SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal

Israel's cabinet votes to dismiss the head of the security service Shin Bet. Israel's highest court stops the dismissal. It is the government that decides, responds Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

» Published: March 21 2025 at 17:37

Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal
Photo: Gil Cohen-Magen/AP/TT

The dispute between the Prime Minister and the Supreme Court has been going on for a long time, where Israel's current government has wanted to limit the Supreme Court's mandate – which has previously led to massive protests.

The struggle intensified when the government voted on Thursday evening to dismiss Ronen Bar, who is the head of the country's internal security service Shin Bet.

Review Appeals

The decision was temporarily stopped by the country's Supreme Court on Friday. The Supreme Court wants to review the appeals filed against the dismissal. The decision applies until the appeals are presented, no later than April 8.

Israel's Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara then announced that the Prime Minister is not allowed to appoint a successor during the ongoing process.

The response came quickly from Netanyahu:

"The State of Israel is a state of law, and according to the law, it is Israel's government that decides who will lead (intelligence service) Shin Bet", Netanyahu wrote on the X platform. Netanyahu did not mention the Supreme Court, but his statement was still a direct attack on the country's Supreme Court.

Lacks Confidence

Netanyahu stated earlier in the week that he lacks confidence in Bar. The security chief responded in a letter to the assembled ministers, where he repeated his harsh criticism of Netanyahu and his demands for "personal loyalty", which Bar considers inappropriate.

The two men have disagreed on who bears the greater responsibility for Hamas' ability to carry out the bloody terrorist attacks on October 7, 2023.

Ronen Bar says he has taken responsibility for Shin Bet's failure at the time and that Netanyahu's decision has little to do with it.

The dismissal must be formally approved in the Israeli parliament, the Knesset, where Netanyahu's government coalition has a majority.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Niger Declares National Mourning After Deadly Mosque Attack

Niger Declares National Mourning After Deadly Mosque Attack

Israel Intercepts Missile from Yemen Amid Rising Tensions

Israel Intercepts Missile from Yemen Amid Rising Tensions

Oleg Gordievskij, Key Cold War Double Agent Who Exposed Stig Bergling, Dies at 86

Oleg Gordievskij, Key Cold War Double Agent Who Exposed Stig Bergling, Dies at 86

European Ministers Urge Immediate Ceasefire Renewal in Gaza

European Ministers Urge Immediate Ceasefire Renewal in Gaza

Israel Strikes Military Bases in Central Syria, Including Palmyra

Israel Strikes Military Bases in Central Syria, Including Palmyra

Columbia University Agrees to US Demands to Restore Funding

Columbia University Agrees to US Demands to Restore Funding

Erdogan's Crackdown on CHP Sparks Concerns Over Turkey's Democracy

Erdogan's Crackdown on CHP Sparks Concerns Over Turkey's Democracy

Massive Protests Erupt in Istanbul Over Mayor's Arrest

Massive Protests Erupt in Istanbul Over Mayor's Arrest

Ukraine Seeks Ceasefire Progress in Saudi Talks with US and Russia

Ukraine Seeks Ceasefire Progress in Saudi Talks with US and Russia

Russian Drone Strike Sparks Fires and Injuries in Odessa

Russian Drone Strike Sparks Fires and Injuries in Odessa

Germany Approves €3.3 Billion Military Aid Package to Ukraine

Germany Approves €3.3 Billion Military Aid Package to Ukraine

Over 100,000 Flee Eastern Congo Amid Escalating Violence

Over 100,000 Flee Eastern Congo Amid Escalating Violence

Germany Approves 500 Billion Euro Loan Package for Defense and Infrastructure

Germany Approves 500 Billion Euro Loan Package for Defense and Infrastructure

Record Deaths on Migration Routes in 2024, Reports UN Agency

Record Deaths on Migration Routes in 2024, Reports UN Agency

Fire Erupts at Russian Gas Facility Amid Blame Game with Ukraine

Fire Erupts at Russian Gas Facility Amid Blame Game with Ukraine

Russian Security Council Chair Shoygu Meets Kim Jong-Un in North Korea

Russian Security Council Chair Shoygu Meets Kim Jong-Un in North Korea

Sudan's Military Claims Control of Presidential Palace Amid Ongoing Clashes

Sudan's Military Claims Control of Presidential Palace Amid Ongoing Clashes

Russia's Sergey Shoygu Meets Kim Jong-Un in North Korea

Russia's Sergey Shoygu Meets Kim Jong-Un in North Korea

Argentina's CGT Union Calls 24-Hour Strike for April 10

Argentina's CGT Union Calls 24-Hour Strike for April 10

Israeli Court Temporarily Blocks Dismissal of Security Chief

Israeli Court Temporarily Blocks Dismissal of Security Chief

US to Finalize Mineral Agreement with Ukraine Soon, Says Trump

US to Finalize Mineral Agreement with Ukraine Soon, Says Trump

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Stance on Ukraine at EU Summit

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Stance on Ukraine at EU Summit

Israel Strikes Hezbollah Targets in Southern and Eastern Lebanon

Israel Strikes Hezbollah Targets in Southern and Eastern Lebanon

French Doctor Admits to Assaulting 299 Children in Ongoing Trial

French Doctor Admits to Assaulting 299 Children in Ongoing Trial

Haiti's Media Under Siege as Gangs Target Journalists

Haiti's Media Under Siege as Gangs Target Journalists

Israel Intensifies Ground Operations Across Southern Gaza

Israel Intensifies Ground Operations Across Southern Gaza

Norwegian Police in Finnmark Offered Bonuses to Boost Retention

Norwegian Police in Finnmark Offered Bonuses to Boost Retention

Thousands of South Africans Eye US Refugee Status Amid Tensions

Thousands of South Africans Eye US Refugee Status Amid Tensions

Trump Backs Israel's Recent Actions in Gaza, Says White House

Trump Backs Israel's Recent Actions in Gaza, Says White House

Sudan's Army Closes In on Presidential Palace Amid Intensifying Conflict

Sudan's Army Closes In on Presidential Palace Amid Intensifying Conflict

French Citizen Freed After 880 Days in Iranian Detention

French Citizen Freed After 880 Days in Iranian Detention

Zelensky Confirms US Talks on Ceasefire Set for Monday in Saudi Arabia

Zelensky Confirms US Talks on Ceasefire Set for Monday in Saudi Arabia

Teens Among Victims in North Macedonia Nightclub Fire

Teens Among Victims in North Macedonia Nightclub Fire

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Ban on Pride Events at EU Summit

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Ban on Pride Events at EU Summit

UK Report: Up to 250,000 Russian Soldiers Killed in Ukraine Conflict

UK Report: Up to 250,000 Russian Soldiers Killed in Ukraine Conflict

Canada Set for April 28 Elections, Sources Reveal

Canada Set for April 28 Elections, Sources Reveal

USA and Russia to Resume Talks in Saudi Arabia on Monday

USA and Russia to Resume Talks in Saudi Arabia on Monday

Trump Moves to Dissolve Education Department, Cites Sweden as Model

Trump Moves to Dissolve Education Department, Cites Sweden as Model

Zelensky Confirms Upcoming US Talks Amid European Support Tour

Zelensky Confirms Upcoming US Talks Amid European Support Tour

Sweden Ready to Join Ukraine Peacekeeping Talks, Says PM Kristersson

Sweden Ready to Join Ukraine Peacekeeping Talks, Says PM Kristersson