High Civilian Death Rate in Gaza Raises Concerns

Over 80 percent of the fatalities in Gaza may be civilians, according to an examination by, among others, The Guardian which retrieved figures from an Israeli military database. Unusually high if it is true, according to researchers at Uppsala University.

» Published:

High Civilian Death Rate in Gaza Raises Concerns
Photo: Mariam Dagga/AP/TT

Share this article

In May, 8,900 named combatants for Hamas and Islamic Jihad were listed as dead or "likely dead" in the classified military database, according to the investigation.

At the same time, the Hamas-controlled health authorities in Gaza reported that 53,000 Palestinians had been killed in Israeli attacks.

"Very unusual"

The named combatants make up 17 percent of that figure. If all the remaining 83 percent were civilians, the proportion of civilian casualties in the war would be unusually high compared to other conflicts since 1989, says Therése Pettersson at Uppsala University's conflict database UCDP to The Guardian.

Especially considering it has been going on for so long.

If you isolate a particular city or battle in another conflict, you can find similar proportions, but it is very unusual overall, she continues.

UCDP maps civilian casualties in conflicts around the world.

Israel: Incorrect figures

Behind the investigation are The Guardian, the Hebrew-language site Local Call and +972, an Israeli-Palestinian blog collective that, according to its own statement, wants to be an alternative to established media and conduct "intersectional and progressive" journalism.

The Israeli military states in a statement to The Guardian that the figures presented in the article are incorrect and that they "do not reflect the data in the military's system". Previously, both Israeli politicians and military commanders have stated that significantly more than 8,900 Palestinian combatants have been killed in Gaza.

In its annual report for 2024, UCDP notes that it has generally become more difficult for researchers to determine who are civilians and who belong to armed groups, and specifically mentions wars where densely populated areas are bombed from the air.

Israel does not allow international journalists into Gaza, and information about the number of people killed in the war is often difficult to verify.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Sebastien Lecornu Sworn In as Protests Erupt Across France

Sebastien Lecornu Sworn In as Protests Erupt Across France

Netanyahu Urges Qatar to Expel or Prosecute Terrorists

Netanyahu Urges Qatar to Expel or Prosecute Terrorists

Right-wing Commentator Charlie Kirk Shot Dead at US University

Right-wing Commentator Charlie Kirk Shot Dead at US University

Cuba Faces Fifth Nationwide Power Outage This Year

Cuba Faces Fifth Nationwide Power Outage This Year

Deadly Floods Devastate Bali and Flores, 15 Dead and 6 Missing

Deadly Floods Devastate Bali and Flores, 15 Dead and 6 Missing

Qatar's Neutrality Questioned After Israeli Airstrike in Doha

Qatar's Neutrality Questioned After Israeli Airstrike in Doha

New Concerns Arise for Ursula von der Leyen in European Parliament

New Concerns Arise for Ursula von der Leyen in European Parliament

Israeli Airstrikes in Yemen Kill Over 30, Houthi Movement Reports

Israeli Airstrikes in Yemen Kill Over 30, Houthi Movement Reports

Nepal Military Enforces Control Amid Protests and Government Resignation

Nepal Military Enforces Control Amid Protests and Government Resignation

IS Member Sentenced to Life for Fatal Knife Attack at German Festival

IS Member Sentenced to Life for Fatal Knife Attack at German Festival

France Faces Protests as New Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu Takes Office

France Faces Protests as New Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu Takes Office

EU Proposes Pausing Trade Agreement with Israel Amid Gaza Concerns

EU Proposes Pausing Trade Agreement with Israel Amid Gaza Concerns

Trump Criticizes Israel Over Qatar Incident: "Not Satisfied"

Trump Criticizes Israel Over Qatar Incident: "Not Satisfied"

Poland Shoots Down Russian Drones: Expert Says It Was Inevitable

Poland Shoots Down Russian Drones: Expert Says It Was Inevitable

Trump Questions Russian Drone Incursion in Poland

Trump Questions Russian Drone Incursion in Poland

EU Leader Ursula von der Leyen Faces Pressure in Parliament This Autumn

EU Leader Ursula von der Leyen Faces Pressure in Parliament This Autumn

Poland Invokes NATO Article 4 After Russian Drone Airspace Violation

Poland Invokes NATO Article 4 After Russian Drone Airspace Violation

Greta Thunberg's Convoy Targeted by Drone Attack for Second Night

Greta Thunberg's Convoy Targeted by Drone Attack for Second Night

Two Judges Find Bolsonaro Guilty in Coup Attempt Trial

Two Judges Find Bolsonaro Guilty in Coup Attempt Trial

Israeli Airstrike in Doha Targets Hamas Leadership; Conflicting Reports on Casualties

Israeli Airstrike in Doha Targets Hamas Leadership; Conflicting Reports on Casualties