Tough challenge to choose right at the fish counter

Threatened stocks, environmental toxins and impact on ecosystems – fish is heavily strained. In dietary recommendations, we are urged to eat fish and shellfish two to three times a week. But how do you do it? It's extremely difficult to be a consumer, especially when it comes to fish, says Johanna Hållén at Sweden's Consumers.

» Updated: September 07 2024

» Published: August 24 2024

Tough challenge to choose right at the fish counter
Photo: Caisa Rasmussen/TT

Swedes eat less fish and shellfish than the National Food Agency's dietary guidelines of two to three times a week. The goal is to increase consumption. However, it is not unproblematic since it is not possible to increase fishing in many cases. Therefore, it is important how it is done, says Irene Blom, an advisor at the National Food Agency's unit for sustainable food consumption.

Instead of eating salmon every week, you can vary with herring or mackerel. They are fatty so that you get the same beneficial fats, she says and develops:

That you shift from such fish and shellfish species that have a relatively high climate and environmental impact – which we eat a lot of today – to those with less impact.

Difficult for the consumer

Eating fish is healthy – at the same time, there are many aspects to consider, says Johanna Hållén, Secretary-General of the Swedish Consumer Association.

As a consumer, I should keep track of whether I and my children get enough nutrients and eat good food. At the same time, we must ensure that we do not get too many harmful substances that actually exist in some fish and shellfish, and we should think about the environmental aspect and the survival of fish stocks.

Companies must report in writing, for example, on the packaging, where the fishing took place and with which gear. Hållén believes that trade has a great responsibility to take in fish that is environmentally labeled and from sustainable stocks. Furthermore, politicians and decision-makers should ensure that stocks are protected and that environmentally hazardous substances are not released into the oceans, she emphasizes.

It is not us consumers who should take the responsibility.

Yellow light for salmon

Today, Swedes eat most salmon and shrimp. But Norwegian farmed salmon has a yellow light in WWF's fish guide and is recommended to be eaten only one to three times a year, for example, on holidays.

Since a few years, certifications such as MSC, ASC, and Krav no longer automatically get a green light in the fish guide. Even if the fish is certified but has a yellow or red light, it is not sustainable, according to Inger Melander, fish expert at the World Wildlife Fund WWF.

Eating fish a few times a week and considering sustainability is difficult, says Melander. The advice to eat fish two to three times a week is good, but then other aspects must also be fulfilled.

Then you must ensure that the fish does not contain toxins and that it comes from sustainable fishing. Where we are now, it is not necessarily compatible.

Eat fish and shellfish 2-3 times a week. Vary between fatty and lean fish species. You should choose environmentally labeled fish in the form of labels MSC, ASC, and Krav.

Certain fish species contain more or less environmental pollutants such as dioxins, PCBs, PFAS, and mercury.

Wild-caught fish from Lake Vänern, Lake Vättern, and the Baltic Sea can be eaten once a week for most people. If you are a child, young, pregnant, breastfeeding, or want to become pregnant in the future, you should eat these high-risk fish 2-3 times a year.

Source: National Food Agency

Green light is a good choice and recommended according to WWF. Yellow light signals caution and should only be eaten 1-3 times a year, for example, on holidays. Red light means that the species should be avoided altogether.

Fish and shellfish species are assessed according to three criteria. How the stocks are doing, how effective the management and control are, and how the fishing affects the ecosystem. When it comes to farmed species, the origin of the feed and the environmental impact of the farming are assessed.

A species can have multiple colors depending on where and how it is caught or farmed.

If you cannot find seafood with a green light, the labels MSC, ASC, and Krav are recommended as a second-hand choice.

Examples from WWF's Fish Guide:

Alaska pollock: yellow and red light.

Cod, Pacific cod: yellow and red light.

Shrimp, North Sea shrimp: yellow and red light.

Freshwater crayfish in Swedish waters: red light.

Wild-caught signal crayfish in Swedish lakes: yellow light.

