Israeli Supreme Court Halts Spy Chief's Dismissal, Seeks Resolution

The Israeli Supreme Court gives the government and the prosecutor general barely two weeks to find a solution regarding the dismissed intelligence chief Ronen Bar, who until then gets to keep his job. The case risks throwing Israel into a constitutional crisis.

» Published:

Israeli Supreme Court Halts Spy Chief's Dismissal, Seeks Resolution
Photo: Ohad Zwigenberg/AP/TT

Share this article

The head of the security service Shin Bet, Ronen Bar, was dismissed in March, according to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu due to lack of confidence – a case that has ended up in the Supreme Court.

When the Supreme Court began proceedings on Tuesday, it was decided that the government is not allowed to dismiss Ronen Bar or appoint a successor – or interfere with his work.

At least not within the next twelve days. The Supreme Court instead wants to see the parties come to an agreement and issue a joint statement on the matter by April 20.

Netanyahu says in a brief statement that the Supreme Court's ruling is "perplexing", according to Israeli media.

Conflicts of Interest

Opposition politicians and non-profit organizations have criticized and contested the dismissal, which they claim is based on allegations of conflicts of interest from Netanyahu's side.

Shin Bet is currently investigating two cases involving people close to the Prime Minister: a leak of state secrets about the Gaza war last year and what has come to be called Qatargate, where two of Netanyahu's closest men are suspected of bribery to Qatar.

Many in Israel wondered beforehand what would happen if the court ruled against the government and blocked the dismissal of Bar, writes The Jerusalem Post. If the government were to ignore the court's ruling, it would lead Israel straight into a constitutional crisis, the newspaper notes.

Tuesday's proceedings were barely underway before they were interrupted several times and later resumed without spectators.

Removed

Among other things, a man whose son was killed during the war between Israel and Hamas held a long speech, writes The Times of Israel. In the speech, he condemned the court for even taking up the case, as he believes that Ronen Bar's hands are "dripping with blood".

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's party colleague, Member of Parliament Tally Gotliv, was subsequently removed from the chamber after she had interrupted the proceedings several times.

After the commotion, opposition leader Yair Lapid accused the Prime Minister and his allies of an "orchestrated uprising" and of "shamefully exploiting" bereaved families for their own gain, writes The Times of Israel.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Brazil's Former President Bolsonaro Sentenced to 27 Years for Coup Attempt

Brazil's Former President Bolsonaro Sentenced to 27 Years for Coup Attempt

UN Security Council Condemns Attack on Qatar, Urges De-escalation

UN Security Council Condemns Attack on Qatar, Urges De-escalation

Brazil's Ex-President Bolsonaro Guilty of Coup Attempt

Brazil's Ex-President Bolsonaro Guilty of Coup Attempt

Recent Politically Motivated Attacks That Shook the US

Recent Politically Motivated Attacks That Shook the US

Russia Cautions Poland on Belarus Border Closure Consequences

Russia Cautions Poland on Belarus Border Closure Consequences

Netanyahu Declares No Palestinian State in West Bank Speech

Netanyahu Declares No Palestinian State in West Bank Speech

Anti-Islamic Motorcycle Gang Secures Gaza Humanitarian Aid

Anti-Islamic Motorcycle Gang Secures Gaza Humanitarian Aid

Ebola Cases Surge in Congo-Kinshasa Amid Ongoing Outbreak

Ebola Cases Surge in Congo-Kinshasa Amid Ongoing Outbreak

Hyundai Workers Detained in Georgia Returning to South Korea

Hyundai Workers Detained in Georgia Returning to South Korea

Hamas Claims Israeli Attack Halts Ceasefire Talks

Hamas Claims Israeli Attack Halts Ceasefire Talks

Trump Announces Posthumous Medal of Freedom for Charlie Kirk

Trump Announces Posthumous Medal of Freedom for Charlie Kirk

Police Probe Religious Motive in Essen Teacher Stabbing

Police Probe Religious Motive in Essen Teacher Stabbing

FBI Seeks Help Identifying Suspect in Charlie Kirk Murder Case

FBI Seeks Help Identifying Suspect in Charlie Kirk Murder Case

West Africans Deported from USA Arrive in Ghana

West Africans Deported from USA Arrive in Ghana

EU Parliament Backs Recognition of Palestine as Independent State

EU Parliament Backs Recognition of Palestine as Independent State

Red Youth Leader Amrit Kaur Resigns After Controversial Kirk Video

Red Youth Leader Amrit Kaur Resigns After Controversial Kirk Video

UK Ambassador Mandelson Fired Over Leaked Epstein Emails

UK Ambassador Mandelson Fired Over Leaked Epstein Emails

Immunity Removed for AfD Politician Maximilian Krah in Spy Scandal

Immunity Removed for AfD Politician Maximilian Krah in Spy Scandal

EU Court Rules Against Hungarian State Aid for Russian Nuclear Project

EU Court Rules Against Hungarian State Aid for Russian Nuclear Project

NATO Faces Risky Decisions After Russian Drones Enter Polish Airspace

NATO Faces Risky Decisions After Russian Drones Enter Polish Airspace