The Warning: USA's Democracy is More Fragile than We Think

In step with Donald Trump's new regime taking shape, fears of a severe "backlash" for democracy are growing. It is not as robust as many believe, says Eric J Segall, professor of constitutional law, at Georgia State University.

» Published: November 25 2024

The Warning: USA's Democracy is More Fragile than We Think
Photo: Brandon Bell/AP/TT

The Republican Trump's future government has taken shape, and there is no doubt that the incoming president will surround himself with loyalists. People who, like Trump, can be assumed to be open to letting the goal justify the means if necessary.

With a majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, the conditions for Trump's "Maga" visions ("Make America Great Again") look good.

The question is whether there is anything that can stop Trump if he goes full speed and runs over democratic and legal principles along the way?

CEO of the entire USA

Donald Trump's ambition is to be the CEO of the entire USA without any legal restrictions. Can he do it? Probably not. But the question is how far he can go, says Eric J Segall, professor of constitutional law.

A "paper barrier". That's what James Madison, one of the USA's so-called founding fathers, is said to have called the Constitution. What he meant was that it only works if those in power take it seriously. A statement that, according to Segall, is more relevant than ever.

If Trump goes very, very far over the line, which I think is possible, it will be very turbulent times ahead, he says.

In the country that has long been a democratic model for the whole world, the incoming president has, among other things, promised more power to himself, purges of disloyal individuals in the administration, prosecution of antagonists, pardoning of rioters who stormed the Capitol, and deportation of millions of undocumented immigrants – possibly with the help of the military. Moreover, he is inciting against journalists and political opponents.

"Checks and balances"

The fact that the Supreme Court has given Trump immunity for actions in office has great significance for what he can achieve. It gives him enormous opportunities to act overall, says Erik Åsard, professor emeritus at Uppsala University and USA expert.

When it comes to Trump's opportunities to get his policy through, Åsard believes it will be easiest at the beginning of the term.

Some of his proposals are controversial and will be unpopular. Further ahead, public opinion may have turned, and then it will be easier for hesitant Republicans to go against the party, he says.

The idea behind American democracy is the division of power between the president, Congress, and the Supreme Court. The Constitution prohibits, for example, the president from spending money that has not been allocated by Congress. But Eric J Segall does not believe that the system's "checks and balances" will stop Trump.

The chance that Congress will stand up to Trump is very small. And the Supreme Court has no money and no military. If Trump says "to hell with it", then it will be so, he says.

A bumpy road

Erik Åsard is more skeptical about Congress laying down for Trump.

Even if Congress's effectiveness has been discussed for decades, it's not a given that it won't put up a stop. If a few senators fall away, it may be enough, since decisions in the Senate are made by a simple majority. In any case, the nominations to ministerial posts have worried some Republican senators, he says.

Eric J Segall believes rather that it is the geographical conditions that could resist Trump.

What can save America, if anything, is our geography and individual people with an ethical compass. Imagine 50 Spains and try to govern it in a dictatorial way. It's very complicated, he says.

At the same time, there is a fear of violence, not least if democratically inclined states or populations set themselves against it.

What can happen is that the president, or for that matter a governor, uses police or military in ways that cause a lot of violence. It's possible that it will happen. We have a bumpy road ahead of us, says Eric J Segall.

Note: The USA's area is roughly 20 times larger than Spain, not 50.

The Federal Republic of the USA has 50 states. According to the Constitution, the principle of separation of powers applies, i.e., that the executive, legislative, and judicial branches should balance each other. In practice, this means that the president governs the USA, Congress writes the laws, and the Supreme Court ensures that presidential decisions and laws do not conflict with the Constitution.

Congress consists of the Senate and the House of Representatives. For a bill to pass, it must be approved by a majority in both chambers.

The rules in the Senate give the smaller party the opportunity to delay and sometimes stop the majority party's agenda through the so-called filibuster. Normally, 51 votes are required, or 50 votes plus the Vice President's casting vote, for a proposal to be adopted. If the filibuster is invoked, a "supermajority" of 60 votes is required to end the debate and put the proposal to a vote. At the same time, there are exceptions to the rule and ways to circumvent it.

The Supreme Court determines whether laws are compatible with the Constitution. It plays a significant political role when it takes a stand on various social issues. The candidates are nominated by the president and must be approved by the Senate. The court has become increasingly conservative in recent years.

The individual states have relatively great autonomy, and the differences between them can be significant.