Crayfish caught with traps in Turkey: green light.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Elderly Woman Airlifted After Clothes
1 MIN READ

Elderly Woman Airlifted After Clothes Catch Fire at Swedish Hospital

Swedes Struggle as Food Prices
4 MIN READ

Swedes Struggle as Food Prices Soar: 200 Kronor Gift Cards Run Out

Police Push for Expanded Surveillance
3 MIN READ

Police Push for Expanded Surveillance Powers on Minors in Sweden

Siblings in Sweden Marvel at
1 MIN READ

Siblings in Sweden Marvel at Rare Solar Eclipse with Welding Masks

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Expected
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Expected to Be Released Soon in Turkey

Police Struggle to Keep Up
3 MIN READ

Police Struggle to Keep Up as Online Radicalization Surges

Witness the Partial Solar Eclipse
3 MIN READ

Witness the Partial Solar Eclipse on March 29: How to Safely Watch

Body Discovered After Gislaved Apartment
1 MIN READ

Body Discovered After Gislaved Apartment Fire; Police Investigate

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Arrested in Turkey Without Charge Details

Teen Convicted in Skärholmen Tunnel
1 MIN READ

Teen Convicted in Skärholmen Tunnel Murder Appeals 14-Year Sentence

Key Figures Depart Following Millennium
1 MIN READ

Key Figures Depart Following Millennium System Halt in Västra Götaland

Teen Arrested After Man Shot
1 MIN READ

Teen Arrested After Man Shot in Gothenburg Residential Area

Two Arrested After Gunfire Hits
1 MIN READ

Two Arrested After Gunfire Hits Apartments in Arlöv Near Malmö

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Five Hospitalized Following Serious Car Crash Near Surahammar

Sweden Sets Clocks Forward for
1 MIN READ

Sweden Sets Clocks Forward for Summertime Transition

Man in His 70s Dies
1 MIN READ

Man in His 70s Dies in Drowning Accident in Jämtland

Facebook Revives Friend Feed to
1 MIN READ

Facebook Revives Friend Feed to Reconnect Users

Sweden Redirects 158 Million Kronor
1 MIN READ

Sweden Redirects 158 Million Kronor Aid to Myanmar Earthquake Relief

Fegen Residents Advised to Boil
1 MIN READ

Fegen Residents Advised to Boil Water Due to Waterworks Issue

Swedish Journalist's Arrest in Turkey
2 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist's Arrest in Turkey Sparks Global Outcry

EU License Changes May Impact
4 MIN READ

EU License Changes May Impact Swedish A-Tractor Rules for Teens

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Detained
3 MIN READ

Swedish Journalist Joakim Medin Detained in Turkey

Sixth Suspect Linked to December
1 MIN READ

Sixth Suspect Linked to December Murder in Växjö

Swedish Foreign Minister Deeply Moved
1 MIN READ

Swedish Foreign Minister Deeply Moved by Southeast Asia Earthquake

Man in Custody After Shooting
1 MIN READ

Man in Custody After Shooting at Police in Karlshamn

Swedish IS Terrorist Osama Krayem
1 MIN READ

Swedish IS Terrorist Osama Krayem Detained for Serious War Crimes

25 Charged in Sweden for
2 MIN READ

25 Charged in Sweden for Defrauding Elderly of Millions

Swedish Court to Decide on
2 MIN READ

Swedish Court to Decide on Alleged Birth Intervention Without Consent

18-Year-Old Faces Charges for Nine
1 MIN READ

18-Year-Old Faces Charges for Nine Attempted Murders in Malmö

Person Dies After Falling from
1 MIN READ

Person Dies After Falling from Ship Near Göteborg

Kristersson Faces New Inquiry Over
1 MIN READ

Kristersson Faces New Inquiry Over Alleged Political Bias in Government

Students Call for Better Sex
1 MIN READ

Students Call for Better Sex and Consent Education in Swedish Schools

Police and Prison Uniforms Illegally
1 MIN READ

Police and Prison Uniforms Illegally Sold on Sellpy, Investigation Reveals

Molotov Cocktail Attack on Uddevalla
1 MIN READ

Molotov Cocktail Attack on Uddevalla Mosque Sparks Arson Investigation

Sis CEO Responds to Criticism:
2 MIN READ

Sis CEO Responds to Criticism: Report Key to Improving Child Care

Man Sentenced to 10 Years
1 MIN READ

Man Sentenced to 10 Years for Stabbing Girlfriend in Västerås

Report Highlights Failures in Sweden's
3 MIN READ

Report Highlights Failures in Sweden's Treatment of Detained Children

Sweden's National Parks Struggle with
5 MIN READ

Sweden's National Parks Struggle with Maintenance and Accessibility

Explosion Rocks Malmö Apartment Building
1 MIN READ

Explosion Rocks Malmö Apartment Building Stairwell Overnight

Cutting Public Service Now is
1 MIN READ

Cutting Public Service Now is Irresponsible Say Swedish Social Democrats