ICJ’s Myanmar Genocide Ruling Could Shape Israel Case Over Gaza
Photo: Shamimul Islam Faisal/AP/TT

ICJ’s Myanmar Genocide Ruling Could Shape Israel Case Over Gaza

The historic genocide ruling against Myanmar offers the Rohingya a reprieve. But it could also have implications for another genocide case - the one against Israel over Gaza. “It’s the same court, and it tries to follow its own precedents,” says international law professor Mark Klamberg.

Advertisement

Following the International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) ruling that Myanmar committed genocide, the EU praised its “crucial role” in upholding the rule of law at the international level. The ruling went further than Mark Klamberg, a professor of international law at Stockholm University, had expected.

They went all the way, and that is remarkable. It is an important ruling in that way.

It will likely be read carefully by Israel, which is currently facing the ICJ over charges of genocide in Gaza. Klamberg believes the ruling could have significance.

There was precedent before, but there have been some clarifications, he says.

Clarifications

Mark Klamberg points out that during a case between Bosnia and Serbia, there was a discussion about how many people had to be affected for an act to be called genocide. He believes the court has now clarified three crucial criteria.

The first is the number of people affected. The second is the size of the area controlled by the accused party and how it acts there.

The third is how important the affected part is to the entire group. This is what you need to look at to see if there is an intention to destroy a group in whole or in part.

The ruling may also be relevant for Germany, which has been sued by Nicaragua before the ICJ. Germany is accused of having facilitated and failed to prevent genocide in Gaza through arms deliveries to Israel and the suspension of support for the UN relief agency UNRWA.

Pressures

The question is whether the Rohingya will receive justice beyond the ruling on paper. Myanmar has called the ruling unfair and announced that it will review it carefully.

The decision talks about compensation and that the Rohingya will have the right to return. Myanmar is legally obliged to comply with it, but the question is: will it really happen? The court does not have its own police or any other coercive power that can force them, says Mark Klamberg.

If Myanmar does not act, pressure from UN member states and the UN Security Council will be required, according to Klamberg. There may be deadlocks there - Donald Trump's administration has been critical of international law, for example.

But the conditions for other states to act now exist, Klamberg says.

It could involve diplomatic exchange or various forms of economic pressure. Sweden has previously provided aid that it has ended; it could resume it and support, for example, journalists or other strategic groups or individuals.

In this story
AuthorTT News AgencyEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for our readers
Was this useful?

What do you think?

Keep readingmore from Conflicts

All