The Gender Battle in the Olympic Games: "Individual Cases Can Dominate"

A gender dispute has received major headlines in the Olympic Games as two female boxers who are said to have typically male chromosomes were stopped in the World Championship but are allowed to compete in the Olympic Games. According to chief physician Angelica Hirschberg, female athletes can have a significant advantage if they have high levels of male sex hormone. We know that it plays a major role for performance, she says.

» Updated: September 19 2024

» Published: August 05 2024

The Gender Battle in the Olympic Games: "Individual Cases Can Dominate"
Photo: Tomas Oneborg/SvD/TT

A gender test during the latest World Championship in boxing, which the International Olympic Committee (IOC) does not consider valid, states that Imane Khelif, Algeria, and Lin Yu-Ting, Taiwan, have X and Y chromosomes, which according to the genetic setup usually applies to men.

Since the IOC does not approve of the boxing federation's gender test, both are competing in the Olympic Games, where they have secured a medal since they reached the semifinals.

Even if it is not clear whether the OS boxers have X and Y chromosomes, the question remains whether it has any decisive significance for female athletes' performance if they have X and Y chromosomes.

According to chief physician Angelica Hirschberg, who is also a professor of obstetrics and gynecology, it is not easy how the question should be handled, but she believes that the debate is important for women's sports.

It's so that even if these cases are very rare, they can dominate an entire sport in some cases, says Hirschberg.

Rare cases

Cases where women have a male chromosome set and also produce testosterone at a male level are rare, according to Hirschberg.

In some cases, 10 to 20 times more testosterone can be produced compared to the "normal female level".

We know that it plays a significant role for performance and if you have continued high levels of testosterone and the body can respond to testosterone, then we can say that you have an advantage in terms of performance, says Hirschberg.

Does not assess individuals' gender

Regarding gender tests, Hirschberg wants to make it clear that investigations do not involve making assessments of individuals' gender.

What one is trying to determine with the regulations is – can this woman compete in a female category or not? That is the big question.

We know that there is a very large difference in performance in the normal case between women and men in most sports. The gender difference is 10 to 20 percent and that means that if women were to compete with individuals who have a body biologically developed as a man, then women do not have a chance in most cases, she says.

Corrected: In an earlier version, it was incorrectly stated that the boxers were stopped before the World Championship. Correct is that it happened during the latest World Championship. There are also inaccuracies regarding the gender test performed on the boxers, where the correct information is that the IOC does not approve of the tests.

Chief physician at Karolinska University Hospital and professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Karolinska Institute.

Hirschberg is a medical advisor to the Swedish Olympic Committee (SOC), the International Olympic Committee (IOC), and the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF).

She was a medical expert for the IAAF when the case of runner Caster Semenya, who has hyperandrogenism, was settled in the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) in 2019.

Boxers Imane Khelif from Algeria and Lin Yu-Ting from Taiwan were stopped during the latest World Championship after being disqualified following gender tests conducted by the International Boxing Federation IBA.

According to IBA, the boxers had X and Y chromosomes, which according to the genetic setup usually applies to men. Women usually have two X chromosomes.

The International Olympic Committee, however, believes that the gender tests are not valid and has allowed the boxers to participate in the Olympic Games.

I don't think it should be allowed. Especially not in combat sports where it can be really dangerous, said Caitlin Parker, who competes in the 75-kilo class during the Olympic Games, according to AFP.

The reactions were strongest when Imane Khelif entered the tournament against Angela Carini, who chose to break off the match after 42 seconds.

I've never been beaten so hard before, said the Italian after the match, according to Gazzetta dello Sport.

The International Boxing Federation (IBA) is offering the Italian money, equivalent to what an Olympic champion would receive from IBA, despite the loss in the first round.

IOC President Thomas Bach says that it is "unacceptable" with the hate that the boxers have received.

It is totally unacceptable. We will not participate in a politically motivated culture war. We have two women who were born women, they grew up as women, they are women in their passports, and have competed for many years as women, said Bach at a press conference.

The debate that has arisen during the Olympic Games has its origin in the IOC not allowing IBA to manage the boxing tournament during the Olympic Games due to, among other things, corruption, referee scandals, and Russian connections. The IOC has removed boxing from the Olympic program in Los Angeles 2028.

