Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk entirely different penalties. One can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, PhD student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

» Updated: August 06 2024

» Published: July 26 2024

Girls suspected of murder risk vastly different penalties
Photo: Andreas Hillergren/TT

Two girls are suspected of involvement in a murder in Landskrona. Despite being suspected of the same crime and being almost the same age, they risk completely different penalties.

The one can get prison and the other cannot, says Amanda Lublin, Ph.D. student in criminal procedure law at Stockholm University.

A 15-year-old girl has been arrested, suspected of murdering a high school-aged girl in Landskrona.

Another girl figures in the investigation as a suspect for the same crime. But the girl is under 15 years old and cannot be detained or convicted.

You cannot initiate a preliminary investigation. Instead, you initiate a crime investigation, which is regulated by another law, says Amanda Lublin, who specializes in young offenders.

Decisive differences

The process for children under 15 years old resembles a regular criminal trial. A prosecutor conducts a so-called evidence inquiry and examines intent and circumstances. However, there are decisive differences, emphasizes Lublin.

The process is often held behind closed doors, and it should preferably be judges and lay judges who are experienced in dealing with young offenders.

The biggest difference is that children under 15 years old cannot be punished. The decision is instead used as a basis for social authorities.

If there is a trial against the 15-year-old, a parallel evidence inquiry can be conducted against the younger girl at the same time, if the prosecutor requests it. The outcome for the two will, however, be different if they are convicted, where the younger girl cannot be found guilty.

Instead of saying that someone is guilty, you say that it is either established or not established.

As soon as a person turns 15 and becomes criminally liable, imprisonment can be imposed as a penalty.

The only thing that differs in the penalty scale is that you cannot get life imprisonment. The most common is that they are sentenced to something called closed youth care. In certain special cases, you can be sentenced to prison.

"Extremely unusual" case

It is extremely unusual for prosecutors to bring charges against children under 15 years old in Sweden. However, since a new law came into force last year, it has become more common, says Lublin.

Previously, it was up to the National Board of Health and Welfare or guardians to request that charges be brought. Now it is up to a prosecutor.

Bringing charges against children under 15 years old is still not considered unless it is so serious that it carries at least five years' imprisonment, says Lublin and continues:

Since 1965, we are talking about between 10 and 20 cases. But I have never seen them investigate a girl under 15 years old. So it is extremely unusual.

Corrected: In an earlier version, there was an incorrect crime classification in the arrest.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Report Highlights Workplace Vulnerability of
2 MIN READ

