Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk entirely different penalties. One can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, PhD student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

» Updated: August 06 2024

» Published: July 26 2024

Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties
Photo: Andreas Hillergren/TT

Share this article

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk completely different penalties.

The one can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, Ph.D. student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

A 15-year-old girl has been arrested, suspected of murdering a high school-aged girl in Landskrona.

Another girl figures in the investigation as a suspect for the same crime. But the girl is under 15 years old and cannot be detained or convicted.

You cannot initiate a preliminary investigation. Instead, you initiate a crime investigation, which is regulated by another law, says Amanda Lublin, who specializes in young offenders.

Decisive differences

The process for children under 15 years old resembles a regular criminal trial. A prosecutor conducts a so-called evidence inquiry and examines intent and circumstances. However, there are decisive differences, emphasizes Lublin.

The process is often held behind closed doors, and it should preferably be judges and lay judges who are experienced in dealing with young offenders.

The biggest difference is that children under 15 years old cannot be punished. The decision is instead used as a basis for social authorities.

If there is a trial against the 15-year-old, a parallel evidence inquiry can be conducted against the younger girl at the same time, if the prosecutor requests it. The outcome for the two will, however, be different if they are convicted, where the younger girl cannot be found guilty.

Instead of saying that someone is guilty, you say that it is either established or not established.

As soon as a person turns 15 and becomes criminally liable, imprisonment can be imposed as a penalty.

The only thing that differs in the penalty scale is that you cannot get life imprisonment. The most common is that they are sentenced to something called closed youth care. In certain special cases, you can be sentenced to prison.

"Extremely unusual" case

It is extremely unusual for prosecutors to bring charges against children under 15 years old in Sweden. However, since a new law came into force last year, it has become more common, says Lublin.

Previously, it was up to the National Board of Health and Welfare or guardians to request that charges be brought. Now it is up to a prosecutor.

Bringing charges against children under 15 years old is still not considered unless it is so serious that it carries at least five years' imprisonment, says Lublin and continues:

Since 1965, we are talking about between 10 and 20 cases. But I have never seen them investigate a girl under 15 years old. So it is extremely unusual.

Corrected: In an earlier version, there was an incorrect crime classification in the arrest.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Suspected Hazardous Object Found in Eskilstuna Prompts Evacuation
1 MIN READ

Suspected Hazardous Object Found in Eskilstuna Prompts Evacuation

Swedish Foreign Minister Affirms Genocide Principle Amid Gaza Concerns
2 MIN READ

Swedish Foreign Minister Affirms Genocide Principle Amid Gaza Concerns

Swedish Government Proposes Halving Food VAT from April
1 MIN READ

Swedish Government Proposes Halving Food VAT from April

Uppsala University Proposed for New Police Training Program
1 MIN READ

Uppsala University Proposed for New Police Training Program

Teen Acquitted of Rape by Court of Appeal in Lycksele Case
1 MIN READ

Teen Acquitted of Rape by Court of Appeal in Lycksele Case

Andersson Vows to Halt Gang Recruitment if Social Democrats Win
2 MIN READ

Andersson Vows to Halt Gang Recruitment if Social Democrats Win

Slussen Bus Terminal Opening Delayed to Autumn 2026
1 MIN READ

Slussen Bus Terminal Opening Delayed to Autumn 2026

SMHI Warns of Heavy Rain and Flood Risk in Götaland
1 MIN READ

SMHI Warns of Heavy Rain and Flood Risk in Götaland

Teen Sentenced for Attempted Murder in Eslöv Bus Stabbing
1 MIN READ

Teen Sentenced for Attempted Murder in Eslöv Bus Stabbing

15-Year-Old Killed in Stockholm Car Explosion Linked to Bomb Plot
1 MIN READ

15-Year-Old Killed in Stockholm Car Explosion Linked to Bomb Plot

Faulty Vaccine Storage in Dalarna May Have Reduced Effectiveness
1 MIN READ

Faulty Vaccine Storage in Dalarna May Have Reduced Effectiveness

Most Older Swedes Report Good Mental Health but Group Differences Exist
1 MIN READ

Most Older Swedes Report Good Mental Health but Group Differences Exist

Hagvidson Profits Millions While Rationing Butter at Preschools
1 MIN READ

Hagvidson Profits Millions While Rationing Butter at Preschools

Three Men Charged in Kramfors Stabbing Murder Case
1 MIN READ

Three Men Charged in Kramfors Stabbing Murder Case

Erik Sturegård Responds to Criticism of Sweden's Public Health Agency
1 MIN READ

Erik Sturegård Responds to Criticism of Sweden's Public Health Agency

Police Launch Major Operation in Linköping After Shooting Incident
1 MIN READ

Police Launch Major Operation in Linköping After Shooting Incident

Deposit on Cans and PET Bottles Doubles in Sweden
2 MIN READ

Deposit on Cans and PET Bottles Doubles in Sweden

Man Arrested After Explosion at Stockholm Apartment Building
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested After Explosion at Stockholm Apartment Building

Employment Service Monitors IP Addresses to Combat Benefit Fraud
1 MIN READ

Employment Service Monitors IP Addresses to Combat Benefit Fraud

Elderly Missing Man Found Dead in Västerås Forest
1 MIN READ

Elderly Missing Man Found Dead in Västerås Forest