Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal

Israel's cabinet votes to dismiss the head of the security service Shin Bet. Israel's highest court stops the dismissal. It is the government that decides, responds Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

» Published: March 21 2025

Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal
Photo: Gil Cohen-Magen/AP/TT

The dispute between the Prime Minister and the Supreme Court has been going on for a long time, where Israel's current government has wanted to limit the Supreme Court's mandate – which has previously led to massive protests.

The struggle intensified when the government voted on Thursday evening to dismiss Ronen Bar, who is the head of the country's internal security service Shin Bet.

Review Appeals

The decision was temporarily stopped by the country's Supreme Court on Friday. The Supreme Court wants to review the appeals filed against the dismissal. The decision applies until the appeals are presented, no later than April 8.

Israel's Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara then announced that the Prime Minister is not allowed to appoint a successor during the ongoing process.

The response came quickly from Netanyahu:

"The State of Israel is a state of law, and according to the law, it is Israel's government that decides who will lead (intelligence service) Shin Bet", Netanyahu wrote on the X platform. Netanyahu did not mention the Supreme Court, but his statement was still a direct attack on the country's Supreme Court.

Lacks Confidence

Netanyahu stated earlier in the week that he lacks confidence in Bar. The security chief responded in a letter to the assembled ministers, where he repeated his harsh criticism of Netanyahu and his demands for "personal loyalty", which Bar considers inappropriate.

The two men have disagreed on who bears the greater responsibility for Hamas' ability to carry out the bloody terrorist attacks on October 7, 2023.

Ronen Bar says he has taken responsibility for Shin Bet's failure at the time and that Netanyahu's decision has little to do with it.

The dismissal must be formally approved in the Israeli parliament, the Knesset, where Netanyahu's government coalition has a majority.

Tags

TTT
By TT - Translated and adapted by Sweden Herald under license from TT

More news

EU Lists Seven Countries for
1 MIN READ

EU Lists Seven Countries for Faster Asylum Processing

Iran Stands Firm: Uranium Enrichment
2 MIN READ

Iran Stands Firm: Uranium Enrichment Off the Negotiation Table

Swedish Woman's Killer Appeals Psychiatric
1 MIN READ

Swedish Woman's Killer Appeals Psychiatric Care Verdict in Norway

UK Supreme Court Rules 'Woman'
1 MIN READ

UK Supreme Court Rules 'Woman' Defined by Birth Biology

Israel Maintains Gaza Blockade, Rejects
1 MIN READ

Israel Maintains Gaza Blockade, Rejects Aid Entry After Six Weeks

Israeli Airstrikes in Gaza Result
1 MIN READ

Israeli Airstrikes in Gaza Result in Civilian Casualties

German Doctor Accused of Murdering
1 MIN READ

German Doctor Accused of Murdering 15 Patients in Palliative Care

Trump Considers Sending Violent Offenders
2 MIN READ

Trump Considers Sending Violent Offenders to El Salvador Prisons

Trump Administration Considers Closing 27
1 MIN READ

Trump Administration Considers Closing 27 Embassies and Consulates

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israel Targets Hezbollah Sites in Southern Lebanon

Can Italy's Meloni Bridge EU-US
3 MIN READ

Can Italy's Meloni Bridge EU-US Tensions in Washington Visit?

Russian Attacks in Southern Ukraine
1 MIN READ

Russian Attacks in Southern Ukraine Leave One Dead, Several Injured

WHO Backs Historic Agreement on
2 MIN READ

WHO Backs Historic Agreement on Future Pandemic Preparedness

Biden Criticizes Trump for Public
1 MIN READ

Biden Criticizes Trump for Public Sector Cuts and "Great Harm"

Robot Begins Second Mission to
1 MIN READ

Robot Begins Second Mission to Retrieve Radioactive Waste at Fukushima

Genre image
2 MIN READ

Sudan's RSF Leader Declares Rebel Government on Conflict Anniversary

Global Leaders Pledge Billions in
2 MIN READ

Global Leaders Pledge Billions in Aid for Sudan at London Conference

Peru's Ex-President Humala Sentenced to
1 MIN READ

Peru's Ex-President Humala Sentenced to 15 Years for Money Laundering

French Ministers Face Legal Action
2 MIN READ

French Ministers Face Legal Action Over Healthcare Staff Suicides

Russian Journalists Receive Prison Sentences
1 MIN READ

Russian Journalists Receive Prison Sentences for Extremism Charges

Hamas Rejects Israel's Six-Week Ceasefire
1 MIN READ

Hamas Rejects Israel's Six-Week Ceasefire Proposal for Gaza

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Jordan Foils Plot Threatening National Security, 16 Arrested

Rutte: Ukraine Peace Talks Challenging
2 MIN READ

Rutte: Ukraine Peace Talks Challenging Amid Ongoing Violence

WHO Warns 10% of Afghans
1 MIN READ

WHO Warns 10% of Afghans May Lose Healthcare Due to US Aid Cuts

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Zelensky to Remove Sumy Governor Following Deadly Attack

Vance Urges Europe to Embrace
2 MIN READ

Vance Urges Europe to Embrace Greater Independence from the USA

Fires and Shootings Target Multiple
1 MIN READ

Fires and Shootings Target Multiple French Prisons Overnight

US Budget Proposal Targets UN
2 MIN READ

US Budget Proposal Targets UN and NATO Funding Cuts

Israeli Airstrike on Gaza Hospital
1 MIN READ

Israeli Airstrike on Gaza Hospital Kills Healthcare Worker, Injures Nine

Over 230 Arrested in Major
1 MIN READ

Over 230 Arrested in Major International Crime Bust Across Europe and Turkey

Trump's Envoy Hints at Easing
2 MIN READ

Trump's Envoy Hints at Easing Nuclear Demands on Iran

Trump's Envoy Reveals Putin's Peace
2 MIN READ

Trump's Envoy Reveals Putin's Peace Demands After Key Meeting

Columbia Student Activist Arrested, Faces
2 MIN READ

Columbia Student Activist Arrested, Faces Deportation from the USA

Humanitarian Crisis Deepens as Refugees
4 MIN READ

Humanitarian Crisis Deepens as Refugees Flee Sudan to South Sudan

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Elderly Woman Killed, Nine Injured in Ukrainian Drone Strike on Kursk

Mallorca Couple Arrested for Selling
1 MIN READ

Mallorca Couple Arrested for Selling Exotic Cats and Hyenas Online