SwedenLivingWorld world_2_fill WorldBusiness BusinessSports sports-soccer SportsEntertainmentEntertain

Expert: USA's proposal puts Putin in a difficult situation

The USA's turnaround on the war puts pressure on Russia, according to two experts. Vladimir Putin may very well be forced to accept the proposal for a ceasefire, they believe. The question is what happens next.

» Published: March 12 2025

Expert: USA's proposal puts Putin in a difficult situation
Photo: Jose Luis Magana/AP/TT

Fredrik Wesslau, formerly deputy chief of the EU mission in Ukraine and now at the Centre for East European Studies, is sitting in a taxi through Kyiv. Since Tuesday's message from Jeddah – when Ukraine was said to have accepted the US proposal for a ceasefire – the atmosphere in the Ukrainian capital has changed.

People are relieved, above all that the American arms deliveries and sharing of intelligence have started again and that the ball is now in Russia's court. It's a positive atmosphere, says Wesslau over the phone.

The fact that the so-called American proposal is actually a direct copy of the proposal that Ukraine, the UK, and France presented earlier in March about a 30-day ceasefire in the air and at sea – plays a lesser role, he says.

That they call it American puts even more pressure on Russia to actually say yes. Let the US own it – it's better for the process, I believe.

Time to gear up?

The proposal puts Russia in a difficult situation where they now have to make a calculated assessment. On the one hand, Moscow has signaled that they want a ceasefire, on the other hand, the proposal means that the military pressure on Ukraine will ease. Now it remains to be seen how President Putin chooses to respond.

It could be a yes, but then come with additional political demands from Russia to agree to it. Or they say yes, but don't respect the ceasefire. That would be very typical of Russia, says Fredrik Wesslau.

A month-long ceasefire would mean a welcome respite for Ukraine. But also risks – at least if no security guarantees from Europe and the US are given, warns he.

It would mean a very unstable peace – or rather a ceasefire that gives Russia time to gear up and attack again in a few years.

"Breaks all agreements"

Jakob Hedenskog, also a Ukraine analyst at the Centre for East European Studies at UI, is unsure of the US's intentions. Donald Trump sees himself as the "CEO of the company USA" and acts according to what is best for himself, he says.

Therefore, it is unclear how far he is willing to go if Russia now kicks back. Will he insist on moving forward or just say: "I did what I could, they didn't want peace"?

Hedenskog still sees it as fairly likely that Putin will accept the proposed proposal. But Russia traditionally breaks all agreements, he emphasizes.

It's highly likely that there will be many breaches of the ceasefire. The important thing is to get long-term conditions for Ukraine to survive as a sovereign state – and not to ease the pressure on Putin just because he agrees to a 30-day ceasefire.

Ukraine and Russia are to agree on an immediate, 30-day ceasefire that can be extended according to agreement.

The ceasefire primarily applies in the air and at sea.

The statement about the US proposal, which Ukraine has approved, did not provide many details.

For example, nothing is mentioned about the Russian-occupied territories in Ukraine, nor the possibility of peacekeeping forces that can monitor the ceasefire on site.

On the other hand, it mentions the exchange of prisoners of war, the release of civilian detainees, and the return of forcibly displaced Ukrainian children.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Argentina's CGT Union Calls 24-Hour Strike for April 10

Argentina's CGT Union Calls 24-Hour Strike for April 10

Netanyahu's Cabinet Moves to Dismiss Shin Bet Chief Ronen Bar

Netanyahu's Cabinet Moves to Dismiss Shin Bet Chief Ronen Bar

US to Finalize Mineral Agreement with Ukraine Soon, Says Trump

US to Finalize Mineral Agreement with Ukraine Soon, Says Trump

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Stance on Ukraine at EU Summit

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Stance on Ukraine at EU Summit

Israel Strikes Hezbollah Targets in Southern and Eastern Lebanon

Israel Strikes Hezbollah Targets in Southern and Eastern Lebanon

French Doctor Admits to Assaulting 299 Children in Ongoing Trial

French Doctor Admits to Assaulting 299 Children in Ongoing Trial

Haiti's Media Under Siege as Gangs Target Journalists

Haiti's Media Under Siege as Gangs Target Journalists

Israel Intensifies Ground Operations Across Southern Gaza

Israel Intensifies Ground Operations Across Southern Gaza

Norwegian Police in Finnmark Offered Bonuses to Boost Retention

Norwegian Police in Finnmark Offered Bonuses to Boost Retention

Thousands of South Africans Eye US Refugee Status Amid Tensions

Thousands of South Africans Eye US Refugee Status Amid Tensions

Trump Backs Israel's Recent Actions in Gaza, Says White House

Trump Backs Israel's Recent Actions in Gaza, Says White House

Sudan's Army Closes In on Presidential Palace Amid Intensifying Conflict

Sudan's Army Closes In on Presidential Palace Amid Intensifying Conflict

French Citizen Freed After 880 Days in Iranian Detention

French Citizen Freed After 880 Days in Iranian Detention

Teens Among Victims in North Macedonia Nightclub Fire

Teens Among Victims in North Macedonia Nightclub Fire

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Ban on Pride Events at EU Summit