Report Highlights Workplace Vulnerability of Young Women in Sweden

Fasting Three Days a Week
3 MIN READ

Fasting Three Days a Week Yields Greater Weight Loss Than Calorie Cutting

Medicine Turns Human Blood Toxic
2 MIN READ

Medicine Turns Human Blood Toxic to Mosquitoes, Offering Malaria Hope

Explosion Damages Malmö Apartment Gate;
1 MIN READ

Explosion Damages Malmö Apartment Gate; Investigation Underway

Two Seriously Injured in Ydre
1 MIN READ

Two Seriously Injured in Ydre Car Crash; Police Investigate Negligence

Suspicious Object in Malmö Deemed
1 MIN READ

Suspicious Object in Malmö Deemed Harmless by Police

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of
1 MIN READ

Lena Nyberg Takes Helm of Sami Truth Commission

Tony's Chocolonely Recalls Chocolate Over
1 MIN READ

Tony's Chocolonely Recalls Chocolate Over Stone Contamination Risk

Sweden Expands Conscription Eligibility with
1 MIN READ

Sweden Expands Conscription Eligibility with Streamlined Process

Suspect Detained in Uddevalla Mosque
1 MIN READ

Suspect Detained in Uddevalla Mosque Fire Investigation

Critics Urge Sweden to Scrap
2 MIN READ

Critics Urge Sweden to Scrap Proposal on Lifestyle-Based Permit Revocation

Swedes Enjoy Longer Lives but
2 MIN READ

Swedes Enjoy Longer Lives but Face Growing Health Inequality

Stockholm Region's Journalist Register Sparks
2 MIN READ

Stockholm Region's Journalist Register Sparks Privacy Concerns

Woman Hospitalized After Attempted Murder
1 MIN READ

Woman Hospitalized After Attempted Murder in Örsundsbro, Suspect Arrested

Journalist Joakim Medin Declares from
2 MIN READ

Journalist Joakim Medin Declares from Turkish Prison: Journalism Is Not a Crime

Fredrick Federley Eyes Return to
1 MIN READ

Fredrick Federley Eyes Return to Center Party Politics in Sweden

Kristersson: Swedish Efforts Intensify for
1 MIN READ

Kristersson: Swedish Efforts Intensify for Journalist's Release in Turkey

Nina Larsson Steps In as
2 MIN READ

Nina Larsson Steps In as Sweden's New Gender Equality Minister

75-Year-Old Woman Arrested in Ale
1 MIN READ

75-Year-Old Woman Arrested in Ale for Suspected Murder of Elderly Man

New Blood Marker Tracks Alzheimer's
2 MIN READ

New Blood Marker Tracks Alzheimer's Progression, Aiding Drug Approval

Stefan Löfven Leaves Facebook Citing
1 MIN READ

Stefan Löfven Leaves Facebook Citing Concerns Over Democracy

Sweden to Announce New Minister
1 MIN READ

Sweden to Announce New Minister for Gender Equality and Labor Market

Region Skåne to Pay 80
1 MIN READ

Region Skåne to Pay 80 Million Kronor in Ambulance Dispute Settlement

Greta Thunberg Removed by Police
1 MIN READ

Greta Thunberg Removed by Police During Stockholm Climate Protest

Man in His 50s Killed
1 MIN READ

Man in His 50s Killed by Falling Beam in Mölndal Workplace Accident

Swedish Teen Sentenced to 8
1 MIN READ

Swedish Teen Sentenced to 8 Years in Denmark for Attempted Murder

Sweden Considers Deportation for Misbehavior
3 MIN READ

Sweden Considers Deportation for Misbehavior Under New Proposal

Man Arrested in Norrköping Murder
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested in Norrköping Murder Investigation

Death in Fjärås Ruled Non-Criminal
1 MIN READ

Death in Fjärås Ruled Non-Criminal After Investigation

Swedish Armed Forces Ordered to
1 MIN READ

Swedish Armed Forces Ordered to Pay for PFAS Cleanup in Uppsala

Swedish Man Charged in Copenhagen
1 MIN READ

Swedish Man Charged in Copenhagen Murder Disguised as Courier

Gender Gap in Sick Leave:
3 MIN READ

Gender Gap in Sick Leave: Women Face Double Workload Challenges

Sweden's April Fools' Day: Elk
2 MIN READ

Sweden's April Fools' Day: Elk Cavalry and Studio Swap Pranks

Sweden Ends Spruce Bark Beetle
2 MIN READ

Sweden Ends Spruce Bark Beetle Control as Threat Diminishes

Drought Shifts Earth's Axis and
3 MIN READ

Drought Shifts Earth's Axis and Raises Sea Levels, Study Finds

Örebro Doctor Sentenced to 7
1 MIN READ

Örebro Doctor Sentenced to 7 Years for Sexual Assaults on Patients

Swedish Journalist's Detention in Turkey
1 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist's Detention in Turkey Raises Legal Concerns

Woman Hospitalized After Villa Fire
1 MIN READ

Woman Hospitalized After Villa Fire Near Älvsbyn

Sölvesborg Man in Custody for
1 MIN READ

Sölvesborg Man in Custody for Alleged Online Child Sex Crimes

Report Highlights High Rates of
1 MIN READ

Report Highlights High Rates of Relationship Violence Among Young Girls