Judge Blocks Trump's Proposal on Citizenship

A federal judge in Seattle temporarily stops President Donald Trump's attempt to prevent children born in the USA from automatically becoming American citizens. Trump will appeal the court's decision.

» Published: January 23 2025

Judge Blocks Trump's Proposal on Citizenship
Photo: Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP/TT

In a court hearing, Judge John Coughenour issued a ruling that the proposal cannot currently be implemented. The hearing lasted just under half an hour.

I have led court hearings for over four decades. I cannot recall any other case where the question that arises is as clear-cut as in this one. This is an obviously unconstitutional decision, said the judge about Trump's decree.

The Trump administration had previously announced that the proposal would be implemented on February 19.

The atmosphere in the courtroom was tense when the Justice Department's lawyer Brett Shumate presented the arguments for the citizenship decision. Judge Coughenour interrupted the lawyer with the direct question of whether he saw the decree as correct according to the Constitution.

Trump later announced on Thursday evening that the court ruling in Seattle would be appealed.

The states of Arizona, Illinois, Oregon, and Washington, all governed by Democrats, are behind the demand to stop Trump's decision. In total, around 20 states and several organizations have questioned Trump's decision.

A person born in the USA becomes an American citizen, even if their parents do not have American citizenship. The right is not written into the US Constitution, but is established in the 14th amendment to the Constitution from 1868, after the American Civil War.

The constitutional paragraph was last questioned in 1898, but its validity was then confirmed by the Supreme Court.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting
1 MIN READ

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting in Gaza Strip

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives
1 MIN READ

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives as Recovery Efforts Continue

Norovirus Outbreak Hits Queen Mary
1 MIN READ

Norovirus Outbreak Hits Queen Mary 2 Cruise, Over 240 Affected

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold
1 MIN READ

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold Passes Away

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package
1 MIN READ

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package to Ukraine

Russia Not on US Tariff
2 MIN READ

Russia Not on US Tariff List Despite Broad Global Reach

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women
1 MIN READ

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women and Newborns, Says Save the Children

Tragic Boat Sinking Off Lesbos
1 MIN READ

Tragic Boat Sinking Off Lesbos Claims Lives of Migrants, Including Children

Search for Missing MH370 Paused
1 MIN READ

Search for Missing MH370 Paused Until Year-End, Says Malaysia

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze
1 MIN READ

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze in Rome; Italy Boosts Security Measures

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Strikes in Syria Leave Nine Civilians Dead, Tensions Rise

US Calls for UN Official's
1 MIN READ

US Calls for UN Official's Removal Over Alleged Anti-Semitic Views

Putin's Envoy Meets US Officials
1 MIN READ

Putin's Envoy Meets US Officials in Washington for Ceasefire Talks

Over 20 Palestinians Killed in
1 MIN READ

Over 20 Palestinians Killed in Israeli Air Strikes on Gaza Strip

Hungary to Exit ICC Following
2 MIN READ

Hungary to Exit ICC Following Netanyahu's Visit

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350
1 MIN READ

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350 Bears After Fatal Attack

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Air Strikes in Syria Leave Four Dead, Hit Military Sites

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of
1 MIN READ

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of Signal Raises Security Concerns

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland During Challenging Times

Elon Musk Expected to Exit
2 MIN READ

Elon Musk Expected to Exit White House Role Soon, Sources Say

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's
2 MIN READ

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's Journalist Arrest Before Key Meeting

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges
1 MIN READ

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges Against NYC Mayor Adams

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences
1 MIN READ

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences for Americans in Coup Plot

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as
2 MIN READ

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as Netanyahu Visits Budapest

Putin and Trump Not Meeting
1 MIN READ

Putin and Trump Not Meeting in Saudi Arabia, Kremlin Confirms

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks
2 MIN READ

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks Regional Condemnation

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro
1 MIN READ

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro Boost to Defense by 2036

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in
1 MIN READ

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in Alleged US Airstrikes in Yemen

Sperm Whale Found Dead on
1 MIN READ

Sperm Whale Found Dead on Danish Beach Near Aarhus

Argentina Opens Secret Files on
1 MIN READ

Argentina Opens Secret Files on Nazi Refugees and Their Financiers

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK
1 MIN READ

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK History Faces New Allegations

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins
2 MIN READ

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins Key Wisconsin Supreme Court Election

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to Aid Earthquake Relief Efforts

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor
3 MIN READ

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor Through Gaza Strip

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns Over US Interest Persist

China Wraps Up Military Drills
2 MIN READ

China Wraps Up Military Drills Near Taiwan, Raising Regional Tensions

White House Evaluates Economic Impact
2 MIN READ

White House Evaluates Economic Impact of Potential Greenland Acquisition

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored
2 MIN READ

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored by Queen, Dies at 101

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington Visit for Key Talks

Four Killed in Russian Drone
1 MIN READ

Four Killed in Russian Drone Attack on Ukrainian City Kryvyj Rih