Kristersson Criticizes Hungary's Ban on Pride Events at EU Summit

UK Report: Up to 250,000 Russian Soldiers Killed in Ukraine Conflict

UK Report: Up to 250,000 Russian Soldiers Killed in Ukraine Conflict

Canada Set for April 28 Elections, Sources Reveal

Canada Set for April 28 Elections, Sources Reveal

Zelensky Confirms Upcoming US Talks Amid European Support Tour

Zelensky Confirms Upcoming US Talks Amid European Support Tour

Sweden Ready to Join Ukraine Peacekeeping Talks, Says PM Kristersson

Sweden Ready to Join Ukraine Peacekeeping Talks, Says PM Kristersson

Istanbul Protests Escalate as Police Use Tear Gas and Rubber Bullets

Istanbul Protests Escalate as Police Use Tear Gas and Rubber Bullets

EU's Defense Funding: Navigating Complex Paths to Billions by 2030

EU's Defense Funding: Navigating Complex Paths to Billions by 2030

Meta AI Debuts in Europe, Navigating Unique Regulatory Landscape

Meta AI Debuts in Europe, Navigating Unique Regulatory Landscape

Israeli Forces Down Yemen-Launched Drone Targeting Ben Gurion Airport

Israeli Forces Down Yemen-Launched Drone Targeting Ben Gurion Airport

Greenpeace Faces $660 Million Penalty Over Dakota Pipeline Protests

Greenpeace Faces $660 Million Penalty Over Dakota Pipeline Protests

Israel Claims Killing of Hamas Intelligence Chief in Gaza Strikes

Israel Claims Killing of Hamas Intelligence Chief in Gaza Strikes

13 Soldiers Killed in Niger Attacks by Jihadist Groups

13 Soldiers Killed in Niger Attacks by Jihadist Groups

Russian Drone Attack in Ukraine Leaves Two Dead, Several Injured

Russian Drone Attack in Ukraine Leaves Two Dead, Several Injured

Istanbul Erupts in Protest After Mayor's Arrest Despite Ban

Istanbul Erupts in Protest After Mayor's Arrest Despite Ban

Tourist Survives 7-Hour Avalanche Ordeal in Norway's Lyngen Alps

Tourist Survives 7-Hour Avalanche Ordeal in Norway's Lyngen Alps

Unicef Highlights Gaza's Crisis: Children Face Fear and Uncertainty

Unicef Highlights Gaza's Crisis: Children Face Fear and Uncertainty

Russia and Ukraine Swap 372 POWs with UAE Mediation

Russia and Ukraine Swap 372 POWs with UAE Mediation

Sweden and Allies Urge EU to Fast-Track Ukraine Membership Talks

Sweden and Allies Urge EU to Fast-Track Ukraine Membership Talks

Trump and Zelensky Agree on Ceasefire to Protect Ukraine's Energy Grid

Trump and Zelensky Agree on Ceasefire to Protect Ukraine's Energy Grid

Protests Erupt in Jerusalem Against Netanyahu's Gaza Decisions

Protests Erupt in Jerusalem Against Netanyahu's Gaza Decisions

North Macedonia Shuts Down Unlicensed Nightclubs After Tragic Fire

North Macedonia Shuts Down Unlicensed Nightclubs After Tragic Fire

EU Unveils Readiness 2030: A New Era for European Defense Strategy

EU Unveils Readiness 2030: A New Era for European Defense Strategy

Air Leaks from the Inflatable: Deadly Migrant Shipwreck

Air Leaks from the Inflatable: Deadly Migrant Shipwreck

Zelensky: Speaking with Trump today

Zelensky: Speaking with Trump today

Greenland: No Foreign Election Interference

Greenland: No Foreign Election Interference

Israel Launches Targeted Ground Operation in Gaza's Netzarim Corridor

Israel Launches Targeted Ground Operation in Gaza's Netzarim Corridor