Source: The Foreign Policy Institute and others

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

EU Commits 12 Billion Euros
1 MIN READ

EU Commits 12 Billion Euros to Boost Central Asia Ties

Bomb Explosion at Bolivian Gold
1 MIN READ

Bomb Explosion at Bolivian Gold Mine Kills Five in Cooperative Dispute

Israeli Strikes in Gaza Kill
1 MIN READ

Israeli Strikes in Gaza Kill at Least 30 as Ground Offensive Expands

Norwegian Royal Marius Borg Høiby
1 MIN READ

Norwegian Royal Marius Borg Høiby Declines Police Questioning Over Leak Fears

Trump Reshuffles Intelligence Chiefs After
2 MIN READ

Trump Reshuffles Intelligence Chiefs After Meeting with Activist Loomer

TikTok's Future in the US
3 MIN READ

TikTok's Future in the US Hangs in the Balance as Decision Looms

South Korea's Yoon Ousted After
2 MIN READ

South Korea's Yoon Ousted After Martial Law Controversy

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Norwegian Ship's Record Cocaine Haul Seized in South Korea

Putin's Envoy Sees Positive Shift
1 MIN READ

Putin's Envoy Sees Positive Shift in US-Russia Relations

Russian Drone Strikes Kill Four
1 MIN READ

Russian Drone Strikes Kill Four in Kharkiv, Injure Dozens Across Ukraine

Israel Updates Music Festival Death
2 MIN READ

Israel Updates Music Festival Death Toll to 378 After Investigation

Two Dead in Norwegian Plane
1 MIN READ

Two Dead in Norwegian Plane Crash Near Bergen Lake

Pentagon Probes Use of Signal
1 MIN READ

Pentagon Probes Use of Signal App for Discussing Yemen Attack Plans

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Frederiksen to USA: Annexation Not an Option, Let's Strengthen Arctic Security

Seoul Braces for Verdict as
3 MIN READ

Seoul Braces for Verdict as South Korea Awaits Yoon's Fate

Myanmar Earthquake Death Toll Rises
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Death Toll Rises as Aid Efforts Intensify

Trump Fires Key Security Officials
2 MIN READ

Trump Fires Key Security Officials After Oval Office Meeting

Serbian Students Bike 130 Miles
1 MIN READ

Serbian Students Bike 130 Miles to EU Parliament Seeking Support

Iranian Judge Linked to 1988
1 MIN READ

Iranian Judge Linked to 1988 Executions Dies at 70

UN Alarmed by Reports of
1 MIN READ

UN Alarmed by Reports of Civilian Executions in Sudan

Mother and Daughter Found Shot
1 MIN READ

Mother and Daughter Found Shot Dead in Norway; Suspect Also Dead

Elon Musk to Stay as
1 MIN READ

Elon Musk to Stay as Advisor to Trump, Confirms JD Vance

Israeli Legal Experts Call for
1 MIN READ

Israeli Legal Experts Call for War Crimes Probe into Gaza Attack

EU Parliament Approves Delay in
1 MIN READ

EU Parliament Approves Delay in Key Sustainability Rules

Denmark Stands Firm on Sovereignty
2 MIN READ

Denmark Stands Firm on Sovereignty in Talks with US

Modi's New Law Fuels Discrimination
1 MIN READ

Modi's New Law Fuels Discrimination Concerns in India

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting
1 MIN READ

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting in Gaza Strip

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives
1 MIN READ

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives as Recovery Efforts Continue

Norovirus Hits Queen Mary 2
1 MIN READ

Norovirus Hits Queen Mary 2 Cruise, Over 240 Passengers Affected

Rubio Affirms US Commitment to
3 MIN READ

Rubio Affirms US Commitment to NATO, Calls for Increased Defense Spending

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold
1 MIN READ

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold Passes Away

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package
1 MIN READ

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package to Ukraine

Russia Not on US Tariff
2 MIN READ

Russia Not on US Tariff List Despite Broad Global Reach

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women
1 MIN READ

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women and Newborns, Says Save the Children

Tragedy Strikes as Boats Sink
1 MIN READ

Tragedy Strikes as Boats Sink Near Greece and Turkey, 16 Migrants Dead

Search for Missing MH370 Paused
1 MIN READ

Search for Missing MH370 Paused Until Year-End, Says Malaysia

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze
1 MIN READ

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze in Rome; Italy Boosts Security Measures

UN Envoy Urges Israel to
2 MIN READ

UN Envoy Urges Israel to Halt Strikes in Southern Syria

US Calls for UN Official's
1 MIN READ

US Calls for UN Official's Removal Over Alleged Anti-Semitic Views

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Meets US
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Meets US Officials in Washington for Talks