That's Why It's So Hard to Achieve a Ceasefire

It is described as the "last chance" to achieve a ceasefire between Israel and the terrorist-stamped Hamas when the mediators gather again for talks. If it fails, there is a risk that the region will be even more on the brink of a major war.

» Updated: September 19 2024

» Published: August 20 2024

That's Why It's So Hard to Achieve a Ceasefire
Photo: Abdel Kareem Hana/AP/TT

Share this article

The goal of the mediators' meetings in Qatar's capital Doha last week and Egypt's capital Cairo this week can be simply summarized: hope of reaching a ceasefire in Gaza.

But despite the clear goal, the mission is far from simple. Representatives and mediators from different countries have been shuttling back and forth to the region in the hope of reaching an agreement. And even for those who work daily to try to understand what is happening during the negotiations, it is difficult.

I, as an analyst, feel like I'm sitting with a puzzle where I have 20 percent of the pieces, says Anders Persson, Middle East expert at Linnaeus University.

It's very difficult to get a correct picture of what's happening, he continues.

New Demands

One of the reasons he sees why it's difficult to reach an agreement on a ceasefire is that much of what is said and done is constantly changing.

Israel has made new demands. Among other things, they want to keep troops in two places in Gaza, they don't want Hamas to return to northern Gaza, and they want more living hostages released in an early stage. These are new demands that make Hamas furious, says Anders Persson.

If you then look from Hamas' perspective, I'm not even sure that their purpose with the attack on October 7 was to get a ceasefire.

I see it as Hamas still wanting a major war in the region and hoping that Hezbollah and Iran will be drawn into it.

Increased Tensions

Tensions in the region increased further at the end of July when Hamas' political leader Ismail Haniya and the Iran-backed Shia militia Hezbollah's commander Fuad Shukr were killed.

This made both Iran and its allies in the region, including Hezbollah, see red and vow revenge against Israel. So far, that revenge has not materialized. Analysts believe they have been waiting for the ceasefire talks to come to fruition and that such an agreement would make a response unnecessary.

But Anders Persson does not believe that the ongoing talks will lead to a ceasefire.

The reason it hasn't worked out so far is that one side's maximum bid is higher than the other side's minimum bid. Therefore, they have not met.

It's the same as if you and I were negotiating a condominium. I offer you two million and you want three, so we can never meet.

The Islamist extremist group Hamas attacked Israel on Saturday morning, October 7, last year. Around 1,150 people are estimated to have fallen victim to the terrorist attack, most of them civilians, and over 200 people were taken hostage.

Israel responded by declaring war and has besieged Gaza, bombed the strip continuously, and entered with ground forces with the stated aim of eliminating Hamas.

According to Hamas-controlled authorities, more than 40,000 people have been killed in Israeli attacks in Gaza since the outbreak of war. Large parts of the area's buildings have been leveled and aid organizations are warning of severe famine.

More than 100 people are still being held hostage in Gaza, according to Israel, since about the same number were released in exchanges and a few more were rescued. Many of those remaining are feared to no longer be alive.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Hungary Blocks Ukrainian Commander Over Oil Pipeline Dispute
1 MIN READ

Hungary Blocks Ukrainian Commander Over Oil Pipeline Dispute

Polish Air Force F16 Crash During Exercise Kills Pilot
1 MIN READ

Polish Air Force F16 Crash During Exercise Kills Pilot

Trump to Address UN General Assembly in New York
1 MIN READ

Trump to Address UN General Assembly in New York

Haiti Faces Humanitarian Crisis Amidst Escalating Violence and Instability
3 MIN READ

Haiti Faces Humanitarian Crisis Amidst Escalating Violence and Instability

Kyiv Struggles to Counter Escalating Russian Drone and Missile Attacks
2 MIN READ

Kyiv Struggles to Counter Escalating Russian Drone and Missile Attacks

UN Extends Lebanon Peacekeeping Mission Until 2027
1 MIN READ

UN Extends Lebanon Peacekeeping Mission Until 2027

Israeli Military Strikes Huthi Targets in Yemen's Capital Sanaa
1 MIN READ

Israeli Military Strikes Huthi Targets in Yemen's Capital Sanaa

Alligator Alcatraz Closure Plans Move Forward Amid Environmental Concerns
1 MIN READ

Alligator Alcatraz Closure Plans Move Forward Amid Environmental Concerns

Europe Moves to Reinstate UN Sanctions on Iran Over Nuclear Dispute
4 MIN READ

Europe Moves to Reinstate UN Sanctions on Iran Over Nuclear Dispute

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan Faces New Sexual Harassment Allegations
2 MIN READ

ICC Chief Prosecutor Karim Khan Faces New Sexual Harassment Allegations

Kyiv Resident Natalya Lytvynova Sees Divine Protection Amid Russian Attack
2 MIN READ

Kyiv Resident Natalya Lytvynova Sees Divine Protection Amid Russian Attack

Over 20 Killed in New Attack by Rapid Support Forces in Sudan
1 MIN READ

Over 20 Killed in New Attack by Rapid Support Forces in Sudan

UN Experts Alarmed by Disappearances During Gaza Food Distribution
2 MIN READ

UN Experts Alarmed by Disappearances During Gaza Food Distribution

Gaza Crisis: UN Urges More Aid as Children Face Severe Malnutrition
1 MIN READ

Gaza Crisis: UN Urges More Aid as Children Face Severe Malnutrition

Minor Plane Accident at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport Involving Juneyao Airlines
1 MIN READ

Minor Plane Accident at Helsinki-Vantaa Airport Involving Juneyao Airlines

Russian Drones Suspected of Monitoring German Arms Routes to Ukraine
1 MIN READ

Russian Drones Suspected of Monitoring German Arms Routes to Ukraine

Over 1.2 Million Impacted by Pakistan Floods as Rivers Overflow
1 MIN READ

Over 1.2 Million Impacted by Pakistan Floods as Rivers Overflow

CDC Chief Fired Amid Vaccine Policy Dispute and Resignations
2 MIN READ

CDC Chief Fired Amid Vaccine Policy Dispute and Resignations

Israeli Raids Target Sites Near Damascus Amid Demilitarization Talks
1 MIN READ

Israeli Raids Target Sites Near Damascus Amid Demilitarization Talks

US Envoy Condemns Russian Attack on Kyiv as Heinous
2 MIN READ

US Envoy Condemns Russian Attack on Kyiv as Heinous