Expert: It's not certain that the militia group will succeed

Terror-labelled HTS has overthrown the Syrian dictator al-Assad with the goal of establishing an Islamic state. But it is not certain that they will succeed in doing so at all, says Middle East expert Aron Lund.

» Published: December 08 2024

Expert: It's not certain that the militia group will succeed
Photo: Stina Stjernkvist/TT

During the course of just over a week, rebels led by the Islamist group HTS have taken city after city in Syria. On Sunday night, the capital Damascus fell.

The government forces have basically just packed up and disappeared, says Lund at the Total Defence Research Institute, FOI.

The fact that the rebels were able to take the major city of Aleppo with a lightning-fast offensive in just a few days is seen by Lund as the main reason for the regime's collapse. After that, they were unable to form new resistance.

And when the city of Homs fell yesterday, the regime was no longer possible to save, says Lund.

Obviously, Russia and Iran did not provide the support they needed to give, but that support was needed a week ago.

What comes next?

The big question now is what will come after the al-Assad regime in Syria.

The leading rebel group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) was founded as al-Qaeda's Syrian branch Nusra Front when the civil war broke out in 2011. But a few years later, ties were cut with the terrorist network and also with IS.

IS moved in a more radical direction and this group has gradually taken a more pragmatic path, says Lund.

The movement is, however, listed as a terrorist organization by several countries, including the US, and the UN.

HTS is a hardline Islamist group that has strived to appear more pragmatic and moderate than it has been before, says Lund.

HTS, for example, does not aim to wage a global holy war. Commanders in HTS have also made statements that have been interpreted as saying that minorities in Syria can feel safe.

According to Lund, it is "completely obvious" that HTS will want to establish an Islamic state.

It will absolutely be based on Islamic principles and Sharia law will be the basis for legislation. There's no question about that.

Such a state can, according to Lund, take different forms with different levels of popular participation.

But whether HTS will be able to re-establish a functioning state power in Syria remains to be seen, he emphasizes.

It's not a given that they will succeed at all. If they do, the question is how strong it will be and what control it will have over different parts of the country, says Lund.

He points out that other rebel forces have taken over certain cities. In the north, there are Kurdish groups, supported primarily by the US, which HTS has no control over at all.

There are coastal areas where al-Assad supporters, the Alawites, are particularly strong. There are also two Russian military bases.

HTS has, however, worked for many years to build up government functions and institutions on a smaller scale in areas it has controlled, such as in the province of Idlib.

HTS leader Ahmed al-Sharaa has also forbidden rebel forces in Damascus from approaching public institutions until they are officially handed over.

They will naturally take over step by step and try to replace key personnel. To begin with, they will let the state apparatus function, says Lund.

We'll see.

Corrected: An earlier version of the text contained an unverified claim about the terrorist listing of HTS.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Netanyahu Visits Hungary Despite ICC
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Visits Hungary Despite ICC Arrest Warrant

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350
1 MIN READ

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350 Bears After Fatal Attack

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Air Strikes in Syria Leave Four Dead, Hit Military Sites

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of
1 MIN READ

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of Signal Raises Security Concerns

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland During Challenging Times

Elon Musk Expected to Exit
2 MIN READ

Elon Musk Expected to Exit White House Role Soon, Sources Say

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's
2 MIN READ

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's Journalist Arrest Before Key Meeting

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges
1 MIN READ

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges Against NYC Mayor Adams

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences
1 MIN READ

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences for Americans in Coup Plot

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as
2 MIN READ

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as Netanyahu Visits Budapest

Putin and Trump Not Meeting
1 MIN READ

Putin and Trump Not Meeting in Saudi Arabia, Kremlin Confirms

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks
2 MIN READ

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks Regional Condemnation

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro
1 MIN READ

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro Boost to Defense by 2036

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in
1 MIN READ

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in Alleged US Airstrikes in Yemen

Sperm Whale Found Dead on
1 MIN READ

Sperm Whale Found Dead on Danish Beach Near Aarhus

Argentina Opens Secret Files on
1 MIN READ

Argentina Opens Secret Files on Nazi Refugees and Their Financiers

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK
1 MIN READ

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK History Faces New Allegations

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins
2 MIN READ

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins Key Wisconsin Supreme Court Election

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to Aid Earthquake Relief Efforts

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor
3 MIN READ

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor Through Gaza Strip

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns Over US Interest Persist

China Wraps Up Military Drills
2 MIN READ

China Wraps Up Military Drills Near Taiwan, Raising Regional Tensions

White House Evaluates Economic Impact
2 MIN READ

White House Evaluates Economic Impact of Potential Greenland Acquisition

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored
2 MIN READ

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored by Queen, Dies at 101

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington Visit for Key Talks

Four Killed in Russian Drone
1 MIN READ

Four Killed in Russian Drone Attack on Ukrainian City Kryvyj Rih

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech
3 MIN READ

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech Sets Record in Trump Protest

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over
2 MIN READ

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over Private Email Use in Security Role

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential
1 MIN READ

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential Peacekeeping Forces in Ukraine

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit
1 MIN READ

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit for High-Alcohol Drinks

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict
2 MIN READ

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict on 2027 Election Ban Next Summer

Fourth Missing US Soldier Found
1 MIN READ

Fourth Missing US Soldier Found Dead in Lithuania

Russian Advances in Eastern Ukraine
1 MIN READ

Russian Advances in Eastern Ukraine Slow for Fourth Month

Bird Flu Outbreak Hits Danish
1 MIN READ

Bird Flu Outbreak Hits Danish Farm, 24 Chickens Culled

23 States Sue Trump Administration
2 MIN READ

23 States Sue Trump Administration Over Health Funding Cuts

Europol Set for Expansion in
1 MIN READ

Europol Set for Expansion in New EU Security Strategy

Search Continues for Missing Plane
1 MIN READ

Search Continues for Missing Plane in Norway with Two Feared Dead

Trump's First Foreign Trip as
1 MIN READ

Trump's First Foreign Trip as President: Saudi Arabia and Beyond

Danish Police Arrest 10 Bandidos
1 MIN READ

Danish Police Arrest 10 Bandidos Gang Members at Sejet Inn

German EU Politician Faces Probe
1 MIN READ

German EU Politician Faces Probe Over Controversial Nazi Greeting Post