Tags

TTT
By TT - Translated and adapted by Sweden Herald under license from TT

More news

Ingrid Lindblad Shines with Stellar
1 MIN READ

Ingrid Lindblad Shines with Stellar Round to Lead LPGA Tournament

Gyökeres Hat-Trick Secures Sporting Lisbon's
1 MIN READ

Gyökeres Hat-Trick Secures Sporting Lisbon's Lead Over Moreirense

Elias Pettersson Urged to Improve
2 MIN READ

Elias Pettersson Urged to Improve Training by Canucks Coach Tocchet

Swedish Beach Volleyball Duo Exits
1 MIN READ

Swedish Beach Volleyball Duo Exits World Championship in Brazil

Dallas Stars Face Playoffs Without
1 MIN READ

Dallas Stars Face Playoffs Without Top Scorer Jason Robertson

Ludvig Åberg Struggles to Find
1 MIN READ

Ludvig Åberg Struggles to Find Form at RBC Heritage

Djurgården's Grewe Criticizes AIK Forward
2 MIN READ

Djurgården's Grewe Criticizes AIK Forward for Alleged Spearing Incident

NHL's Forsberg Eager for World
2 MIN READ

NHL's Forsberg Eager for World Championship, But Confirmation Pending

Thoresen's Pep Talk Fuels Djurgården's
3 MIN READ

Thoresen's Pep Talk Fuels Djurgården's Stunning Comeback Victory

Mjällby Defeats Hammarby 3-1, Ending
2 MIN READ

Mjällby Defeats Hammarby 3-1, Ending Winning Streak

Malmö FF Held to Draw
2 MIN READ

Malmö FF Held to Draw by Sirius: "Supporters Deserve Better"

Teen Talent Olivia Ulenius Propels
1 MIN READ

Teen Talent Olivia Ulenius Propels Djurgården to League Summit

Chelsea Eyes Champions League Revenge
3 MIN READ

Chelsea Eyes Champions League Revenge Against Barcelona

Rangers End Season with 4-0
1 MIN READ

Rangers End Season with 4-0 Victory Over Lightning

Calle Halfvarsson Parts Ways with
2 MIN READ

Calle Halfvarsson Parts Ways with National Ski Team After 14 Years

Sagström Tied for Fourth After
1 MIN READ

Sagström Tied for Fourth After Hole-in-One at LPGA Los Angeles

Ludvig Åberg Struggles in South
2 MIN READ

Ludvig Åberg Struggles in South Carolina After US Masters Challenge

Djurgården Secures Semifinal Spot Against
2 MIN READ

Djurgården Secures Semifinal Spot Against Chelsea in Conference League

Filip Forsberg Set for Home
1 MIN READ

Filip Forsberg Set for Home World Championship with Sweden

Tottenham Advances to Europa League
1 MIN READ

Tottenham Advances to Europa League Semifinals with Win Over Frankfurt

Sweden Edges Finland 2-1 in
2 MIN READ

Sweden Edges Finland 2-1 in World Championship Warm-Up

Olympic Champion Ahmed Hafnaoui Receives
1 MIN READ

Olympic Champion Ahmed Hafnaoui Receives 21-Month Doping Ban

Scottie Scheffler Doubts Rangefinders Will
2 MIN READ

Scottie Scheffler Doubts Rangefinders Will Speed Up Golf Rounds

Tove Alexandersson Criticizes Media for
2 MIN READ

Tove Alexandersson Criticizes Media for Misinterpreting Her Views

Hockeyallsvenskan Enforces Rule to Protect
3 MIN READ

Hockeyallsvenskan Enforces Rule to Protect Referees During Finals

Virgil van Dijk Signs Two-Year
1 MIN READ

Virgil van Dijk Signs Two-Year Extension with Liverpool

Sweden Exits World Championship After
2 MIN READ

Sweden Exits World Championship After Controversial Loss to Finland

Alexander Straus to Coach Celebrity-Backed
1 MIN READ

Alexander Straus to Coach Celebrity-Backed Angel City FC

Daniel Hermansson Named Skellefteå AIK's
1 MIN READ

Daniel Hermansson Named Skellefteå AIK's New Head Coach

London City Lionesses Near Top
3 MIN READ

London City Lionesses Near Top League Promotion with Three Matches Left

Möregårdh Reaches Quarterfinals; Källberg Falls
2 MIN READ

Möregårdh Reaches Quarterfinals; Källberg Falls Short in Thriller

Miami Heat Advances in NBA
1 MIN READ

Miami Heat Advances in NBA Play-In Without Pelle Larsson

New TV Deal Poses Challenges
3 MIN READ

New TV Deal Poses Challenges for Smaller Allsvenskan Clubs

Montreal Clinches Final Stanley Cup
1 MIN READ

Montreal Clinches Final Stanley Cup Playoff Spot with Win Over Carolina

Inter Secures Semifinal Spot with
2 MIN READ

Inter Secures Semifinal Spot with Quick Goals Against Bayern

Isabelle Gulldén Retires from Handball
2 MIN READ

Isabelle Gulldén Retires from Handball After Illustrious Career