Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk entirely different penalties. One can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, PhD student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

» Updated:

» Published:

Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties
Photo: Andreas Hillergren/TT

Share this article

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk completely different penalties.

The one can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, Ph.D. student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

A 15-year-old girl has been arrested, suspected of murdering a high school-aged girl in Landskrona.

Another girl figures in the investigation as a suspect for the same crime. But the girl is under 15 years old and cannot be detained or convicted.

You cannot initiate a preliminary investigation. Instead, you initiate a crime investigation, which is regulated by another law, says Amanda Lublin, who specializes in young offenders.

Decisive differences

The process for children under 15 years old resembles a regular criminal trial. A prosecutor conducts a so-called evidence inquiry and examines intent and circumstances. However, there are decisive differences, emphasizes Lublin.

The process is often held behind closed doors, and it should preferably be judges and lay judges who are experienced in dealing with young offenders.

The biggest difference is that children under 15 years old cannot be punished. The decision is instead used as a basis for social authorities.

If there is a trial against the 15-year-old, a parallel evidence inquiry can be conducted against the younger girl at the same time, if the prosecutor requests it. The outcome for the two will, however, be different if they are convicted, where the younger girl cannot be found guilty.

Instead of saying that someone is guilty, you say that it is either established or not established.

As soon as a person turns 15 and becomes criminally liable, imprisonment can be imposed as a penalty.

The only thing that differs in the penalty scale is that you cannot get life imprisonment. The most common is that they are sentenced to something called closed youth care. In certain special cases, you can be sentenced to prison.

"Extremely unusual" case

It is extremely unusual for prosecutors to bring charges against children under 15 years old in Sweden. However, since a new law came into force last year, it has become more common, says Lublin.

Previously, it was up to the National Board of Health and Welfare or guardians to request that charges be brought. Now it is up to a prosecutor.

Bringing charges against children under 15 years old is still not considered unless it is so serious that it carries at least five years' imprisonment, says Lublin and continues:

Since 1965, we are talking about between 10 and 20 cases. But I have never seen them investigate a girl under 15 years old. So it is extremely unusual.

Corrected: In an earlier version, there was an incorrect crime classification in the arrest.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Teen Arrested for Attempted Murder in Borås Stabbing

Teen Arrested for Attempted Murder in Borås Stabbing

Second Arrest Made in Kallhäll Double Murder Investigation

Second Arrest Made in Kallhäll Double Murder Investigation

Centre Party Leader Rejects Role as Fifth Tidö Party

Centre Party Leader Rejects Role as Fifth Tidö Party

Months of Recovery Ahead After Västernorrland Floods

Months of Recovery Ahead After Västernorrland Floods

Man in 30s Dies in Örnsköldsvik Traffic Accident

Man in 30s Dies in Örnsköldsvik Traffic Accident

Criticism of Sweden's Benefit Cap: Impact on Children's Rights

Criticism of Sweden's Benefit Cap: Impact on Children's Rights

Salmonella Outbreak in Sweden Linked to Local Egg Producer

Salmonella Outbreak in Sweden Linked to Local Egg Producer

Billström Explains Delays in Sweden's NATO Process

Billström Explains Delays in Sweden's NATO Process

Government Plans Increased Investment in Charging Stations

Government Plans Increased Investment in Charging Stations

Benefit Cap Reform: Large Families Face Significant Reductions

Benefit Cap Reform: Large Families Face Significant Reductions

Orbán Criticizes Swedish Government, Expresses Sympathy for Citizens

Orbán Criticizes Swedish Government, Expresses Sympathy for Citizens

Sweden Proposes Equal Maternity Care for Rural Areas

Sweden Proposes Equal Maternity Care for Rural Areas

Swedish Conscripts Criticize Government's Proposed Pay Increase

Swedish Conscripts Criticize Government's Proposed Pay Increase

Smartphone Use May Benefit Cognitive Health for Those Over 50

Smartphone Use May Benefit Cognitive Health for Those Over 50

Clear-Cutting Linked to Increased Flood Risk in Västernorrland

Clear-Cutting Linked to Increased Flood Risk in Västernorrland

Water Restored in Solna and Sundbyberg After Leak

Water Restored in Solna and Sundbyberg After Leak

Suspected Dangerous Object Found in Stockholm Prompts Investigation

Suspected Dangerous Object Found in Stockholm Prompts Investigation

Man Stabbed to Avoid Military Service Fined Along with Accomplice

Man Stabbed to Avoid Military Service Fined Along with Accomplice

Psilocybin from Mushrooms Tested for Anorexia Treatment in Pilot Study

Psilocybin from Mushrooms Tested for Anorexia Treatment in Pilot Study

Kramfors Residents Urged to Boil Drinking Water Due to Contamination

Kramfors Residents Urged to Boil Drinking Water Due to Contamination