Criticism storm against Katy Perry – flop or satire?

With a new style, a sunny feminist battle song and a full-length album planned for autumn, Katy Perry was supposed to make a grand comeback after the "Smile" album from 2020. Now, instead, it's being talked about as a huge flop. What really happened? We summarize the debate.

» Updated: October 06 2024

» Published: July 19 2024

Criticism storm against Katy Perry – flop or satire?
Photo: Jordan Strauss/AP

With a new style, a sunny feminist battle song, and a full-length album planned for the fall, Katy Perry was supposed to make a grand comeback after the "Smile" album from 2020. Now, instead, it's being talked about as a huge flop.

What really happened? We summarize the debate.

In the spring, pictures emerged of the 39-year-old pop star wearing cyborg-like metal legs, and fans began speculating about a rebranding – something like the futurism seen in Arca or Charli XCX.

Instead, on July 11, a feminist battle song about women's empowerment, "Woman's World", was released, along with a now-notorious music video.

Katy Perry dances in a construction worker-inspired bikini with glittering tools, drinks "whiskey for women", rides a monster truck, and makes a helicopter exit. Everywhere, feminist symbols and oiled, lightly-clad female bodies are visible.

Both the single and the video were panned by a united critical corps – The Guardian's Laura Snapes asked "what is this backward, overheated hell?" while music magazine Pitchfork simply called it "awful". The Cut describes Katy Perry's effort as "an album that will almost certainly flop".

Criticized Collaboration

Something that both critics and fans are pointing out is that "Woman's World" is also produced by longtime collaborator Dr. Luke – who has previously been accused of raping and drugging artist Kesha. After a nearly decade-long legal process, in which Dr. Luke also sued Kesha for defamation, it ended with a settlement in 2023.

Vulture magazine writes in a review that Dr. Luke's involvement contradicts the entire message of the song, and instead recommends other pop artists who portray femininity: Sabrina Carpenter, Billie Eilish, and Chappell Roan, among others.

The Defense: Satire

Now, Katy Perry has published a video on social media that has been interpreted as a response to the harsh criticism. In a sarcastic tone, she explains that they are playing with the concept of "the male gaze".

"We're really going over the top, it's 'on the nose' because we're about to get crushed, which is like a reset for me and my idea of feminine divinity", she says, and continues:

"We're going to a whole new world after this". To the post, she writes "You can do whatever! Even satire!"

It's unclear whether she means by "reset" and the "new world" upcoming songs or the second part of the single "Woman's World". The notorious music video is directed by Charlotte Rutherford, who has a long history of feminist music videos and provocative portrayals of bodies.

Katy Perry was born in 1984 in Santa Barbara, USA.

In 2008, she released the album "One of the Boys", which includes hit singles "I Kissed a Girl" and "Hot n Cold".

Two years later, the successful album "Teenage Dream" was released, with songs like "Firework" and "California Gurls".

Since then, Katy Perry has released the albums "Prism" (2013), "Witness" (2017), and "Smile" (2020). She is one of the best-selling artists in world history.

Throughout her career, Katy Perry has worked with several Swedish producers, including Max Martin, Klas Åhlund, Oscar Görres, and Ilya Salmanzadeh. Another long-time collaborator is American Dr. Luke, who produced the new single "Woman's World".

For several years, Katy Perry has also been a judge on "American Idol". In February 2024, she announced that this year's season would be her last.

Katy Perry is now current with the single release "Woman's World". The album "143" will be released on September 20.

Tags

TTT
By TT - Translated and adapted by Sweden Herald

More news

Oscar Winner Ludwig Göransson Teams
3 MIN READ

Oscar Winner Ludwig Göransson Teams Up Again

Haley Joel Osment Apologizes for
2 MIN READ

Haley Joel Osment Apologizes for Anti-Semitic Remarks After Arrest

Summer 2025: Global Stars and
3 MIN READ

Summer 2025: Global Stars and Swedish Icons Light Up Concert Stages

Malin Stenbäck Exits "Let's Dance"
1 MIN READ

Malin Stenbäck Exits "Let's Dance" After Heartfelt Performance

Nate Bargatze to Host 77th
1 MIN READ

Nate Bargatze to Host 77th Emmy Awards in Los Angeles

Harvey Weinstein Transferred from Rikers
2 MIN READ

Harvey Weinstein Transferred from Rikers to Manhattan Hospital

Menendez Brothers' Sentencing Hearing Delayed
2 MIN READ

Menendez Brothers' Sentencing Hearing Delayed to May 9

Anis Don Demina Unmasked as
2 MIN READ

Anis Don Demina Unmasked as Detective Owl on "Masked Singer"

