Exploded people-searchers can be war crimes

One by one, personal locators and walkie-talkies in pockets and hands exploded. The method – borrowed from a spy novel – raises a number of questions related to the laws of war. The question is what measures have been taken to direct the attacks against legitimate targets, says a professor of international law.

» Updated: September 20 2024

» Published: September 19 2024

Exploded people-searchers can be war crimes
Photo: Hussein Malla/AP/TT

In months, hundreds, perhaps thousands of Lebanese people unknowingly carried small, ticking bombs in their pockets.

This is not the first time seemingly ordinary objects have been transformed into weapons. But the scale of the attacks in Lebanon is unprecedented, according to Jann Kleffner, professor of international law at the Defense University in Stockholm. This makes the legal issues more complex.

Simply put, you can only direct attacks against military targets – not civilians. Here, it's difficult to know, says Kleffner, pointing out that Hezbollah not only consists of armed forces but also has a strong role in politics and social life in Lebanon.

The approach inevitably puts innocent people in the line of fire, several analysts have claimed after the attacks. The laws of war, which are based on the four Geneva Conventions from 1949, state that civilians must be protected.

The question is what measures have been taken to direct the attacks against legitimate targets, says Kleffner.

Difficult to know

According to humanitarian law, the military significance of an attack must also be "in proportion" to the risks civilians are exposed to.

If 80 percent of the victims are armed forces and you know that – then the legal analysis becomes completely different than if you had just sent out thousands of mined seekers on the open market.

The fact that the attacks were carried out remotely makes the whole thing even more complex. When hundreds, perhaps thousands, of people-searchers and walkie-talkies explode almost simultaneously, it's hardly possible for the person pressing the button to know where or in whose hands all the units are, says Kleffner.

We've seen pictures of seekers exploding in the middle of a market. How much did the operators know about where the people in question were at the time? Can you know that? In my eyes, it's almost impossible.

"Ticking bomb"

The attack raises concerns about future warfare in a world where we are becoming increasingly dependent on digital technology. Yousef Munayyer, a Palestinian-American political analyst, claimed on Tuesday that the attack opens "a dangerous Pandora's box".

"Almost every person is walking around as a ticking bomb. It won't take long before this technology is used by many actors", he wrote on X.

How relevant are the laws of war when digital technology becomes a weapon?

The rules that exist are quite general and quite vague. Sometimes it's a disadvantage, but often an advantage, as it makes them easy to apply to new phenomena, says Jann Kleffner.

Civilians must not be attacked in armed conflicts and must be protected, according to international principles that the world community has agreed upon.

The laws of war – formally international humanitarian law – aim to spare combatants, the wounded, prisoners of war, and civilians from unnecessary suffering. The core consists of the four Geneva Conventions from 1949, which have been ratified by nearly 200 states. Both state and non-state actors are bound by the laws.

Key words are distinction (separation of civilians and combatants), proportionality (the military significance of an attack must be weighed against the risks it poses to civilians), and precaution (all parties must take all possible precautions to ensure that attacks are only directed against military targets).

The fact that non-civilian persons are present among civilians does not mean that the group as a whole can be considered a legitimate target. The civilian population must not be used as so-called human shields to defend against attacks.

The special protection emblem of the medical service must be respected, and the warring parties must do what they can to facilitate humanitarian efforts.

Source: UN, Red Cross, and National Encyclopedia

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Russia Not on US Tariff
2 MIN READ

Russia Not on US Tariff List Despite Broad Global Reach

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women
1 MIN READ

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women and Newborns, Says Save the Children

Migrant Boat Tragedy Near Lesbos
1 MIN READ

Migrant Boat Tragedy Near Lesbos Claims Four Lives, Including Children

Search for Missing MH370 Paused
1 MIN READ

Search for Missing MH370 Paused Until Year-End, Says Malaysia

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze
1 MIN READ

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze in Rome; Italy Boosts Security Measures

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Strikes in Syria Leave Nine Civilians Dead, Tensions Rise

US Calls for UN Official's
1 MIN READ

US Calls for UN Official's Removal Over Alleged Anti-Semitic Views

Putin's Envoy Meets US Officials
1 MIN READ

Putin's Envoy Meets US Officials at White House for Talks

Over 20 Palestinians Killed in
1 MIN READ

Over 20 Palestinians Killed in Israeli Air Strikes on Gaza Strip

Netanyahu Visits Hungary Despite ICC
1 MIN READ

Netanyahu Visits Hungary Despite ICC Arrest Warrant

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350
1 MIN READ

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350 Bears After Fatal Attack

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Air Strikes in Syria Leave Four Dead, Hit Military Sites

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of
1 MIN READ

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of Signal Raises Security Concerns

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland During Challenging Times

Elon Musk Expected to Exit
2 MIN READ

Elon Musk Expected to Exit White House Role Soon, Sources Say

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's
2 MIN READ

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's Journalist Arrest Before Key Meeting

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges
1 MIN READ

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges Against NYC Mayor Adams

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences
1 MIN READ

Congo President Commutes Death Sentences for Americans in Coup Plot

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as
2 MIN READ

Hungary Plans ICC Exit as Netanyahu Visits Budapest

Putin and Trump Not Meeting
1 MIN READ

Putin and Trump Not Meeting in Saudi Arabia, Kremlin Confirms

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks
2 MIN READ

Ben-Gvir's Temple Mount Visit Sparks Regional Condemnation

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro
1 MIN READ

Greece Plans 25 Billion Euro Boost to Defense by 2036

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in
1 MIN READ

Houthi Movement Reports Fatalities in Alleged US Airstrikes in Yemen

Sperm Whale Found Dead on
1 MIN READ

Sperm Whale Found Dead on Danish Beach Near Aarhus

Argentina Opens Secret Files on
1 MIN READ

Argentina Opens Secret Files on Nazi Refugees and Their Financiers

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK
1 MIN READ

Suspected Worst Rapist in UK History Faces New Allegations

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins
2 MIN READ

Liberal Judge Susan Crawford Wins Key Wisconsin Supreme Court Election

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Junta Announces Ceasefire to Aid Earthquake Relief Efforts

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor
3 MIN READ

Netanyahu Announces New Security Corridor Through Gaza Strip

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns Over US Interest Persist

China Wraps Up Military Drills
2 MIN READ

China Wraps Up Military Drills Near Taiwan, Raising Regional Tensions

White House Evaluates Economic Impact
2 MIN READ

White House Evaluates Economic Impact of Potential Greenland Acquisition

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored
2 MIN READ

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored by Queen, Dies at 101

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Eyes Washington Visit for Key Talks

Four Killed in Russian Drone
1 MIN READ

Four Killed in Russian Drone Attack on Ukrainian City Kryvyj Rih

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech
3 MIN READ

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech Sets Record in Trump Protest

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over
2 MIN READ

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over Private Email Use in Security Role

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential
1 MIN READ

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential Peacekeeping Forces in Ukraine

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit
1 MIN READ

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit for High-Alcohol Drinks

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict
2 MIN READ

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict on 2027 Election Ban Next Summer