Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal

Israel's cabinet votes to dismiss the head of the security service Shin Bet. Israel's highest court stops the dismissal. It is the government that decides, responds Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

» Published:

Netanyahu and Supreme Court Clash Over Shin Bet Chief's Dismissal
Photo: Gil Cohen-Magen/AP/TT

Share this article

The dispute between the Prime Minister and the Supreme Court has been going on for a long time, where Israel's current government has wanted to limit the Supreme Court's mandate – which has previously led to massive protests.

The struggle intensified when the government voted on Thursday evening to dismiss Ronen Bar, who is the head of the country's internal security service Shin Bet.

Review Appeals

The decision was temporarily stopped by the country's Supreme Court on Friday. The Supreme Court wants to review the appeals filed against the dismissal. The decision applies until the appeals are presented, no later than April 8.

Israel's Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara then announced that the Prime Minister is not allowed to appoint a successor during the ongoing process.

The response came quickly from Netanyahu:

"The State of Israel is a state of law, and according to the law, it is Israel's government that decides who will lead (intelligence service) Shin Bet", Netanyahu wrote on the X platform. Netanyahu did not mention the Supreme Court, but his statement was still a direct attack on the country's Supreme Court.

Lacks Confidence

Netanyahu stated earlier in the week that he lacks confidence in Bar. The security chief responded in a letter to the assembled ministers, where he repeated his harsh criticism of Netanyahu and his demands for "personal loyalty", which Bar considers inappropriate.

The two men have disagreed on who bears the greater responsibility for Hamas' ability to carry out the bloody terrorist attacks on October 7, 2023.

Ronen Bar says he has taken responsibility for Shin Bet's failure at the time and that Netanyahu's decision has little to do with it.

The dismissal must be formally approved in the Israeli parliament, the Knesset, where Netanyahu's government coalition has a majority.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

UN Security Council Condemns Attack on Qatar, Urges De-escalation

UN Security Council Condemns Attack on Qatar, Urges De-escalation

Jair Bolsonaro Faces Conviction for Coup Attempt in Brazil

Jair Bolsonaro Faces Conviction for Coup Attempt in Brazil

Recent Politically Motivated Attacks That Shook the US

Recent Politically Motivated Attacks That Shook the US

Russia Cautions Poland on Belarus Border Closure Consequences

Russia Cautions Poland on Belarus Border Closure Consequences

Netanyahu Declares No Palestinian State in West Bank Speech

Netanyahu Declares No Palestinian State in West Bank Speech

Anti-Islamic Motorcycle Gang Secures Gaza Humanitarian Aid

Anti-Islamic Motorcycle Gang Secures Gaza Humanitarian Aid

Ebola Cases Surge in Congo-Kinshasa Amid Ongoing Outbreak

Ebola Cases Surge in Congo-Kinshasa Amid Ongoing Outbreak

Hyundai Workers Detained in Georgia Returning to South Korea

Hyundai Workers Detained in Georgia Returning to South Korea

Hamas Claims Israeli Attack Halts Ceasefire Talks

Hamas Claims Israeli Attack Halts Ceasefire Talks

Trump Announces Posthumous Medal of Freedom for Charlie Kirk

Trump Announces Posthumous Medal of Freedom for Charlie Kirk

Police Probe Religious Motive in Essen Teacher Stabbing

Police Probe Religious Motive in Essen Teacher Stabbing

FBI Seeks Help Identifying Suspect in Charlie Kirk Murder Case

FBI Seeks Help Identifying Suspect in Charlie Kirk Murder Case

West Africans Deported from USA Arrive in Ghana

West Africans Deported from USA Arrive in Ghana

EU Parliament Backs Recognition of Palestine as Independent State

EU Parliament Backs Recognition of Palestine as Independent State

Red Youth Leader Amrit Kaur Resigns After Controversial Kirk Video

Red Youth Leader Amrit Kaur Resigns After Controversial Kirk Video

UK Ambassador Mandelson Fired Over Leaked Epstein Emails

UK Ambassador Mandelson Fired Over Leaked Epstein Emails

Immunity Removed for AfD Politician Maximilian Krah in Spy Scandal

Immunity Removed for AfD Politician Maximilian Krah in Spy Scandal

EU Court Rules Against Hungarian State Aid for Russian Nuclear Project

EU Court Rules Against Hungarian State Aid for Russian Nuclear Project

NATO Faces Risky Decisions After Russian Drones Enter Polish Airspace

NATO Faces Risky Decisions After Russian Drones Enter Polish Airspace

Bodies Found in Freezers in Finland After 30 Years

Bodies Found in Freezers in Finland After 30 Years