Bryan Ferry Reflects on Roxy
4 MIN READ

Bryan Ferry Reflects on Roxy Music's Legacy and New Collaborations

Ryan Gosling to Lead in
2 MIN READ

Ryan Gosling to Lead in New 'Star Wars: Starfighter' Film, Premiering 2027

Concert Cancellations Continue for New
1 MIN READ

Concert Cancellations Continue for New Miss Snusk Artist

Cinemas Boost Security for "Minecraft"
1 MIN READ

Cinemas Boost Security for "Minecraft" Movie Screenings

Karl Fredrik Gustafsson Brings Summer
3 MIN READ

Karl Fredrik Gustafsson Brings Summer Charm to SVT's New Show

Gaza Boy's Portrait Wins World
1 MIN READ

Gaza Boy's Portrait Wins World Press Photo Award

Edvin Törnblom's "Edvin's Paradise" Premieres
1 MIN READ

Edvin Törnblom's "Edvin's Paradise" Premieres on TV4 May 5

Nils Poletti Departs Östgötateatern for
1 MIN READ

Nils Poletti Departs Östgötateatern for Parkteatern Leadership Role

Greentea Peng to Perform at
1 MIN READ

Greentea Peng to Perform at Gothenburg's Way Out West Festival

KAJ Leads Betting Odds for
1 MIN READ

KAJ Leads Betting Odds for European Song Contest Victory

Fyre Festival 2 Cancelled; New
1 MIN READ

Fyre Festival 2 Cancelled; New Date to Be Announced

Bianca Ingrosso Returns to "Wahlgren's
1 MIN READ

Bianca Ingrosso Returns to "Wahlgren's World" Full-Time Next Season

Documentary Challenges Riefenstahl's Claims of
3 MIN READ

Documentary Challenges Riefenstahl's Claims of Ignorance on Nazi Atrocities

Michelle Trachtenberg's Death Linked to
1 MIN READ

Michelle Trachtenberg's Death Linked to Diabetes Complications

Rare Signed Nirvana 'Nevermind' Album
1 MIN READ

Rare Signed Nirvana 'Nevermind' Album Sells for £18,600 at Auction

Matilda Klarqvist Triumphs in "Sweden's
3 MIN READ

Matilda Klarqvist Triumphs in "Sweden's Master Chef" Competition

Bronze Reuterswärd Sculpture Stolen from
1 MIN READ

Bronze Reuterswärd Sculpture Stolen from Swedish Sports Hall

Ewan McGregor to Join Stockholm
1 MIN READ

Ewan McGregor to Join Stockholm Comic-Con This June

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Spotify Restores Service After Hours of Global Disruptions

JK Rowling Applauds UK Supreme
1 MIN READ

JK Rowling Applauds UK Supreme Court Ruling on Women's Rights

Gitte Ørskou's Tenure Extended at
1 MIN READ

Gitte Ørskou's Tenure Extended at Modern Museum Until 2026

Gene Hackman's Wife Sought Covid
1 MIN READ

Gene Hackman's Wife Sought Covid Info Before Her Passing

Gayle King Defends Space Travel
1 MIN READ

Gayle King Defends Space Travel Against Environmental Criticism

Culture Minister Outraged by Activists'
1 MIN READ

Culture Minister Outraged by Activists' Vasa Ship Protest

Samar Yazbek's New Work Debuts
1 MIN READ

Samar Yazbek's New Work Debuts at Royal Dramatic Theatre

The Who Parts Ways with
1 MIN READ

The Who Parts Ways with Drummer Zak Starkey After 30 Years

Christina Schollin Joins Cast of
1 MIN READ

Christina Schollin Joins Cast of SVT's "The Beetle Flies at Dusk"

Björn Gustafsson Stars in 'The
2 MIN READ

Björn Gustafsson Stars in 'The Penguin Lessons' and More This Week