIN READ

Norwegian Man Arrested After Double Murder in Gothenburg

Four Suspected of Kidnapping in Växjö as Missing Woman Found Safe
1 MIN READ

Four Suspected of Kidnapping in Växjö as Missing Woman Found Safe

Boulder Blocks Ore Railway Trains Between Luleå and Narvik
1 MIN READ

Boulder Blocks Ore Railway Trains Between Luleå and Narvik

Government Proposes Stricter Rules for Dangerous Dog Ownership
2 MIN READ

Government Proposes Stricter Rules for Dangerous Dog Ownership

Hesa Fredrik Test Fails in Scania Due to Technical Issues
1 MIN READ

Hesa Fredrik Test Fails in Scania Due to Technical Issues

Woman Sentenced for Moving Park Bench in Romantic Gesture
1 MIN READ

Woman Sentenced for Moving Park Bench in Romantic Gesture

Woman Found Dead in Västerås; Murder Investigation Launched
1 MIN READ

Woman Found Dead in Västerås; Murder Investigation Launched

Increased GPS Disruptions in Swedish Airspace Over Baltic Sea
2 MIN READ

Increased GPS Disruptions in Swedish Airspace Over Baltic Sea

Malmö Apartment Targeted in Second Shooting Incident
2 MIN READ

Malmö Apartment Targeted in Second Shooting Incident

Extreme Fires Becoming Common in Portugal and Spain
2 MIN READ

Extreme Fires Becoming Common in Portugal and Spain

Minister Warns of Dangers in Normalizing Choking Sex Among Youth
2 MIN READ

Minister Warns of Dangers in Normalizing Choking Sex Among Youth

Choking Sex Poses Serious Risks: Safe Words Often Fail, Experts Warn
4 MIN READ

Choking Sex Poses Serious Risks: Safe Words Often Fail, Experts Warn

Using a Phone on the Toilet May Raise Hemorrhoid Risk by 46%
2 MIN READ

Using a Phone on the Toilet May Raise Hemorrhoid Risk by 46%

Pharmacy Employee Avoids Prison for 135 Fake Prescriptions
1 MIN READ

Pharmacy Employee Avoids Prison for 135 Fake Prescriptions

Police Probe Connection Between Double Explosions in Östergötland
2 MIN READ

Police Probe Connection Between Double Explosions in Östergötland