Expert: It's not certain that the militia group will succeed

Terror-labelled HTS has overthrown the Syrian dictator al-Assad with the goal of establishing an Islamic state. But it is not certain that they will succeed in doing so at all, says Middle East expert Aron Lund.

» Published: December 08 2024

Expert: It's not certain that the militia group will succeed
Photo: Stina Stjernkvist/TT

During the course of just over a week, rebels led by the Islamist group HTS have taken city after city in Syria. On Sunday night, the capital Damascus fell.

The government forces have basically just packed up and disappeared, says Lund at the Total Defence Research Institute, FOI.

The fact that the rebels were able to take the major city of Aleppo with a lightning-fast offensive in just a few days is seen by Lund as the main reason for the regime's collapse. After that, they were unable to form new resistance.

And when the city of Homs fell yesterday, the regime was no longer possible to save, says Lund.

Obviously, Russia and Iran did not provide the support they needed to give, but that support was needed a week ago.

What comes next?

The big question now is what will come after the al-Assad regime in Syria.

The leading rebel group Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) was founded as al-Qaeda's Syrian branch Nusra Front when the civil war broke out in 2011. But a few years later, ties were cut with the terrorist network and also with IS.

IS moved in a more radical direction and this group has gradually taken a more pragmatic path, says Lund.

The movement is, however, listed as a terrorist organization by several countries, including the US, and the UN.

HTS is a hardline Islamist group that has strived to appear more pragmatic and moderate than it has been before, says Lund.

HTS, for example, does not aim to wage a global holy war. Commanders in HTS have also made statements that have been interpreted as saying that minorities in Syria can feel safe.

According to Lund, it is "completely obvious" that HTS will want to establish an Islamic state.

It will absolutely be based on Islamic principles and Sharia law will be the basis for legislation. There's no question about that.

Such a state can, according to Lund, take different forms with different levels of popular participation.

But whether HTS will be able to re-establish a functioning state power in Syria remains to be seen, he emphasizes.

It's not a given that they will succeed at all. If they do, the question is how strong it will be and what control it will have over different parts of the country, says Lund.

He points out that other rebel forces have taken over certain cities. In the north, there are Kurdish groups, supported primarily by the US, which HTS has no control over at all.

There are coastal areas where al-Assad supporters, the Alawites, are particularly strong. There are also two Russian military bases.

HTS has, however, worked for many years to build up government functions and institutions on a smaller scale in areas it has controlled, such as in the province of Idlib.

HTS leader Ahmed al-Sharaa has also forbidden rebel forces in Damascus from approaching public institutions until they are officially handed over.

They will naturally take over step by step and try to replace key personnel. To begin with, they will let the state apparatus function, says Lund.

We'll see.

Corrected: An earlier version of the text contained an unverified claim about the terrorist listing of HTS.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Russian Spy Sensors Found Near
1 MIN READ

