Demand on tech giants: Protect children or pay

Australia has put its foot down against popular platforms like Facebook, Instagram and X. Social media is banned for children under 16 – now the tech giants must find ways to stop young people from using them. As soon as the kids started with social media, the addiction was enormous, says Swedish teenage parent Josefin Fox in Australia – who simultaneously sees the ban as the wrong way to go.

» Published: December 02 2024

Demand on tech giants: Protect children or pay
Photo: Rick Rycroft/AP/TT

Half past twelve at night and after a heated debate, the Australian Senate passed a ban on social media for children under 16 years old last week.

A platform for group pressure, a source of anxiety, a tool for scammers, and, worst of all, a tool for online criminals, said Prime Minister Anthony Albanese before the vote and urged young people to put down their phones and head to the sports fields.

He represents the centre-left Labour Party and is one of those who have driven the push for a law change.

When the law comes into force, social media companies will have to take "reasonable measures" to prevent young teenagers from having accounts. The companies risk fines of up to 50 million Australian dollars (approximately 355 million Swedish kronor) if they do not follow the rules.

Intensive debate

Although the law was adopted with a large majority in parliament, the debate has been intense and many have expressed concerns.

The concept of excluding part of our population from a form of communication does not feel right. I respect the arguments from my colleagues who think we should do something, and clearly we should do something, but not like this, said, for example, Liberal Senator Richard Colbeck before the vote, reports ABC.

On paper, the new law is one of the strictest in the world. At the same time, there are virtually no clear details on how the ban will be enforced in practice. It is up to the social media giants behind the platforms to find technical solutions.

Everything should be in place within a year.

It requires an infrastructure, otherwise it can become a futile effort if you just set up a requirement without knowing how it will be followed, says Daniel Westman, a lawyer specializing in media law.

He also sees challenges related to a requirement for identification.

If you require identification to use these services, it will have consequences for other users as well. Then you cannot have anonymous accounts, for example, and that can be both good and bad, he says.

"The change is total"

Swedish Josefin Fox has lived in Wollongong, near Sydney, with her children, aged 13 and 16, since 2012.

I've thought a lot about this and what's really behind the proposal. It's going to be so fast to push through the new law, and I wonder why they don't take the time to discuss it properly first, she says to TT.

At the same time, she agrees that children's and young people's use of social media is a huge problem.

As soon as the kids started with social media, the addiction was huge, and they want to sit with their phones all day. The change is total, and it's something many parents experience, she says.

If you ask me if it would be better for children not to be on social media, the answer is yes. But if you ask me if a ban is the right way to go, I'm hesitant. How do you check that it's being followed? I think it's hard to make it work in practice, says Josefin Fox.

"Will find a way"

Many young people are also expected to try to circumvent the rules.

I want to continue using it. It will feel weird not to have it and be able to talk to all my friends at home. I'll find a way. And so will all my other friends, says 12-year-old Angus Lydom to AFP.

Alexandra Weilenmann is a professor of interaction design at the University of Gothenburg. In addition to the practical difficulties associated with a ban and its enforcement, she also sees other problems.

In my opinion, it's not about whether we should have social media or not. It's much more complicated than that, but it doesn't go home politically. You take a hard line and then it's a ban, she says.

Weilenmann emphasizes that social media is both good and bad, and that a ban also affects the positive aspects.

But it's of course much more complicated and costly to target the problematic aspects. It's quite easy for a politician to say they're banning something, she says.

No specific list of platforms covered by the law on 16-year-olds has been made public.

The law's definition of social media is very broad. It describes social media as an electronic service that meets the following conditions:

The sole or primary purpose of the service is to enable social interaction online between two or more end-users

The service allows end-users to link to or interact with some or all other end-users

The service allows end-users to upload material to the service.

