Ranstorp: The War Does Not End with Sinwar - "Naive"

The Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar was killed last week. But the terrorist-classified movement is stronger than its military branch – and will be able to be rebuilt again, according to Hamas expert Magnus Ranstorp. And in Israel, there are strong forces that want to continue waging war.

» Published: October 19 2024

Ranstorp: The War Does Not End with Sinwar - "Naive"
Photo: Linus Sundahl-Djerf/SvD/TT

With the architect behind the terrorist attack on Israel on October 7 - Yahya Sinwar - dead, there is an opening for Benjamin Netanyahu's fragile coalition government to declare victory in the Gaza War and initiate negotiations to bring home the hostages.

Yahya Sinwar was notorious for his fanaticism and brutality, and during the negotiations with Israel, he was stone-hard in his demands for a permanent ceasefire.

It is possible that another leadership (in Hamas) might now be open to compromising on certain principles in the negotiations, says Isabell Schierenbeck, political scientist at the University of Gothenburg and Middle East expert.

"Naive"

However, there are parties within Israel's coalition government that do not want to negotiate - instead, they see Sinwar's death as an opportunity to strike even harder against Hamas, and then continue with the same tactics against Hezbollah.

Isabell Schierenbeck sees both scenarios as equally likely. She notes that several factors can influence the outcome: Israel's promised retaliation against Iran after the major robot attack, the upcoming presidential election in the USA, the internal protests against the government in Israel, and the demand to free the hostages - as well as the question of who will lead the negotiations from Hamas' side.

For terrorism researcher Magnus Ranstorp, who has written a book about Hamas and has interviewed several of its leaders over the years, it is naive to see Sinwar's death as "the beginning of the end" for the movement.

The Goals Remain

The military part, the Qassam Brigades, has received a significant blow with the decapitated leadership. Moreover, Israel claims that tens of thousands of fighters have been killed. But Hamas is a multifaceted movement with collective leadership and a very strong social and religious activity, says Ranstorp.

Israel has actually only reached a part of Hamas' structure in Gaza, and it is not even totally decimated there. Hamas has a much broader presence and a leadership structure that makes it quite resilient.

Magnus Ranstorp also points out the possibility that certain issues may become easier to negotiate with someone other than Sinwar at the helm.

But the maximalist goal of an Islamic state in Palestine - which Hamas has trained hundreds of thousands of Palestinian youths in under ideological and military training camps over the years - is unwavering, he says.

Sinwar's death is an enormous setback, but they will lift themselves up gradually.

Tags

TTT
By TTThis article has been altered and translated by Sweden Herald

More news

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Russian Drone Strikes on Ukraine Leave 3 Dead, 32 Injured

Israel Updates Music Festival Death
2 MIN READ

Israel Updates Music Festival Death Toll to 378 After Investigation

Two Dead in Norwegian Plane
1 MIN READ

Two Dead in Norwegian Plane Crash Near Bergen Lake

Pentagon Probes Use of Signal
1 MIN READ

Pentagon Probes Use of Signal App for Discussing Yemen Attack Plans

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Frederiksen to USA: Annexation Not an Option, Let's Strengthen Arctic Security

Seoul Braces for Verdict as
3 MIN READ

Seoul Braces for Verdict as South Korea Awaits Yoon's Fate

Myanmar Earthquake Death Toll Rises
2 MIN READ

Myanmar Earthquake Death Toll Rises as Aid Efforts Intensify

Trump Fires Key Security Officials
2 MIN READ

Trump Fires Key Security Officials After Oval Office Meeting

Serbian Students Bike 130 Miles
1 MIN READ

Serbian Students Bike 130 Miles to EU Parliament Seeking Support

Iranian Judge Linked to 1988
1 MIN READ

Iranian Judge Linked to 1988 Executions Dies at 70

UN Alarmed by Reports of
1 MIN READ

UN Alarmed by Reports of Civilian Executions in Sudan

Mother and Daughter Found Shot
1 MIN READ

Mother and Daughter Found Shot Dead in Norway; Suspect Also Dead

Elon Musk to Stay as
1 MIN READ

Elon Musk to Stay as Advisor to Trump, Confirms JD Vance

Israeli Legal Experts Call for
1 MIN READ

Israeli Legal Experts Call for War Crimes Probe into Gaza Attack

EU Parliament Approves Delay in
1 MIN READ

EU Parliament Approves Delay in Key Sustainability Rules

Denmark Stands Firm on Sovereignty
2 MIN READ

Denmark Stands Firm on Sovereignty in Talks with US

Modi's New Law Fuels Discrimination
1 MIN READ

Modi's New Law Fuels Discrimination Concerns in India

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting
1 MIN READ

Israel Probes Deadly Ambulance Shooting in Gaza Strip

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives
1 MIN READ

California Wildfires Claim 30 Lives as Recovery Efforts Continue

Norovirus Hits Queen Mary 2
1 MIN READ

Norovirus Hits Queen Mary 2 Cruise, Over 240 Passengers Affected

Rubio Affirms US Commitment to
3 MIN READ

Rubio Affirms US Commitment to NATO, Calls for Increased Defense Spending

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold
1 MIN READ

Bandidos European President Michael Rosenvold Passes Away

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package
1 MIN READ

Denmark Pledges Major Support Package to Ukraine

Russia Not on US Tariff
2 MIN READ

Russia Not on US Tariff List Despite Broad Global Reach

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women
1 MIN READ

Gaza Blockade Endangers Pregnant Women and Newborns, Says Save the Children

Tragedy Strikes as Boats Sink
1 MIN READ

Tragedy Strikes as Boats Sink Near Greece and Turkey, 16 Migrants Dead

Search for Missing MH370 Paused
1 MIN READ

Search for Missing MH370 Paused Until Year-End, Says Malaysia

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze
1 MIN READ

17 Tesla Cars Set Ablaze in Rome; Italy Boosts Security Measures

UN Envoy Urges Israel to
2 MIN READ

UN Envoy Urges Israel to Halt Strikes in Southern Syria

US Calls for UN Official's
1 MIN READ

US Calls for UN Official's Removal Over Alleged Anti-Semitic Views

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Meets US
1 MIN READ

Russian Envoy Dmitrijev Meets US Officials in Washington for Talks

31 Killed in Israeli Air
1 MIN READ

31 Killed in Israeli Air Strike on Gaza School Shelter

Netanyahu's Visit to Hungary Sparks
3 MIN READ

Netanyahu's Visit to Hungary Sparks ICC Withdrawal Decision

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350
1 MIN READ

Slovakia Approves Culling of 350 Bears After Fatal Attack

Genre image
1 MIN READ

Israeli Air Strikes in Syria Leave Four Dead, Hit Military Sites

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of
1 MIN READ

Mike Waltz's Extensive Use of Signal Raises Security Concerns

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland
2 MIN READ

Frederiksen Pledges Support for Greenland During Challenging Times

Elon Musk Expected to Exit
2 MIN READ

Elon Musk Expected to Exit White House Role Soon, Sources Say

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's
2 MIN READ

NATO Faces Silence on Turkey's Journalist Arrest Before Key Meeting

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges
1 MIN READ

Federal Court Dismisses Corruption Charges Against NYC Mayor Adams