Russian Spy Sensors Found Near UK Nuclear Submarines

Protests Erupt in Paris Following
2 MIN READ

Protests Erupt in Paris Following Le Pen Fraud Verdict

Floods in Kinshasa Leave 30
1 MIN READ

Floods in Kinshasa Leave 30 Dead and Disrupt City Access

Putin's Envoy Signals Upcoming US-Russia
1 MIN READ

Putin's Envoy Signals Upcoming US-Russia Talks

Israeli Strikes in Gaza Kill
2 MIN READ

Israeli Strikes in Gaza Kill 24, Including Women and Children

Pope Francis Returns to Vatican
1 MIN READ

Pope Francis Returns to Vatican After Severe Illness

Rain and Heat Challenge Myanmar
2 MIN READ

Rain and Heat Challenge Myanmar Earthquake Recovery Efforts

Austria Shuts 24 Border Crossings
1 MIN READ

Austria Shuts 24 Border Crossings Due to Foot-and-Mouth Outbreak

Two Killed in Suspected US
1 MIN READ

Two Killed in Suspected US Strikes on Yemen's Huthi Stronghold

Palestinian Teen Dies from Starvation
1 MIN READ

Palestinian Teen Dies from Starvation in Israeli Prison, Family Seeks Answers

Second Child Dies from Measles
1 MIN READ

Second Child Dies from Measles in Texas Outbreak

Lesotho Faces HIV Crisis as
4 MIN READ

Lesotho Faces HIV Crisis as US Aid Halts, Patients Seek Alternatives

Missile Strikes Rock Ukraine as
2 MIN READ

Missile Strikes Rock Ukraine as Air Defense Springs into Action

Severe Weather Claims 16 Lives
1 MIN READ

Severe Weather Claims 16 Lives Across Southern and Central USA

Genre image
1 MIN READ

UK MPs Detained and Denied Entry to Israel, Sparks Diplomatic Tensions

Space Miso: Fermentation in Orbit
1 MIN READ

Space Miso: Fermentation in Orbit Alters Flavor and Color

Man Arrested After Barricading in
1 MIN READ

Man Arrested After Barricading in Canada's Parliament Building

Israel Expands Military Presence to
2 MIN READ

Israel Expands Military Presence to Isolate Rafah from Gaza

Thousands Rally Across US and
2 MIN READ

Thousands Rally Across US and Europe Against Trump's Policies

Judge Orders Return of Wrongly
2 MIN READ

Judge Orders Return of Wrongly Deported Salvadoran Man to US

Thousands Rally Across Spain Over
1 MIN READ

Thousands Rally Across Spain Over Soaring Housing Costs

Democrats Seek New Leaders as
6 MIN READ

Democrats Seek New Leaders as Trump Era Challenges Persist

UK and France Discuss Peacekeeping
1 MIN READ

UK and France Discuss Peacekeeping Forces in Ukraine with Zelensky

Americans Protest Against Trump's Billionaire
2 MIN READ

Americans Protest Against Trump's Billionaire Influence

Thousands Rally in Seoul Backing
1 MIN READ

Thousands Rally in Seoul Backing Ousted Ex-President Yoon

Video Shows Medical Personnel Killed
2 MIN READ

Video Shows Medical Personnel Killed in Gaza, UN Accuses Israel

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 3,400
1 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Claims Over 3,400 Lives, Thousands Injured

US Senate Greenlights Trump's Tax
1 MIN READ

US Senate Greenlights Trump's Tax and Spending Cuts

Nine Children Among 18 Killed
2 MIN READ

Nine Children Among 18 Killed in Russian Attack on Zelensky's Hometown

Severe Storms and Floods Devastate
1 MIN READ

Severe Storms and Floods Devastate Southern and Midwest USA

Los Angeles County Settles $4
1 MIN READ

Los Angeles County Settles $4 Billion Child Abuse Case

Earth Mounds in Khartum Mark
3 MIN READ

Earth Mounds in Khartum Mark Graves of Thousands in Sudan Conflict

Prosecutor Seeks Over Seven Years
2 MIN READ

Prosecutor Seeks Over Seven Years for George Santos in Fraud Case

Roman Battlefield Unearthed Beneath Vienna
2 MIN READ

Roman Battlefield Unearthed Beneath Vienna Football Pitch

First Bird Flu Case in
1 MIN READ

First Bird Flu Case in Mexico: Young Girl in Serious Condition

130,000-Year-Old Mammoth Calf Dissected for
1 MIN READ

130,000-Year-Old Mammoth Calf Dissected for Climate Insights

Arctic Sea Ice Hits Record
2 MIN READ

Arctic Sea Ice Hits Record Low, Losing Area Equal to England

Norwegian Astronaut Jannicke Mikkelsen Returns
1 MIN READ

Norwegian Astronaut Jannicke Mikkelsen Returns from Historic Space Journey

Iran Doubles Execution Rate in
1 MIN READ

Iran Doubles Execution Rate in Early 2023, Reports Show

Netanyahu Criticized for Firing Shin
2 MIN READ

Netanyahu Criticized for Firing Shin Bet Chief Over Testimony Dispute