Source: ABC

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Visits Greenland as Concerns Over US Interest Persist

China Conducts Extensive Military Drills
1 MIN READ

China Conducts Extensive Military Drills Near Taiwan's Coast

White House Evaluates Economic Impact
2 MIN READ

White House Evaluates Economic Impact of Potential Greenland Acquisition

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored
2 MIN READ

WWII Codebreaker Charlotte Webb, Honored by Queen, Dies at 101

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev to Meet
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev to Meet US Officials in Washington Talks

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Russian Drone Strike Injures Three in Kharkiv, Ukraine

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech
3 MIN READ

Cory Booker's 25-Hour Senate Speech Sets Record in Trump Protest

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over
2 MIN READ

Trump Adviser Faces Scrutiny Over Private Email Use in Security Role

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential
1 MIN READ

Zelenskyj Seeks Support for Potential Peacekeeping Forces in Ukraine

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit
1 MIN READ

Denmark Sets 18-Year Age Limit for High-Alcohol Drinks

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict
2 MIN READ

Le Pen Awaits Appeal Verdict on 2027 Election Ban Next Summer

Fourth Missing US Soldier Found
1 MIN READ

Fourth Missing US Soldier Found Dead in Lithuania

Russian Advances in Eastern Ukraine
1 MIN READ

Russian Advances in Eastern Ukraine Slow for Fourth Month

Bird Flu Outbreak Hits Danish
1 MIN READ

Bird Flu Outbreak Hits Danish Farm, 24 Chickens Culled

23 States Sue Trump Administration
2 MIN READ

23 States Sue Trump Administration Over Health Funding Cuts

Europol Set for Expansion in
1 MIN READ

Europol Set for Expansion in New EU Security Strategy

Search Continues for Missing Plane
1 MIN READ

Search Continues for Missing Plane in Norway with Two Feared Dead

Trump's First Foreign Trip as
1 MIN READ

Trump's First Foreign Trip as President: Saudi Arabia and Beyond

Danish Police Arrest 10 Bandidos
1 MIN READ

Danish Police Arrest 10 Bandidos Gang Members at Sejet Inn

German EU Politician Faces Probe
1 MIN READ

German EU Politician Faces Probe Over Controversial Nazi Greeting Post

EU Eyes Boosting Eastern Infrastructure
1 MIN READ

EU Eyes Boosting Eastern Infrastructure for Defense and Development

23 States Sue Trump Administration
2 MIN READ

23 States Sue Trump Administration Over $11 Billion Health Cuts

Israel Sets Record for Palestinian
3 MIN READ

Israel Sets Record for Palestinian Home Demolitions in West Bank

Red Cross Faces Deadliest Attack
2 MIN READ

Red Cross Faces Deadliest Attack in Eight Years During Gaza Conflict

Georgia Approves US-Inspired Agent Law
1 MIN READ

Georgia Approves US-Inspired Agent Law After Criticism

Scottish Fisherman Missing Since 2021
1 MIN READ

Scottish Fisherman Missing Since 2021 Identified on Norwegian Coast

Ukraine Election Preparations Denied by
1 MIN READ

Ukraine Election Preparations Denied by Zelenskyj's Party Leader

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Norwegian Man Gets Life for Murdering Finnish Hockey Star Janne Puhakka

Denmark Sees Highest Wolf Population
1 MIN READ

Denmark Sees Highest Wolf Population in Modern History

USA and Ukraine Resume Talks
1 MIN READ

USA and Ukraine Resume Talks on Key Mineral Agreement

Finland Prepares to Exit Ottawa
1 MIN READ

Finland Prepares to Exit Ottawa Treaty on Personal Mines

Denmark Boosts Defense with 130
1 MIN READ

Denmark Boosts Defense with 130 New Armored Vehicles from Finland

Media Worker Killed in Gaza
1 MIN READ

Media Worker Killed in Gaza as Evacuations Ordered in the North

Palestinian Teen Dies in Israeli
2 MIN READ

Palestinian Teen Dies in Israeli Prison After Six Months Without Charge

Bardella Slams Le Pen Verdict
1 MIN READ

Bardella Slams Le Pen Verdict as Politically Driven in EU Funds Case

Iceland's Grindavík Evacuated as Lava
2 MIN READ

Iceland's Grindavík Evacuated as Lava Flows from New Eruption

Woman Rescued 91 Hours After
3 MIN READ

Woman Rescued 91 Hours After Myanmar Earthquake Kills 2,700

UNICEF Reports Over 300 Children
1 MIN READ

UNICEF Reports Over 300 Children Killed in Gaza in Recent Conflict

145 Injured in Massive Gas
2 MIN READ

145 Injured in Massive Gas Pipeline Fire Near Kuala Lumpur

Netanyahu Reconsiders Shin Bet Appointment
2 MIN READ

Netanyahu Reconsiders Shin Bet Appointment After US Criticism