Expert slams Paludan verdict: "Beyond reasonable"

Rasmus Paludan has been sentenced to prison for two cases of incitement to racial hatred after statements that the district court considers to be offensive towards Muslims. It is like an introduction of a form of blasphemy legislation, says freedom of expression expert Nils Funcke.

» Published: November 05 2024

Expert slams Paludan verdict: "Beyond reasonable"
Photo: Janerik Henriksson/TT

Share this article

The criticism is directed at the first charge, where Paludan himself believes that he has expressed himself critically about Islam and thus stayed within the limits of freedom of speech.

The Malmö District Court has interpreted the statements differently and considers that Paludan turned to Muslims when he, for example, said "Islam is good at killing".

In another example, the court, in accordance with the prosecutor, has interpreted "Islam as a religion cannot possibly like Western democracy and freedom of speech" as "Muslims do not like Western democracy and freedom of speech".

"Too far-reaching"

I think the district court has interpreted this too far-reaching and beyond what is reasonable. He is expressing himself about Islam as a whole and is not targeting any specific ethnic group, but the court is interpreting it as if he is doing so indirectly, says Funcke.

In combination with the fact that Quran burnings have been used as an aggravating circumstance, he believes that the verdict is in line with blasphemy laws.

I sincerely hope that this will be appealed and that the court of appeal will correct the first charge. If it stands, we have in principle introduced a form of blasphemy legislation in Sweden.

It will become impossible to express oneself about Islam as an ideology in the strong way that he has done.

Directed contempt

Regarding the second charge, which concerns Paludan's statements about Arabs and Africans, Funcke has no objections to a guilty verdict.

There's no question about it. There's directed contempt towards specific, explicitly stated ethnic groups or people of a certain origin.

Paludan made the statements at two separate gatherings in Malmö in 2022. At one of the gatherings, he burned a Quran after wrapping it in bacon. He was also convicted of defamation in connection with one of the gatherings. The sentence is set to four months in prison.

Paludan has already announced that he will appeal the verdict.

Tags

Author

TTT
By TTEnglish edition by Sweden Herald, adapted for local and international readers

More news

Person Arrested After Alby Subway Shooting South of Stockholm
1 MIN READ

Person Arrested After Alby Subway Shooting South of Stockholm

Road Collapse in Årsta: Car Falls into Crack After Heavy Rainstorm
2 MIN READ

Road Collapse in Årsta: Car Falls into Crack After Heavy Rainstorm

Children Risk Lives for Status: Police Warn of Brutal Injuries
3 MIN READ

Children Risk Lives for Status: Police Warn of Brutal Injuries

Liberals' National Meeting on Sweden Democrats Sparks Political Debate
4 MIN READ

Liberals' National Meeting on Sweden Democrats Sparks Political Debate

Defence to Review Semiconductor Supply Vulnerabilities
1 MIN READ

Defence to Review Semiconductor Supply Vulnerabilities

Explosion in Nödinge Leads to Evacuation After Hazardous Object Found
1 MIN READ

Explosion in Nödinge Leads to Evacuation After Hazardous Object Found

Flooding on E4 in Härnösand Causes Major Traffic Disruptions
1 MIN READ

Flooding on E4 in Härnösand Causes Major Traffic Disruptions

Person Critically Injured in Höganäs Apartment Fire
1 MIN READ

Person Critically Injured in Höganäs Apartment Fire

Man Injured by 300 Kilo Cement Block in Vikbolandet Farm Accident
1 MIN READ

Man Injured by 300 Kilo Cement Block in Vikbolandet Farm Accident

Asphalt Cooker Explosion in Kungälv Sends One to Hospital
1 MIN READ

Asphalt Cooker Explosion in Kungälv Sends One to Hospital

Blood Moon to Grace Swedish Skies This Weekend
2 MIN READ

Blood Moon to Grace Swedish Skies This Weekend

Government Plans to End Restaurant Food Requirement by Next Summer
1 MIN READ

Government Plans to End Restaurant Food Requirement by Next Summer

Car and Train Collision in Skene Injures Two
1 MIN READ

Car and Train Collision in Skene Injures Two

Magnet Fishermen Discover Live Grenade in Helge River
1 MIN READ

Magnet Fishermen Discover Live Grenade in Helge River

Beware of Deceptive Mushrooms: Avoid These Common Mistakes
2 MIN READ

Beware of Deceptive Mushrooms: Avoid These Common Mistakes

Teen Detained in Connection to Kallhäll Double Murder
1 MIN READ

Teen Detained in Connection to Kallhäll Double Murder

Firefighter Injured in Fatal Accident Rescue Near Norrköping
1 MIN READ

Firefighter Injured in Fatal Accident Rescue Near Norrköping

Gällivare Hospital in Emergency Mode Due to Mobile Network Outage
1 MIN READ

Gällivare Hospital in Emergency Mode Due to Mobile Network Outage

Dad Misplaces Baby in Stroller Now Suspected of Crime
1 MIN READ

Dad Misplaces Baby in Stroller Now Suspected of Crime

Major Fire in Upplands Bro Leaves Dozens Homeless
2 MIN READ

Major Fire in Upplands Bro Leaves Dozens Homeless