Criticism storm against Katy Perry – flop or satire?

With a new style, a sunny feminist battle song and a full-length album planned for autumn, Katy Perry was supposed to make a grand comeback after the "Smile" album from 2020. Now, instead, it's being talked about as a huge flop. What really happened? We summarize the debate.

» Updated:

» Published:

Criticism storm against Katy Perry – flop or satire?
Photo: Jordan Strauss/AP

Share this article

With a new style, a sunny feminist battle song, and a full-length album planned for the fall, Katy Perry was supposed to make a grand comeback after the "Smile" album from 2020. Now, instead, it's being talked about as a huge flop.

What really happened? We summarize the debate.

In the spring, pictures emerged of the 39-year-old pop star wearing cyborg-like metal legs, and fans began speculating about a rebranding – something like the futurism seen in Arca or Charli XCX.

Instead, on July 11, a feminist battle song about women's empowerment, "Woman's World", was released, along with a now-notorious music video.

Katy Perry dances in a construction worker-inspired bikini with glittering tools, drinks "whiskey for women", rides a monster truck, and makes a helicopter exit. Everywhere, feminist symbols and oiled, lightly-clad female bodies are visible.

Both the single and the video were panned by a united critical corps – The Guardian's Laura Snapes asked "what is this backward, overheated hell?" while music magazine Pitchfork simply called it "awful". The Cut describes Katy Perry's effort as "an album that will almost certainly flop".

Criticized Collaboration

Something that both critics and fans are pointing out is that "Woman's World" is also produced by longtime collaborator Dr. Luke – who has previously been accused of raping and drugging artist Kesha. After a nearly decade-long legal process, in which Dr. Luke also sued Kesha for defamation, it ended with a settlement in 2023.

Vulture magazine writes in a review that Dr. Luke's involvement contradicts the entire message of the song, and instead recommends other pop artists who portray femininity: Sabrina Carpenter, Billie Eilish, and Chappell Roan, among others.

The Defense: Satire

Now, Katy Perry has published a video on social media that has been interpreted as a response to the harsh criticism. In a sarcastic tone, she explains that they are playing with the concept of "the male gaze".

"We're really going over the top, it's 'on the nose' because we're about to get crushed, which is like a reset for me and my idea of feminine divinity", she says, and continues:

"We're going to a whole new world after this". To the post, she writes "You can do whatever! Even satire!"

It's unclear whether she means by "reset" and the "new world" upcoming songs or the second part of the single "Woman's World". The notorious music video is directed by Charlotte Rutherford, who has a long history of feminist music videos and provocative portrayals of bodies.

Katy Perry was born in 1984 in Santa Barbara, USA.

In 2008, she released the album "One of the Boys", which includes hit singles "I Kissed a Girl" and "Hot n Cold".

Two years later, the successful album "Teenage Dream" was released, with songs like "Firework" and "California Gurls".

Since then, Katy Perry has released the albums "Prism" (2013), "Witness" (2017), and "Smile" (2020). She is one of the best-selling artists in world history.

Throughout her career, Katy Perry has worked with several Swedish producers, including Max Martin, Klas Åhlund, Oscar Görres, and Ilya Salmanzadeh. Another long-time collaborator is American Dr. Luke, who produced the new single "Woman's World".

For several years, Katy Perry has also been a judge on "American Idol". In February 2024, she announced that this year's season would be her last.

Katy Perry is now current with the single release "Woman's World". The album "143" will be released on September 20.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Robert Gustafsson Reflects on Career in New Documentary Series

Robert Gustafsson Reflects on Career in New Documentary Series

Opera Stopped by Nazis Debuts in Berlin with Norrköping Symphony

Opera Stopped by Nazis Debuts in Berlin with Norrköping Symphony

Jimmy Kimmel's Show Halted by ABC After Controversial Comment

Jimmy Kimmel's Show Halted by ABC After Controversial Comment

Jonas Brothers Return for New Camp Rock Film After 15 Years

Jonas Brothers Return for New Camp Rock Film After 15 Years

Korslagda Kukar Changes Name to Korslagda to Avoid Booking Issues

Korslagda Kukar Changes Name to Korslagda to Avoid Booking Issues

Gold Valued at Millions Stolen from Paris Natural History Museum

Gold Valued at Millions Stolen from Paris Natural History Museum

Norway Urges EBU to Address Israel's Eurovision Participation

Norway Urges EBU to Address Israel's Eurovision Participation

Jan Scherman Awarded Torgny Segerstedt's Freedom Pen for Democracy Work

Jan Scherman Awarded Torgny Segerstedt's Freedom Pen for Democracy Work

Jonas Sjöstedt Calls for Israel's Exclusion from Eurovision

Jonas Sjöstedt Calls for Israel's Exclusion from Eurovision

Melodifestivalen 2026 Tour Cities Announced for Next Year

Melodifestivalen 2026 Tour Cities Announced for Next Year

Hollywood Remembers Robert Redford: A Unique Talent

Hollywood Remembers Robert Redford: A Unique Talent

This Week's Films and Series: Dance and Drama Highlights

This Week's Films and Series: Dance and Drama Highlights

Cecilia Uddén Faces Criticism Over Middle East Book and Gaza Reporting

Cecilia Uddén Faces Criticism Over Middle East Book and Gaza Reporting

Julia Franzén's Film Debut in The Dance Club: A Brave New Role

Julia Franzén's Film Debut in The Dance Club: A Brave New Role

Man Arrested in Atlanta for Theft of Beyoncé's Unreleased Music

Man Arrested in Atlanta for Theft of Beyoncé's Unreleased Music

Court Denies New Trial for Menendez Brothers

Court Denies New Trial for Menendez Brothers

Swedish Filmmaker Lasse Westman Passes Away at 86

Swedish Filmmaker Lasse Westman Passes Away at 86

Måns Zelmerlöw Exits Masked Singer Panel for Upcoming Season

Måns Zelmerlöw Exits Masked Singer Panel for Upcoming Season

Camilla Läckberg's Fjällbacka Murders Adapted for Italian TV Series

Camilla Läckberg's Fjällbacka Murders Adapted for Italian TV Series

Meryl Streep and Jane Fonda Honor Robert Redford After His Passing

Meryl Streep and Jane Fonda Honor Robert Redford After His Passing